New York Pasta Garden
The fresh seafood and friendly staff will keep you coming back for more! We offer a full bar with an array of frozen tropical drinks and a great wine list. We strive to have something on our menu for every palette and dedicate ourselves to make your experience both memorable and delightful.
Food was ok, not bad but not overwhelmingly great. Server was attentive.
Some of the best food we have ever had!!! Highly recommend!!!
Food excellent. Hospitality superb. Can sit inside or out.
We were visiting Key West last week and decided to try the NY Pasta Garden. Food was great and sitting outside was wonderful. We had a rooster keep us company. He got so comfortable that he settled in a fluff under a chair immediately next to us. Just wonderful.
We’ll be back the next time we are in Kay West. We recommend it highly to all. Joan and Randy
Waiter took 1/2 hr to come to table / dropped off a drink we never saw him again / heard he passed out / pouring rain / moved inside / nobody came to help us / I asked about food / they served it cold / gave us wrong check / nitemare
We always have a good meal at NY Pasta; so much so that we return once each year. Food is good and priced well. Service is decent.
I made a reservation noting it was our anniversary, but nothing was said. Server was very forgetful and slow. Ladies restroom out of order.
We did not care for our food. The service was really good.
We arrived 30 minutes ready with a party of 7, so we expected to wait- but they were ready for us. The kids menu is very limited so if you have picky eaters feed them before you come. The outside dining was perfect for our dinner.
We often stop here when we visit Key West. The food and service was excellent.
Great service . Our waiter who used to live in Panama City was awesome. Keep up the good work
Bday dinner was great.
Gross. Bread that was just out of oven was hard. Tourist trap.
Generous pours of wine! Good portion size and fast service. Nice atmosphere outside.
We sat outside, the staff was beyond friendly/happy. Made us feel very welcome; Fletcher, our waiter was superb. Food was excellent, from appetizer, entree and dessert. We will definitely enjoy back!
One of our regular spots. Always dependably delicious. We are angry though at the condo association in Duval Square. For years and years one of the highlights here was eating with the fantastic parrots doing their thing in the trees on the patio. It was so cool to being visitors down for that experience. Anyway shout out to Jeannette for being her wonderful self. She will also help you get your parry catered at a very reasonable price!!
Great food and fabulous service! Restaurant ambiance is nothing to write home about...but food makes up for it
We were seated outside but it took a long time for a waiter to come and even take a drink order, and the place wasn’t even busy. However, the maitre d’ apologized and gave us a complimentary artichoke appetizer, which was delicious. Prices are great and food pretty good, but the Caesar salad wasn’t great at all. Probably wouldn’t visit again but it was okay for one dinner.
Lovely setting. Nice option on KW for families. Good pasta, large portions. Service was excellent.
The outside setting is wonderful. The service was rather slow and the server was not very attentive. The food was average. Was certainly nothing spectacular but was good.
We shared a delicious meal on the patio. It could not have been more perfect. The service was great too. We are in Key West for a week but we plan to revisit this one ... just that good. Plus, very generous wine pours.
Excellent food., nice outdoor atmosphere, good for families... groups
Great pour of wine!!
Terrific food, excellent wine and large portions of both. Definitely go here!
Excellent pasta. Great Shrimp and scallops dish in sherry cream sauce. Andrew provided very good service. Generous wine servings.
Our server MrFletcher was very accommodating & knowledgeable about our wine selections & food pairing. Service was impeccable
We would highly recommend for a great dining experience.
Went to NY pasta garden for wedding reception & fletcher couldn’t have been a better host. The entire party loved the food & the ambiance
The garlic bread is wonderful and the glasses of wine are huge.
Although our server was good and accommodating, the food was not so good.
Much confusion in getting everyone seated
We waited almost 30 minutes with a reservation
Food was excellent. Wine pours very generous. Our only concern was two chickens decided to roost over our heads and we’re knocking down pine needles and other debris onto the table and into our glasses. But we slid our tables back a foot or so and we were fine. We’d go back.
First time there. Everything was excellent. Bread delicious. Had the Gorgonzola chicken-excellent. Will definitely go there again on my next visit.
Delicious food. Great service. VERY generous pour for wine! Away from the craziness of Duval St which is a nice break. Would definitely recommend and visit again.
Manager did not wear mask and was rude when pointing it out.
We sat outside, decent ambience. Wild chickens and roosters running around. Apparently, they are protected by law (?) so they run free and literally roost in the trees above your table.
Huge menu - many options but just ok food. Dishes were very saucy and cheesy, which is often a good thing; our dishes were overly so. Would try a different Italian next time.
The food was excellent, the ambiance calming disturbed only by the occasional crowing of a rooster😁. But the server went above and beyond. We didn’t think it was beer and wine only and my husband ordered a vodka. The server got it for him from the next restaurant. He has French onion soup, I had the fried artichoke bites. Both excellent. He had veal Marsala (very good) and I had the lobster ravioli (scrumptious). I never have ravioli but this sounded so good and I’m glad I did. Highly recommend
Pasta was very good. Veal was fatty
Probably one of the best Italian meals I have ever had. Very generous wine pours. Friendly family atmosphere. Quiet for conversation. I will definitely return!
Paul was an excellent server - took great care and paid attention to everything I needed. Very polite and prompt.
Excellent meal. Severe was awesome. Throughly enjoyed.
Great food and great service!!! Highly recommended!
New York Pasta Garden is rated 4.4 stars by 201 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.