Old Stove Pub
The Old Stove Pub is a Hamptons Classic Steakhouse. Originally opened in 1967 as a Pub, then in 1969 The Old Stove Pub transformed into a Greek Restaurant and Steakhouse. The Old Stove Pub has been closed for several years and completed extensive renovations and restoration. The process took over a year to complete, while also keeping much of the original detail and charm. Re-opened in July of 2020, the Old Stove Pub is now considered one of the best restaurants in the Hamptons, not only for the food, but for our friendly and welcoming service.
The Old Stove Pub returns to the Hamptons with its classic menu, some new additions, and SUSHI. Our Sushi Chef is a culinary and Sushi master, delivering not on some classic items but also creative additions.
We offer outdoor dining in our HUGE tent, front patio, dinner inside and a reduced capacity, and Bar Seating. There is TAKE OUT as well.
Dine Well. Be Safe and we look forward to seeing you in the near future.
Safety precautions
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Menu
Fantastic and fast!
Everything was very slow. Second round of drinks came when dinner was over. Appetizers took forever as did entrees. When entrees came, one entree was cold, another was raw and had to be sent back. Only one was prepared as requested.
Server was very nice and doing her beat but there was only one bartender for a huge crowd and obviously not enough kitchen help or servers.
Will not return even though the food is pretty good because high prices are not warranted by the service or the overall experience.
Always fun, consistent food quality and service and reservation availability! Can’t wait to try the new Manhattan location!
Very disappointed in the food. Bland. No presentation. Expensive for what it was
A bit noisy but otherwise a pretty space and warm staff. Food was great!
Great meal and service. Thanks
food and service were great.... didn't mind paying the price
Delicious meal & great service. Pleasant ambiance and festive atmosphere!
Hostess and waiter were friendly and professional. Portions are small and overpriced.
Beautiful outdoor setting with welcoming professional staff and very good food .. First time dining since it’s reopened and we will definitely be back!!
I enjoyed my meal, but I was really turned off that the waitstaff does not wear masks. The owner walks around to each table and says hello, also WITHOUT a mask. Unreal.
Owner did a fabulous job of scrambling with a very very short staff. always a memorable night and one of the best outdoor areas in the Hamptons
Good food, nice ambiance, pleasant service
We had a confirmed reservation…we arrived and the restaurant was closed. Fine weather was an issue in the morning. Someone could have cancelled the res.
We were pleasantly surprised that the Old Stove Pub not only kept some if its predecessor's unusual charm, but also the ability to make a tremendous steak
Perfect evening out with delicious food and excellent service.
Nice surprise for an ole favorite that I have never tried.
Strong Recommendation
Not worth the price . They changed $35 for eggplant with a spoon of rice and a few lentils. They had the audacity to call me 3 hours later and accuse me of not paying the bill, to then turn around and say never mind we found it .. never again spent 405.00 and was looking for a drive thru after ..
Great food, great cocktails, the filet mignon is awesome
Great dinner and friendly service. Lamb chops and filet were great. Au poivre sauce was perfectly true to the French recipe. Fries and Brussels sprouts were terrific. Looking forward to going back.
No servers wearing masks. Food served cold.
Food was excellent-grilled branzino, Greek salad, very fresh! Would def go back to this laid back outdoor spotz
Wow. The best Greek salad ever. Everything else was amazing as well. We had the lamb and the Branzino both were perfectly cooked and the taste was tops! The sides of corn and potatoes a la old stove were AMAZING! Go here.
The food and ambiance were wonderful. Love the outdoor space and the service was excellent. Just very pricey!
Lovely dinner! Sat outside on patio. Beautiful live piano music. An 85 degree night but idyllic breezy setting underneath the trees. Started with trio dioper. Delish! Pita bread warm and fluffy. Branzino perfect! Cauliflower side shared very tasty. Lamb chops very good too! Barbara our server was perfect! Attentive and friendly. We will be back!
Thank You ! We all work very hard to deliver the service and the quality you would deserve.
We liked everything, except their tipping policy. It already is an expensive restaurant, but automatic tipping on the bill...tax included?? Paying tip on the tax!?
A little much.
We will be back, but alert to this policy.
Thank you for coming and we enjoy serving you. I apologize for any confusion. Our system allows ours guests to choose the tip amount so you do have a choice and you also custom tip allowing you to enter whatever amount you are comfortable with. When you decide on percentage its added to the bill but not on the tax. The tip charged is only on the cost of the meal. We can provide you with a copy of the receipt if you would like. Please feel free to call us, and we can email it to you.
$50 sushi roll at a Greek restaurant, not worth it
Hello and thank you for giving us the opportunity to serve you. The Old Stove Pub was a Greek restaurant for years however we are more of Mediterranean restaurant now although we do have some of the old menu items. We do have a sushi bar however none of our rolls are $50. You can get 2 choice rolls for $34 and we only use the highest quality products on all our items. Our menu is online on our website. If we made an error on your bill I would be happy to fix it or refund. Thank you.
The environment is delightful. The outdoor dining is beautifully set up with linen table cloths and attractive silverware. The menu is extensive and there was live entertainment. I had branzino for a main course along with spinach. My friend had the lamb chops which she enjoyed a lot. She also had French Fries. For dessert we shared a chocolate and vanilla ice cream dish.
Table cloth was filthy. Server was pleasant. Food was mediocre.
I apologize that the cloth was dirty. Our linens are professionally cleaned and are only used once. Its definitely an oversight on our end. We are all trying our very best to deliver a great dining experience not only with proper service but fresh and high quality meals. Thank you for coming.
The food was delicious and the staff was working their butts off to make everyone happy. We understand that ALL restaurants are understaffed (thanks Covid) but it did not ruin our evening one bit. We had a great experience! Will be coming back soon to enjoy the awesome food and ambiance :)
We thought the food and menu was better this summer than last summer so that was a plus and the ambience is nice with different areas to sit both inside and outside. But it's an expensive place, especially the sushi menu so be prepared for that. Lucy who at the front of the house and was there last summer is a standout employee and always very pleasant so that's another plus.
What a beautiful place!!! The food was delicious and it came out promptly. The server very nice and attentive.I was a bit concerned about the prices because of some reviews but our dinner was priced as should be and well worth it. No different than any other restaurant of this caliber such as Bilboque, Sant Ambroeus, Pierres... And the wine prices are less. We will be back.
Thank you for your review. Its exactly what I want our guests to experience. We do our very best all the time. Come back soon.
Absolutely AMAZING atmosphere! My husband and I had a great time. Delicious food, sensational staff and beautiful service. I’m definitely looking forward for the next time.
Food delicious - great outdoor dining. -wonderful vibe and service and friendly owner !
We ate outdoors, which was very nice. The tables were spaced apart and nice sized. The food was very good and the service was excellent. There was adequate parking. Overall this is good place to go for an enjoyable dinner.
Poor quality food and over priced. Waitstaff was attentive . However, they did acknowledge that I did not eat my meal due to poor quality. Yet, I was still charged for it.
So sorry for your experience. I am proud of our team and we do our very best to deliver high quality meals. We only buy the best, and the freshest foods available and they are more expensive now than in the past. We are priced the same as many other Hampton restaurants and we are less expensive than many (granted more expensive than others as well) I do try and stop at every table during dinner service and I must apologize that I may not have stopped at your table. I would have resolved it.
Great food, lovely ambiance outside, extremely noisy on porch, felt service was excellent but rushed.
Food quality was mixed at best, prices very high relative to portions (esp. sushi menu), wine markups are excessive, even for the Hamptons.
The atmosphere is the only thing appealing about this place. Our server was also very nice.
I read all of the other low reviews and agree with them all. The grilled octopus is small and thin, and the sushi is 6 pieces to a roll unless stated otherwise.
The tartar is a mix of 3 different fish and is extremely fishy.
The scallops were a nice size but completely over cooked and RUBBER.
Honestly paying half the price we paid for dinner, it still wouldn't have been worth it.
Don't waste your time with this place. The food at World Pie and Bobby Vans is way better.
Excellent all around
Would never go back! Service was horrible. Food took over 2 hours to bring out an appetizer and we never got our drinks. No apologies and the owner was a complete jerk who didn’t care that everyone eating in his restaurant was not happy due to the service. We were seated by the kitchen and saw them serving food on top of the garage bin which is not only gross but unsanitary!
FAQs
Old Stove Pub offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 537-3300.
Old Stove Pub is rated 4.3 stars by 167 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.
