Michael Anthony's Cucina Italiana

Great place with better food.

Excellent night in the market area with our friends and neighbors! Our server was awesome, Elijah came out and chatted, and it was overall a wonderful evening. Thanks much!

Mud say - the food was fantastic. However for 26.95 it was a very tiny portion which was disappointing. Other than that the food / service was great.

We had a very attentive waiter and our service was impeccable. Food was great and so was the wine selection.

The service was fantastic
The food was flavorful

Fantastic food and wine. Great service. Great for family dinner or romantic dinner. Lobster pasta was the best I ever had. The kind of place the locals go so glad a local recommended it to us. Tucked away in a shopping center but close to Coligny and Sea Pines. We plan to go again when we are on the island. Stacy

Everything on the menu looks great and the veal I got was great. And a wonderful pinenut salad.

Wonderful New Years Eve!

We have been returning to Michael Anthony’s Cucina for years. The food and friendly servers never disappoint. The grouper for me and veal for my wife were outstanding. The red wine merlot Syrah blend was delicious.

We will be back next year to celebrate the night we met.

nice restaurant but somewhat overpriced for the entree specials.

The food was excellent... the best on Hilton Head in my opinion. The pasta tasted so fresh and the fish was not overcooked. The service was friendly from the reservationist to the waiter. I also appreciate that we could have a conversation without having to raise our voices over too loud music or excessive room chatter. Will definitely eat there again.

We found the food to be fabulous, however, we found the upstairs head server on New Year’s Eve to be condescending. He corrected our pronunciation of the wine selected, not once but twice. When asked where the restroom was located rather than respond kindly we received a curt response. He had an arrogant response to my husband’s inquiry about one of the nightly specials.

We chose to enjoy our evening, but it certainly was our choice and not because of the service.

Food was perfect!

Lovely place with great service and fabulous food. Everyone from the hostess, bartender and server was amazing!

Consistently excellent food and service

Our server Chris was very friendly and engaging. Food was excellent as always.

The whole experience was excellent!

Forgot special event. Very busy night.

Good service but disappointed in food. Great presentation and variety but lacking flavor

Great meal. Servers Jay & Rich? were super friendly.

Excellent meal and service. One of our favorite meals ever! We had some of the very special white truffles with scallops. My husband ordered the Osso Buco and I had the Lobster ravioli! Still talking about how good the meal was the next day. They also made our anniversary very special with glasses of Prosecco and to start and Limoncello to finish!🤗 Will go back here again and again!

By far one of the best restaurants in the area. The food and service can’t be beat. We celebrated a birthday on our recent visit and our waiter couldn’t have been more accommodating with celebratory Prosecco and limoncello for the table. The salads and appetizers were fabulous as were our entree selections. We will continue to keep Michael Anthony’s on our restaurant rotation!

This was our first time at the restaurant. Both the food and the service were impeccable. Definitely will be back!

After the kids left the day after Christmas and hubby’s returned to work, I came to the beach to spend a long weekend by myself. I made a reservation letting them know that I was on a special vacation and dining alone. The reserved a special quiet table with a view of the Christmas tree and other holiday decorations. I did the early bird menu and the meal was exquisite. The beet salad, shrimp pasta dish and tiramisu. Just delicious! The server was knowledgeable and excellent. When I come back with my husband we will definitely come for a romantic meal! Bravo

just fabulous all around....great FOOD too!! the staff was warm & atmosphere great!

Portion sizes were a good bit smaller than expected given the prices, but the food was delicious and we all still left "fat and happy". Our wait staff was great but definitely preoccupied with larger / older parties. The ambiance was amazing (until a large noisy group came in, but the restaurant cannot help that!). Definitely recommend for a nice family dinner in Hilton Head, or a romantic dinner date.

Great restaurant. We will be back. Service superb especially with Jonathan

Wonderful meal, served hot and delicious from the kitchen. Also a very attentive waiter who knew how to describe the food we had questions about. Terrific and romantic experience.

The waitstaff was attentive without being intrusive. Wonderful waiter and server. However, the practice here is that when a patron leaves the table, the waiter refolds their napkin. I dislike this practice. I just imagine someone coughing, sneezing, even wiping there mouth with their napkin...he folds it and then folds mine. Please, please do not do this. Unless you are washing hands between patron, do not touch my napkin!

Wonderful!

Consistently good food.

Wonderful dinner! I always visit when I am in Hilton Head!

We have visited Michael Anthony's several times and have not been disappointed each time. We shared the wide pasta with chicken and sausage ragu in marinara sauce. It was flavorable and very filling even though we shared. Their pasta is homemade. We also shared a Pino Noir recommended by our server that was very robust and an excellent pairing with the pasta. Highly recommended albeit a little pricey

An exceptional experience from beginning to end. They honored my special request re seating and our server was outstanding. All four of us enjoyed our apps & entrees. We especially savored the calamari app--great flavors. We thought the bread was different this time--it did not have the delish crusty chewiness that we remembered. The two of us who ordered the pasta with mushrooms felt the flavor of the dish would have had more depth with earthier mushrooms. Nevertheless, we believe it provides the best in each category on the island.

One of the best in Hilton Head . We enjoyed the food.

This is our favorite restaurant on the island. Jeff, our server was excellent. Our meals were memorable. My wife had a mediteraniam veal dish while I had the oso buco, very tender and full of flavor. The terimisu for dessert was very good.

Very disappointed. Food was bland and the soup seemed watered down. Reviews were better than this but there was not a burst of flavor for any of the courses.

Had a wonderful dinner, our waiter was very helpful finding the perfect dinner based on what our dietary needs. Our wine was excellent and we hope to return soon.

Christopher is an excellent server. We followed his recommendations on everything and had an excellent meal.

We received a table in the upstairs corner for two, mind you we dine out regularly. The table is Aweful, one person can only see the wall. The wine selection is always good, and the beer choices are lousy. The don’t have Mic Ultra, the number 1 new selling beer. It sell because of its low carbs. With all the choices of places to eat, this was disappointing for its high rating. We’ll try again next month and see if anything changes.

Our server was incredibly professional, and he was also genuinely kind. The food was delicious. We were on our honeymoon and want to come back!