McCormick & Schmick's Seafood - Indianapolis
Seared Ahi Tuna
Seared Rare, Sesame Cucumber Salad, Sushi Rice
Maine Lobster Bisque
Went for our anniversary. Food was delicious as usual. Service was great. Every one was good about social distancing and masks.
So-so filet. Food presentation disappointing. Great server.
1st Wedding Anniversary
Great service very good food, portions a little small. My wife and I really liked it. Will definitely go back.
Valet is not yet back in service, but plenty of parking on street. Diners were spaced out well, and sanitizer available just inside the door. Meal service was timed perfectly and our waitress was one of the best we’ve ever had. Crab cake appetizer was delicious, Caesar salad was big enough to split in two. We enjoyed twin lobster tails, a small and a large filet. All were cooked perfectly and the seasonal veggies serving size was ample. Hard to see such a good establishment struggle to fill tables on weeknights, but glad we had such a good experience and looking forward to going back.
Have been to M & S twice this week! Food excellent both times. Fabulous crab cake, perfectly prepare grilled shrimp, wonderful oysters, crusty sourdough, perfect cheesecake. Entire meal outstanding. Preferred the male server the first evening. Female server a bit too chatty, constantly upselling and involving herself in our evening.
We had a great time at this restaurant and can’t wait to go back.
Food and service was great. It was a little pricey but an enjoyable experience.
Food was good. due to virus limited menu, but found something for both of us. Service was excellent.
food was food not anything to write home about not worth the $
This was our first dinner inside a restaurant since the start of COVID and it also happened to be a birthday celebration. Everything was perfect from cocktails to appetizers to dinner and dessert. We felt special and felt the M&S staff cared about our special occasion. Can't wait to return.
Great food and service. Good social distancing!!
We had a great experience. Their filet was so tender you could cut with a fork. Crab cake appetizer was incredible. Service was great. We’ll definitely be coming back.
Spectacular dining experience. Love the restaurant.
Very good value. Vibe was entergetic but with the booths design we still had plenty of privacy.
The good had really good flavor. Really enjoyed the place and the food.
It was very noisy in the restaurant. The server was great. The food was great.
Awesome service and atmosphere!
We thoroughly enjoyed our meal! It was delicious! Our server, Wendi, was fabulous and the manager was great too! We will definitely return for another meal!
We enjoyed our first dining experience here this evening!
Service was horrific - ordered drinks that never came to the table. Ordered a glass of wine for my dinner they brought an empty glass and never brought the wine. Ate my dinner with what little ice melt water I had in water glass. Then charged me for the wine on the bill. While waiting for the crap show at the table ordered a couple drinks at the bar and the bartender was less than friendly.
Too many other places close by to have a business dinner - no need to have to deal with this type of service.
Great wood service was excellent.
Highly recommend it.
Appetizer never brought to table. Communication and execution poor on appetizers being delivered. Server Wendi very good
Overall we enjoyed our visit, but my husbands ordered a 18oz NY Strip MW. First he received a 6 oz Filet. Once sent back he received a 13 oz NY Strip Mrare. He sent that back just to have it cooked correctly to MW because we didn't want to wait on a whole new steak. The food was amazing was it was prepared correctly.
We had "Tabby" as a waitress and she was probably the worst waitress we have ever had. She forgot what I ordered to drink. She brought things at different times - we had our 1st courses served separately. Then she was surprised when I asked where my first course was. She was going to serve my shrimp cocktail at the same time she served my steak. She then spilled dessert on my husband's sweater and pants. The manager spoke to us and offered to consider our cleaning bill if we send her the receipt. She was not very sincere with her apology either. We are not sending you a receipt - we can pay for our own cleaning bills but that waitress and manager need to be retrained.
Service (Laney?) was attentive and precise. Food was good, as always.
Enjoyed an excellent meal here for Valentine's Day. It was a bit noisy, but other than that an excellent experience for our first time here. My wife had the lobster and I had the ribeye and both were great. We had a knowledgeable waiter who always checked on us. We will return!!
I realize with it being Valentine's day, that could affect this but we waited so long for our food. Around 45 minutes for our meal. It was also very cold where we were seated, so the food got cold very quickly.
First, I have been to M&S many times and always have had a great meal. This time I made the mistake of going on Valentines day with my wife. We arrived on time for our reservation and were immediately seated in the back room at a small table, although there were several open tables in the main dining room. Table was a big problem as it was so unstable, several items fell on the ground when we were seated. We sat there for almost 10 minutes before someone asked if we had been waited on. They finally brought water, which spilled on the table due to the table moving again. After this happened one more time, I asked to be seated in the main dining. We were told that that wasn't their area, but could move us to another adjacent table. OK. Better than nothing. They apologized about the table as it was a "temporary" table that was brought in due to the high demand.
Then we went to order off the menu, which I love seafood. However, my wife does not like seafood and is allergic to beef. No problem, right? They always have one chicken dinner. Except tonight. No chicken. We were told that because it was so busy they decided to consolidate the menu to make it easy on the kitchen. At this point, I asked for the manager. Really? You consolidate the menu and get rid of the one chicken dish on the menu? At this point, attitudes changed and they went out of their way to get my wife taken care of and the service and food was good.
Was just the worst greeting into a restaurant that I have experienced in a very long time. Not what I expect from M&S, and I know they can do better.
Steak was good but vegetables were little to be desired. Very slow service.
Cordial staff. Formal but relaxed atmosphere. Scrumptious food.
Did ask for a table near by the window. They couldn't have put us at one any further away.
Do not like special menus or was Valentines Day. I will check next time.
The only real issue I had was with a hostess. Our server was very nice. When he brought us our wedge salads, one was noticeably better prepared than the other. My wife’s salad had hardly any dressing and bacon bits. So we flagged down a hostess and told her our observation. She fairly indignantly looked over the salad and proceeded to educate us on how salads with different types of dressing will look differently. My wife said all she wanted was more dressing and bacon bits. The hostess quickly picked up the salad and went to the kitchen. When she came back she sat the salad down and just went on her way. It had more dressing and no bacon! Our server came back and was kind enough to bring us more bacon for the salad, but the experience was fairly tainted by then.
We knew it would be busy as it was Valentine’s Day. That really wasn’t an issue. I ordered my steak very well done. The server was a bit short with me when I asked her if it was well done. She assured me it was. It was rare. Very, very rare. So while the rest of our party and I waited for my meal. It arrived after everyone else was finished. So, unfortunately not the best experience.
Food was great and the service was on point. Dinner was perfect!
Valentine’s Day dinner.
M&S is one of my family's favorite places, especially for special occasions. The ambiance is great. The food is generally outstanding, though a little pricey.
We've eaten there in the past, and it was excellent. This year, we went for Valentine's Day. There was a special menu with limited items. While our entrees were very good, the sides of roasted veggie and roasted potatoes were crunchy and nearly cold. Those side were very disappointing. Not sure we would recommend for Valentine's Day. Stick to the regular menu.
McCormick & Schmick's Seafood - Indianapolis offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (317) 631-9500.
McCormick & Schmick's Seafood - Indianapolis is rated 4.3 stars by 3682 OpenTable diners.
McCormick & Schmick's Seafood - Indianapolis does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://www.landrysinc.com/giftcards/default.asp.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.