Great waiter loved sitting outside with the brewze

Great food, nice ambiance, energetic ambiance! Only remark we have is that the glasses of rosé were really dutch like 😄! USD 10 a glass for half a glass is expensive! Nevertheless, food was good! We definiteley recommend the restaurant!! It was great!!

Matt's Stock Island Kitchen has wonderful ambience. The outdoor seating is awesome. Even on a hot day , the breeze made our dinner spectacular, and looking over the marina just adds to the experience. My husband ordered the Oysters and they were fresh and tasty. Our Grouper was tasty with the exception of the overfried cornmeal crust. This is the second time I ordered my fish this way and that was my mistake. There are many things yet to try on the menu. We will be returning on our next trip to Stock Island.
The S O B bar next to the pool is a gem as well.

Everything was delicious!

Staff is very friendly. Debra welcomed us back to Matt's.

Great place for a casual meal with many choices. All staff were so very friendly and attentive from the hostess Deborah, to our charming waiter Rustam and even the quick Balan clearing off our used dishes. Such a pleasant evening meal, feeling welcomed and special. Food is delicious and just the right portions. Will be back!

Leon was our waiter and he was fabulous.! We had teens that asked lots of questions and he patiently answered them and helped in making menu decisions. The fish tacos were spot on! Great environment!

Matt’s was perfect. The food was original, fresh and imaginative. We are discerning, and each course was wonderful. The Fire and Ice salad was the most unique and delicious take in a salad we have seen in a very long time. Good service, great patio view. Stock Island has a winner. As locals, We did not know about Matt’s until we fueled our boat and the Marina mentioned it. A great secret, but not for long.

Love the vibe & atmosphere! I think they should of turned off the fireplace on the outside patio. Kinda ridiculous to make a hot climate more hot.

Food was great and service was awesome great job Matts Stock Island

Consistently a great experience. I’m a 30-year Key West resident and consider Matt’s a real safe haven from “yea old tourist traps” in town. I highly recommend for all occasions.

The Restaurant is very cool. We brought in our own fresh catch and the chef made it ceviche and tacos. The filet was a touch over cooked for the tacos but it was still pretty tasty. We had to flag down another server for a second drink and also for our check. That being said it was a very relaxing meal.This is our second visit and we will be returning on our next trip down to Key West.

This was by far the best meal we have ever had in Key West. . .We cannot wait to come back!!!!!

This was our first time eating at Matt's. We loved our dinner and will be back!

Nice spot by the harbor. Saw some dolphins while we dined which was nice! Unfortunately the patio is right next to the pool so there were some rowdy kids making a lot of noise nearby. Food was good, service could have been better. But a very nice ambiance.

Best food on Stock Island... including fresh fish, lobster, oysters and amazing steaks. The key to each plate is the variety of amazing sauces available...every dish is carefully crafted, along with delicious side dishes.

Had one of the best dinners why staying in Key West would highly recommend very good

This is the second time we’ve eaten at Matt’s and have been very pleased both times. We are local and know how fish is supposed to taste. We had very fresh, perfectly cooked fish with a lovely sauce. My green bean side was just OK but my husband said his cornbread mash was outstanding. Even though we are used to high prices in a tourist area, Matt’s prices were high even by key west standards as everything is alacarte and the service, while pleasant is not fine dining. Otherwise, we’ll be back.

Great place. Enjoyed it tremendously. Would go again

Reservation at 7, restaurant was fairly empty. Server was nice, food was expensive for what you get. $24 for an 8 shrimp basket was pricey. If you are staying at the hotel it is convenient enough, but has potential to be a lot better!

I was looking for something different that was not in Key West. Matt's had good reviews and we decided to give it a try. We will definitely be returning. The crab beignets were amazing. The grouper with gnudi was delicious. Hand crafted cocktails. Seating outside near the water. The bar looked great with a couple of TV's. I would have drinks there. Outside area with firepit for drinks looked great as well.

The preparation and presentation of fresh oysters to begin, yellowtail snapper tacos and skillet seared yellow edge grouper for dinner was the BEST fresh seafood we’ve enjoyed in years- and we’re born and raised in Miami foodies!

A delightful change of pace and scenery from the Duval Crawl scene at a brand new property, beautifully appointed, evoking a causally elegant dockside vibe that includes a hotel, an indoor and an outdoor bar, and a restaurant with indoor and outdoor seating at nearby Stock Island.

Service staff and management were friendly, helpful and professional.

A friend was in town for her last meal in KW for a while!!!
When we couldn’t get into another early gathering/dining spot we went to The Perry & Matt’s Restaurant!
Vera at the bar made a very special cocktail for 2 of us & they have IPA’s on draft!!!

Thanks allot for the amazing dinner great chief great service 100% delicious . The best customer service in key west glad I went there

My wife and I tried Matt’s along with friends the first night with reservations and went back for a second without reservations to see if we could get a table. We sat inside both evenings and the dining area was nice. There were a few other diners in the area but I don’t think this place has been really discovered yet so it was not noisy at all. Both the food and drinks we ordered were flavorful, perfectly prepared, and consistently good over the two days we ate there. I would recommend trying this place and will make it a stop during future trips to the area.

Mother’s Day

Our server was great and the grouper was awesome! Will be back

Decent food - very overpriced. Louis backyard prices but without Louis backyard quality...Shrimp basket was good- ribs very bad. Oyster Rockefeller great as well... however for the price everything should have been excellent... I have no problems spending on a great dinner but hate paying great dinner price for a ok at best dinner... leaving this place for the hotel guests.

Eggs benedict were barely warm and the muffin under it was cold. Must have been sitting around for awhile. Not what we expected.

Great food and service

The service and ambiance were first rate. Our fresh catch Cornbread Mahi was over fried which gave it a burnt taste. The mahi fish and chips were undercooked , the breading was heavy and soggy. The oysters and sides were delicious. The wine and mixed drinks were on the pricey side and the specialty coffees were not worth the 12.00 price tag.
We will return , there are more things to try and it is beautiful .

Lives up to it’s reputation for poor service despite being empty on a Sunday evening.
Food was good

This is a really cool spot. Great chefs there! Loved the Commodore Tower - seafood in a tackle box....it was a delicious according to our group (I am allergic to seafood) but a big hit. Drinks were delicious...we never felt hurried and enjoyed our waterfront table.

Couple things that would make it better..would love if they would carry Cooranbong Australian Vodka....and if they would add a few more non seafood items to the menu for those of us that can't eat it.

Otherwise...a special place with a beautiful view. Cheers to the great new spot on Stock Island!

Food and atmosphere were great. I think our server was new but I'm sure with experience she will get better.

Amazing food and service! The Clam Chowder was unbelievable! Caleb does an outstanding job! The service was excellent as well! We will definitely be back for dinner!

The food was superb! And service was on point.

I've been for lunch & dinner and I would ago back anytime...Fab Food, Great Service, Wonderful view of the marina, Very Nice atmosphere. We loved it!

Fresh fish and cocktails were delicious.Had to wait for about 15 min even though we had a reservation.
Nice ambience and good service. Bar was not bussed and was messy looking when we had to get a drink during our wait. Luckily that wasnt reflective of the overall experience we had but was off putting at first. Overall one of the best meals had on Key West.

Lovely food. Service was lovely but slow

My family had a wonderful experience! Food was delicious and the atmosphere was perfect! Highly recommend for breakfast too!