Michaelangelo's Italian Bistro
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Pasta a la Carbonara
Diced Ham, Peas, Bacon, Mushrooms with Linguine and Parmesan Cream Sauce
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Marinara or Meat Sauce
Great food, reasonably priced. Great service. I would recommend reservations as it seemed to be a popular place.
Smaller sized serving of lasagna than the last time we were here. Was later in the evening last time, though, so maybe that had something to do with it. Food is always pretty dependable.
Hi, Swanney. We appreciate the rating, and are glad we could provide you with a positive experience!
We came for a birthday dinner with our two small children. Everything was delicious, fast and the atmosphere was great!
Restaurant did NOT have our reservation, which I made on Open Table. We ordered off the Devour Indy menu. 2 meals for $35. The salad was Olive Garden quality. The breaded cheese sticks were huge and amazing. I would recommend ordering those again. Fettucine Alfredo sauce was burned and made with powdered Parmesan cheese. Lasagna again, Olive Garden quality. Dessert was a frozen cheesecake. Nothing great. Our waiter was non-attentive. We had to reach out to him several times. I'm not sure if he was new or just not a good waiter. We were over charged for our meal, by $35, so that needed to be corrected. I did not eat any of my pasta, not did I ask for a box. He did not ask us if everything was good. My husband did not finish his lasagna and did not ask for a box. Our waiter, brought two boxes. He also did not clear away any dishes during our meal. Appetizer/salad plates remained on table, as well as the bread basket, salad, appetizer platter and dessert plate. Our table was crowded with dirty dishes thru most of our meal.
With so many Italian options in the area (Noblesville/Westfield), I would not recommend or return to Michaelangelos. Honestly, I would recommend Olive Garden over this place.
good food ,right price in neighborhood eat local in support
This was our first time at Michaelangelo's and it won't be our last. The food was really tasty and the service was couldn't have been better. Our server was very attentive to our needs. The atmosphere was nice and you could actually talk across the table with some romantic music in the background. My wife commented that this was her new most favorite place to eat.
Dependable dining at a reasonable price. We've never had a bad meal, but some have been especially better than others. Service is good! We will continue to visit, and recommend.
Had a lovely dinner out with our grandchildren, after singing Christmas carols outside of a nearby nursing home. It was the perfect food for cold kids and grands. We love the kids menu and my grandson loves to build his own pasta.
I loved it. The food was absolutely amazing. The staff was very friendly and prompt.
Can go there for anything! Absolutely love this place and their food is SO good!!!
We celebrated a Friend and Coworker’s Birthday! The food items we chose were all delicious and the serving size was more than enough- we all took leftovers 😁
Service was great and attentive and friendly!
Super enjoyed our meal! Tuscany Alfredo was simply marvelous! We’ll be back!!
Very fine rustic Italian food in a modest restaurant. The service was impeccable. I can see dining here often for comfort food.
The waitress never repeated what we ordered and got half of our orders wrong, then disappeared for our entire meal, never asked if we wanted desert (even though we didn't), and then never gave us our card back after she ran the bill. We celebrated a Birthday dinner, and I left feeling embarrassed that's where I made the reservation!
I made reservations for 8 people several days before we were coming to dine. When we got there we were told there would be an hour wait. We feel that was unacceptable given the fact that we had reservations. This wasn't even on a weekend. We left and went somewhere else. They have lost our business.
This is our third time at this wonderful restaurant. The food is outstanding (true Italian tastes). This is a restaurant that is a must when looking for Italian dinning!!!!!!!!
Went for a birthday dinner with my family. Decided to get a bottle of red wine, for some reason it was chilled? We all ordered our entrees and I ordered an appetizer. The waitress repeated the order back correctly, but never brought out the appetizer. At least it wasn’t on the bill. Not in a huge rush to go back, I can say I’ve been there.
My daughter and I agree that Michaelangelos alfredo sauce is the best in the metro Indy area. We love the entrees and the salad alike! Thank you for incredible service despite it being only the second day of work for our waitress. We cannot wait to come again.
Great food, great service. 5/5
Food was wonderful and service was exceptional as always.
It's always a great way to end the day. Food is always great!
Good food, good service, great value
Our first counter with Michelangelo’s Italian bistro.
Overall we had mixed feelings about our dining experience tonight.
The restaurant is nicely designed. The wait staff was good. Our dining outside experience was positive. The restaurant was very COVID-19 compliant.The only disappointment was the food.
We ordered calamari as an appetizer and found that it was just OK. It was served with a marinara sauce that was very thick and almost like a pizza sauce. We both ordered seafood entrées that were served with a complimentary house salad. I specifically asked that the salad be lightly dressed, but it was oozing in dressing. It was nothing special.
We both had seafood entrees that were served very dry. I had Lemon Caper Salmon and my friend had the Branzino. The salmon had some capers on top and a lemon wedge – no hint of lemon flavoring at all. The Branzino was served with from chopped asparagus. Both had very lackluster presentation..
So given that the main reason you come to restaurant for the food – we thought this was the only thing that let us down.
Unfortunately it’s doubtful that we will return.
I don't particularly enjoy Italian food...my wife does. This place IS the exception. Food here is REALLY GOOD!!! This is my favorite local Italian cuisine restaurant. Marvelous salads service was excellent, and the main dishes I will come back for....
We experienced great food and service, very clean environment, social distancing, definitely felt comfortable with precautions being taken.
Great service, hot tasty food!
We sampled a little bit of everything off the menu including the dessert menu. Everything was made perfectly and tasted incredible. We will be back soon as there are plenty of options on the menu we want to try another time.
Always great food, friendly service, and good value.
Everything on the menu is Great. I especially love the Pasta Carbonara. The bread sticks are always warm, soft, and buttery. The salads are always fresh and crisp and the soups are hearty and flavorful. The service is always good.
Michelangelo's Italian Bistro is a wonderful little jewel in the heart of Nobelsville. A small restaurant with a big heart and excellent food. I would recommend this quality establishment.
Always a great meal!!
Food was so good and our server, Austin was not only attentive, but a good sport. I recommend it to anyone who wants a great Italian meal, convenient location and casual atmosphere
Service and the food were was outstanding.
Very nice place, in what looks like a former Pizza Hut, the interior is surprisingly nice, and the food is very good. We would come back here, really nice place.
Michaelangelo’s was a very nice restaurant. Our server was very attentive and complimented our manners. The food was delicious. My husband said his Stromboli sandwich was better than any other one he’s had before. We had the breaded mozzarella appetizers and expected sticks but theses were actual slices. The menu is very large. All in all the restaurant is one that we’d visit again.
Food was great. Server was very nice but spread a little thin and didn’t always have the ability to get drink refills when needed.
Went for Devour Indy and had a great time. Food was great and the devor menu was a really good deal!
Always super good - our family loves it! It's our favorite Italian restaurant, by far!
I was so happy to finally have found delicious Italian food at a great price. :)
Nice meal; a little pricey given the ambiance
Michaelangelo's Italian Bistro offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (317) 773-6066.
Michaelangelo's Italian Bistro is rated 4.3 stars by 119 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.