Nourish - Westin Indianapolis

We went on Valentines Day, staying at the Westin it was super convenient and they offered a prefixe menu of a Walnut Salad, Steak & Lobster and Dessert. The old Shula’s steakhouse vibe feels “half” remodeled and by our 8:15 reservation, we were one of maybe ten tables seated in a very large restaurant...That made the atmosphere a little underwhelming.

Food was GREAT. The salads were big fresh and flavorful, Steaks cooked perfectly and a risotto / asparagus was prepared and presented perfectly. Lobster was meh, but I’m not a big lobster fan to begin with. None of these reached the level of the mousse. It was rich, creamy and accented with peanut butter cups crushed topping and strawberries. All kidding aside, best dessert I’ve had in Indy. Ever. -

For two of us to get a bottle of wine, salad, surf & turf, dessert and not feel rushed or delayed by service and a fantastic meal for under $160...that’s hard to beat.

I’m only worried that if they were this slow on Valentine’s Day that they may not be around for long.

Parking is valet, but I hope it’s not the $17 self park rate.

Went with my wife for Valentine’s Day. I got the Ribeye, which was $35. I have had better steaks at Western Sizzlin’! This was only the second time in my life I’ve not finished a steak... it was that bad. All the food is carted up to the second floor from the hotel kitchen so don’t expect anything to be hot. The only redeeming aspect of this place is the view. Otherwise, get your “nourish”ment someplace else.

I had set up a meeting with several of my suppliers in town for an industry meeting. Everything was 1st Class! Service, presentation, and quality of all dishes ordered were 5 stars all the way!

Overall food choices and quality are excellent, especially for those interested in healthier fare than the usual downtown Indianapolis restaurant experience. It’s not a steak house nor Italian style nor fast food. As advertised it’s contemporary American but with more and healthier options for non-meat-eaters.

Expensive buffet for what was offered - what was there was average.

Horrible server...manager did nothing but cover for him

Server was inattentive and seemed very busy although the restaurant wasn’t busy at all. Portions were very very small and flavorless. Would not return.

We were in Indianapolis for a large convention and the restaurant was ill equipped for the crowds that they were aware were coming. We made a reservation and waited over an hour for the food even though the restaurant was half empty. When my salad arrived, the chicken was not cooked and looked absolutely disgusting. I sent it back and they didn’t charge me for the dish. I heard other people sending their food back as well. Very disappointing

We made an OpenTable reservation at Nourish - Westin Indianapolis for 7:45pm. We arrived at 7:35 and were seated early, but told that our server wouldn't be available until 7:45 which was fine with us. The server did not come to our table until 8:15pm and we did not receive our drinks until 8:40pm, even after repeatedly letting them know our party had to leave by a specific time. Our food came out and we only had 10 minutes to actually eat before we had to leave to a group activity appointment. Food was just OK, service was terrible. They shouldn't advertise to large parties if they cannot accommodate them in a timely fashion.