Mitchell's Fish Market - Cleveland
Book your next event with us
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
served grilled, broiled or blackened over your choice of spinach or caesar salad
Cold Water Lobster Tails
mashed redskin potatoes, sauteed asparagus
Gourmet Steak Burger*
applewood smoked bacon, smoked gouda, creminis, tabasco mash remoulade
We have always enjoyed eating here, and we’re glad to see it is as good as always following Covid Lockdown. The food was tasty and healthy, and the service attentive and helpful. It was a fun evening out with friends.
If you want to pay for a plate of potatoes , then go here. Otherwise small portions of food. Extremely disappointed.
The trout was delicious. The smashed potatoes were dry and not warm enough. The asparagus spears were very al dente and needed some sort of sauce.
Service was excellent however the food was lukewarm, very small portions & not good.
I have been to Mitchell’s many times. However this time the food was truly subpar. I often get the crab cakes and did so this time. There was mostly filler and very little lump crab meat and the taste was poor.. In addition, my smashed potatoes were dry and cold. Our server worked hard, but the kitchen was very slow. We won’t be going back especially for the cost.
Greeted by grumpy hostess, food overpriced for what was provided. Service was fantastic but nothing else was.
Food quality took a dive in the last year. The chowder was like paste and I couldn’t really eat it. They did not ask we why. I had salmon for lunch and it was mediocre. The ice tea was fine. The waitress was nice and earnest. The hostess was almost hostile.
The portion seem to get smaller every time we go.....
The soup could of been hotter
The chocolate cake dessert was outstanding!!
Our service was outstanding, and the food delicious. Especially appreciated our server as she ensured no glass was empty, and our check was delivered quickly (we don't like to linger) but there was no pressure to leave.
The food tasted good but was not hot. Luke warm. The scampis were shrimp. The quality of the good is very good. Need to work on their temps.
If it’s a drive for you to go to Mitchell’s probably not worth it.
Food was amazing. Excellent service
Usually we thoroughly enjoy this restaurant, but I think they were off their game because of Easter. Their lobster tails are always great, the scallops perfect, but yesterday was disappointing.
Cooks in kitchen very loud but food and service was great!
The Antarctic salmon was superb. We had never had salmon from that region before. Can highly recommend it! And, the Maryland crab cakes are always excellent. Thank you!
Understaffed and overpriced. Food tasted ok.
The server was nice and friendly. Unfortunately, she was the only one working and seemed a bit overwhelmed.
We had heard that Mitchell's has gone downhill, but we hadn't been there in so long we decided to give it a try. Boy were the negative reviews spot on. This is a very expensive restaurant and the food is just not good. Scallops were spongy and tasteless, snapper was undercooked and equally tasteless, and portions weren't great either. Then you think about the prices and it's easy to see why this place is in trouble. Avoid it until they go out of business and a new place takes this spot.
Mitchell’s consistently has very good food. Staff is knowledgeable and helpful. Will return again and again!
We were looking forward to going, as we used to have a Mitchell’s in Glenview Illinois and remember loving it. Unfortunately, the meal did not live up to our memories or expectations. It was just ok. Not nearly as good or generous as we remember. And, the shark fin dessert is no longer on the menu. We were disappointed.
The food was good, service was good. Drinks from the bar were slow to arrive.
Excellent food and service. I would prefer different/smaller pots for crab legs and they use to pre-crack them. The bread was really sour but overall good food and Service. Will return soon.That parmesean cream sauce..yum
We came to celebrated two birthdays. We had a wonderful time with excellent service, delicious food and ice cream and candles for our two birthday people. Mitchell's is our special place to celebrate events in our lives and they do not disappoint.
The food was fine. Nothing special by any means. I had a stuffed cod entree. Small piece but tasty. Portions were fairly small except for the calamari appetizer, which was enough to share. Although it was not the appetizer we ordered. We kept it regardless, as not to overwhelm the kitchen. I had seen a few other tables complaining that evening and I did not find it necessary to switch it out since we liked this one too.
The salad was good. Service was also fine. Nice server who appeared to have several tables. They did a good job at social distancing the tables. I did not feel that I was too close to any table in particular. So, this part was good. However, the tables that were not in use close to us were really dusty and appeared dirty. Not good at all to look at that while you are eating. UGH! Very surprising. They should have been wiped down regardless of not being in use for 6 months as the manager(?) informed me. Also, we were celebrating a birthday and not once did the server say HB to the bday boy even though I did indicate it was a special occasion. We selected this restaurant because we were looking for seafood. We have been here a few times prior over the years. This was definitely our last visit to this restaurant for sure. It has gone significantly downhill in many aspects.
Hadn't been to Mitchell's for a while. Actually, haven't been anywhere for a while. Food was goof. She had the salmon. I had the shrimp and chips. One disappointment. What happened to the Sharkfin Pie? Bring it back!
A quiet dinner with friends on a Thursday evening. Delightful to be out to dinner again.
We were seated away from other diners and our waitress was most accommodating.
Highly recommend Mitchell’s Fish Market for the food and value
As usual. Great food and service rep Rachel is awesome - we always ask for her.
We have been to Mitchell’s several times now over the last year (4, if memory serves, it’s an hour drive for us), and each time has been excellent. We have had nothing we didn’t enjoy. The servers are always attentive and helpful; the food is neither bland nor pretentious. They trust that well-executed dishes with good ingredients will speak for themselves. We will be back!
Had a good time out for the first time in a long time.
Waiter either did not understand the instruction or did not listen to what we wanted.
Food came hot but not the way we asked for it.
Excellent food and service. Could not decide what to order because everything sounded great. Shanghai Sea bass amazing!!
Great service. Our waiter Edward was friendly, attentive and made some great recommendations.
My husband and I were out for dinner. I had the salad and sea bass and he had the shrimp cocktail and Shanghai salmon. Both were excellent. Spacing of tables felt very comfortable while we were there.
We were seated in the bar and it was nice and quiet. Our food was ok, the mashed potatoes were super salty and not creamy at all.
The food was mediocre at best. Calamari was flavorless and cold. There was nothing good on the seafood trio. The crab cake was cold an soggy, The shrimp were over cooked, extremely dry and chewy, the salmon was ok and the broccoli was mushy as if it had been sitting in a steamer all day. The only thing I can say was good was the lobster bisque, but I’m not sure how the kitchen staff could mess that up as it most likely came from a food service supplier and it just needed to be warmed up. The restaurant itself was drab and in desperate need of a good cleaning and update. Save your money.
I liked the fish sandwich I had there recently. It seemed to be baked rather than fried. It was cod with a light coating of breading. Another thing I love there is the sourdough French bread.
For the first time in a YEAR, I went to dinner!! I am so pleased I chose Mitchell’s, from the time we were greeted by Gwendolyn, pampered by Rachel and until Saysha took pictures to add to our memories as we left, it was truly a pleasurable evening. The food was FANTASTICALLY YUMMERISH. Couple the food with Rachel’s attention to EVERY DETAIL (by memory!!!) and Saysha’s willing helpful spirit, it was a night to remember. Thank you Mitchell’s we appreciate all you did for us. We can put this one in the books as a good time!!
The service was great. Rachael took care of us very well. I will come back again.
Food was good server was nice but the service was slow at times.
Tried to seat us in the busiest pathway, near the kitchen - even though we had a reservation! Hostess moved us to bar area instead. Waitress took our order without writing it down. When she repeated it to us, she had details mixed up. We corrected her & she placed our order. Another couple came in shortly after us & ordered with another waitress. Their meals came & they were nearly finished when ours finally arrived. My meal was accurate - my husband’s was not. I had ordered scallops, he ordered salmon. She brought 2 scallop dinners. No surprise since the waitress wrote nothing down. I finished my meal before my husband’s finally arrived. She comped my husband on his drink, but this whole dining event was clearly not enjoyable.
Disappointing. Slow service, looked like pre-packaged fish most likely frozen in the past. So many better places for the price. No wonder they had time slots available in a Friday night. Avoid place. Not worth the money.
Our server Regina was excellent! She was knowledgeable and professional. The Clam Chowder was delicious! Everyone enjoyed their entrees which was served piping hot. We even got desert. We have a very nice dining experience. 😋
You can order delivery directly from Mitchell's Fish Market - Cleveland using the Order Online button. Mitchell's Fish Market - Cleveland also offers delivery in partnership with Postmates and Uber Eats. Mitchell's Fish Market - Cleveland also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (216) 765-3474.
Mitchell's Fish Market - Cleveland is rated 4.2 stars by 2753 OpenTable diners.
Mitchell's Fish Market - Cleveland does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://www.landrysinc.com/giftcards/default.asp.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.