Mitchell's Fish Market private rooms are available for any occasion! Work one-on-one with your Private Event Manager to create a truly customized affair. To host your event in one of our private dining rooms, contact us today!View Private Dining Details
See availability for bonus point tables
Daily 4:00PM - 6:00PM 8:00PM - 10:00PM
Restaurant was basically empty, but we were placed next to a large group of loud people in the center of the restaurant and couples who came in after were placed in quiet booths with a beautiful view.
I always love going to Mitchell’s in Carmel, Indiana. My date absolutely loved going here following our trip to the New Port Aquarium! Some of the best food around! The server was professional despite her disinterest in serving us...
Our waiter mumbled the entire evening and we could not understand anything he said. There were 4 of us ; one had the chef’s choice salmon bourbon glaze and it was delicious, one had the Shanghai shrimp, scallops, and salmon - it was ok but did have a couple stems of something that tasted like pine sol., one had the 8oz filet medium rare that was very dry with a crisp outside, and lastly I had an 8oz filet ordered medium rare with potatoe wedges and broccoli. I ordered the broccoli to be well steamed. My whole plate came out well done and burnt. Manager fixed and brought me the wrong food to replace it. Husband had lobster mac n cheese that had the shell in it and a Bloody Mary that was too spicy to drink with no alcohol. Needless to say, 40th Birthday dinner ruined and we WILL NOT GO BACK.
Just a very nice meal. We love mitchells
Service was slow at times and the hostess seemed as if our presence was a nuisance.
Amazing as always. Thank you for making a night out with my parents a great time.
Excellent service. We had a party of 10 and our server was on top of everything!!! Food was delicious. Thanks Mitchell's!
I didn’t realize how good the food would be. Every part of the meal was on point!!
We were here to celebrate my birthday. No mention of this was made when we arrived nor by the server. We mentioned it to our server and he said “should I do a little song and dance?” I guess I was expecting at least a happy birthday from someone at this location.
Also, I had requested a seat by a window and they took us to a table by the bar. I know it’s based on availability but my expectation was for a seat by a window in the main dining area. There were no more tables by a window in that area. That was why I had made a reservation!
Overall, the food was what I expect from a Mitchell’s but the service was not.
Very nice place for friends get together, good food and good services.
Slow service. Restaurant wasn’t even full but we waited a long time to get drinks and our food. Hostess was telling us that they are understaffed. I would expect better service considering the prices they charge. I don’t recommend it! There are plenty of fish restaurants nearby with better food and service!
Food good not great. Service WONDERFUL. Very overpriced!!
It was a long time since the last time I went to Mitchell's @ Newport. Despite being Valentine's Day and the expected delays in service, the food was top notch delicious. I love this restaurant and will consider coming back soon. Fish/seafood products are superb !
My husband and I really enjoyed our meals! He had blackened mahi mahi and I had the fried fish. Portions were generous and delicious. We both added goat cheese salads to our meals and they were wonderful! The downside of the visit is that this was Valentine's Day and we were seated in a comfortable booth in the bar area, which became quite crowded and noisy after a large group came in to congregate at the bar. Many were standing and it felt like being on an airplane where people are lined up in the aisle looming over those seated. Not exactly romantic, lol! Our waiter was very nice and attentive, explained menu and specials very well. He didn't bring my husband's salad when he brought mine, and I believe he actually didn't hear him order it because of the ambient noise level. It was quickly corrected and as I said before, the food was very good! We will know next time to request a table NOT in the bar area for a more relaxed experience.
It was Valentine’s Day, so seemed like it was s little mite costly, but good! Server was excellent!
Had a fabulous meal. Even had to add three on to our reservation and were accommodated quickly even though it was a very busy night. Wonderful staff and food. Our out of town guests raved about the meal and service. Thanks!
Great evening, great service, delicious food and we had a wonderful time.
The lighting was dim so it was hard to see the menu. the servers were attentive but not smothering. Overall everything was good but nothing was amazing
This was my birthday dinner. I chose the chef's special (salmon with bourbon sauce). It was excellent! The root vegetables were roasted just right and I ate everything on my plate! My son had a pasta dish with seafood that he loved and my husband always goes for the seafood platter. Both were also very good!
Our server was very friendly and attentive. That always makes it a better experience!
We will be back again!
Very disappointed the the food. Wait staff was attentive, but like robots with no personality. Other than the view, it was all disappointing.
The fish was cooked deliciously with two perfect sides of vegetables and potatoes. If I had to make one recommendation it would be to be able to customize the sides (i.e. no butter).
Very good service, great tasting food. Music was maybe a bit too loud, table lights need dimmed down, and was a bit chilly inside. Overall we loved our time there and would go back again.
Wonderful restaurant. Some of the best tasting seafood I have ever eaten from a restaurant that wasn't near the ocean.
My spouse and I met another couple at Mitchell's for dinner prior to a movie. Nice atmosphere, decent food and our waitress did an extremely good job.
It wasn't busy on Saturday night, which seemed odd. The spicy shrimp appetizer and the blue cheese Iceburg lettuce salad were excellent. But the cod was okay. The stuffed flounder was very small. The potatoes were okay. I think for the price, it should all be better than okay. Not going to be in a huge rush to go back.
The calamari appetizer was disappointing -- it was dry and overcooked. The rest of our meal was very enjoyable. My husband had the cedar plank salmon and he said it was very good. I had the grilled onion mahi mahi and it was delicious -- the cauliflower and brussel sprouts were a wonderful accompaniment. Nice wine list.
Birthday. Friendly service.
Very much enjoyed our meal!
There was a water pipe break that occurred right before we arrived so restaurant had to close
Great ambiance and decor. Food was great as well! Waitress was top notchb
My husband and I came here for an early New Year's Eve dinner. I often order the cedar planked salmon (which I highly recommend), but on this evening they offered shrimp & lobster stuffed sea bass with redskin mashed potatoes and sauteed asparagus, which was amazing! They also have a good selection of affordable wines. The only disappointment was our entrees arrived before our salads. The entrees were removed so we could enjoy our salads, but reappeared a few minutes later, so we felt rushed.
We were very disappointed in the food. The fish didn't seem fresh (sea bass and flounder), and had an odd taste. Too bad as this used to be our favorite place.
Outstanding service with great food. Our server Micheal was beyond belief - friendly and full of great recommendations. Beautiful city view from a nice warm booth on a snowy day.
Christmas dinner. Mitchell’s was out of everything that we really wanted and what we wound up with was just adequate.
We made reservations for Christmas dinner. We had a minimal wait but it took awhile to have a waiter arrive at our table. We both ordered a beer and had to ask three times in order to get it. To add insult to injury, the beer was flat when it finally arrived. We both ordered New England Clam Chowder and when our waiter arrived he brought us Lobster Bisque. He then proceeded to tell us they were out of Chowder and this is all they had. We sent it back. We ordered the fried shrimp which was ok but the French fries were cold. Bad service, bad waiter, so-so food. We won’t be back.
Busy on Christmas evening, a
On Christmas Day, service and food were not up to Mitchell's usual standard. All four entrees were cold, and the scallops were tough. Long lag between courses. Will chalk this up to the holiday, but still disappointing after coming here on Christmas for four years.
A party of ten on Christmas Day; we had a very good time and overall had a very pleasant experience. The service was just a touch slow but friendly and never "sit and wait". The place was full and I'm guessing they were dealing with some staff no shows. The food was good and we enjoyed the dinner with family.
Arrived a few minutes early, and was seated immediately. Appetizers were tasty. Excellent hot fresh bread. Entrées took a long, very long, time to be served. Was told there was a lot of deep fryer orders all at once. Server provided us a complementary shrimp cocktail appetizer because of this. All in all a nice dinner on Christmas day.
Pleasantly surprised. Came here for Christmas lunch and truly enjoyed it!