Matteo's of Huntington

Disappointing. After all I read about Mateo's my husband and were looking forward to a great dinner out. After being seated quickly and the nice ambiance, it went downhill from there. Service was poor (we waited so long for the first drink I was wondering if we had a waiter) and food was just mediocre. Even the Bolognese wasn't great (and portion was small). We'll stick with our more down to earth local Italian place if we want good food.

We really enjo

Our dinner was delicious and graciously served. Due to the pandemic, we dined outside. The staff has made the outdoor dining area pleasant and inviting. The traffic noise can’t be avoided, but it wasn’t too bad. It got a little cool, but our server was quick to turn on the patio heater near our table. Perfect.

We have recently become regulars at this restaurant. The service and food are both consistently very good; and we like the vibe.

I usually go to the Roslyn location but wanted something outdoors due to COVID. We were a table of 7 (3 kids) and even though it was a little noisy with the traffic you can’t notice the street unless you are standing. The food was good, chicken parm is the best at both locations, however; the calamari was very dry like it was old and sitting for a while. We informed our waiter who was amazing btw and he removed the charge from the bill. Overall great experience, will go again. FYI pretty busy for a Wednesday night.

Delicious dinner with exceptional service. Always accommodating and and an enjoyable experience.

No waiting for reserved table, party was sat immediately at beautiful table, excellent service, delicious food!

Loved the place. Everything (our table, our waiter, our food) was wonderful except for our appetizer. Ordered the fried Calamari. It was tough as nails. On the bright side, perhaps all the chewing we did tightened up our jaw lines in the end. But it really was a struggle to chew up the Calamari. The 3 other courses was perfect and totally delicious. We would definitely go back there again (but we will never order the Calamari again).

Friendly staff, food was great. It was great to see Dennis.

my husband order the pork special ,there was so much food we had it for dinner the following night. The napoleon desert is so large 4 people could have share it,
Definitely get your moneys worth with them The place was set up for social distancing so we felt very comfortable Out side was great also for dinners ,there were heaters all over to keep you warm. Been there before will go back again

Horrible service food was not good they forgot to bring out 1 of our entree’s

It was great eating outside and the food and service was great. Outside was noisy because of Jericho Tpk. but it was my choice

Great fresh food, the service and the ambience was also very good. We look forward to returning there many more times again.

The perfect place for dinner during the pandemic. Outdoor seating was well placed and nicely set up. All staff members wore masks. They even had heat lamps which came in handy later in the evening. The food was delicious and the service was attentive without being intrusive. Highly recommend Matteo's in Huntington.

We ate outside and we felt the tables were very spaced out and we felt very comfortable and safe despite the corona virus issue. The service and the food and the atmosphere were terrific. We will be back.

We were celebrating our daughter’s Bday.
We felt safe, comfortable,well attended to.
There’s ample seating indoor and outdoor. The indoor seating is well spaced.. servers, busboys wearing gloves and mask.
The food flavorful and generous. They have family portions you can choose from or a single portion. The bread , baked in house is something you shouldn’t pass up. We dipped ours in balsamic and olive oil...they offer a good variety of desserts, we recommend the Napoleon.. it’s the signature dessert.
We had a wonderful evening

Excellent service and food as always! We love Matteo’s it’s our go to for Italian food.

one of our favorite places

Terrific as usual!

Followed COVID protocols nicely.

We have been consistently pleased with our experiences at Matteo’s. The food is always delicious, the service understated, and the overall vibe very pleasant.

Fantastic value and service. Great seating outside very comfortable Dennis is a great and wonderful and makes you feel very special. Highly recommended for all families

It’s was meh

Matteo’s is one of the best Italian restaurants in Long Island. The outside dining area was excellent plenty of room and tables were at least 6 feet apart. Very clean and nice atmosphere. The food is totally awesome and healthy size portions. The eggplant parmigiana is my favorite,my wife had the burnt broccoli 🥦 that cooked in a wood fire stove ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️. All of the entries are fantastic. The wine was excellent and well priced. Service is friendly and the staff is excellent. Never had a bad meal or experience here. A must go to spot for Italian food.

Great menu, good choices, fast service, perfect pasta, great drinks seating very nice

The food was tasty but the service was far from good. The pasta side dish came after we had all finished our dinner and the grated Parmesan never came. They did make up for it by giving us three free desserts.

Always a great meal at Matteos. Food, ambiance, service: top notch every time.

Excellent food and drinks, as usual! Their outdoor seating in the front parking lot set up because of Covid is done up really nice. Its like it was there all the time, does not feel makeshift. They could use some candles on the tables for better lighting and maybe some barricades out front, it was just a little concerning being so close to such a busy road.

They've done a great job setting up the outdoor seating. Only issue with being right on Jericho Tpke is the traffic and noise it generates. When big trucks come by at 45 mph, you can't here yourself talk. That said, go for a later time slot and you won't be dealing with the commercial traffic. Service was good but very slow which we liked since we were with friends we haven't seen in a while. Four hours start to finish. If you are looking to linger, it's great. If not, it's just going to tick you off. Cocktails were perfectly done, wait staff was great, and food portions plenty. The food itself? Basic Italian dishes. Nothing we can say was outstanding. Good meal and a decent price point in a nice setting.

Love the new outdoor area. Very nicely done. Dennis the head chef and maitre d is awesome. The service is great. Food is always very good. The shrimp Wendy is fresh and burnt green beans are my favorite. The seafood over pasta is also great. Will return.

Wonderful experience. Thanks for a safe and dining experience.

Food was Really EXCELLENT !!!! GREAT SERVICE and you get a choice of Inside
dining or Outside.

Great service great food!

The restaurant had notice that it was our anniversary but did not say anything, seemed to be rushed off their feet, service took far too long and then the food was average to point where my wife was ill later that evening. All in all, we will not be returning or recommending.

Everything was excellent and our server Vince was perfect

Service was slow

Hands down one of the worst meals I have ever had. I ordered a steak to be cooked medium rare and it came out blue. I sent it back and came out well done. A new steak was brought out and was cooked well done again and completely burnt. $40 for without question the worst steak I’ve ever had.

Amazing food and service ALWAYS at Matteos. Cosmic martini was delish along with the apps and meal!! Dennis the manager always checking to see if everything is ok. 5 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

Great food and excellent service at Matteo’s. It was my father’s birthday and everyone there made him feel special.

Very professional and safe