Great all good
This restaurant was boppin' and packed'! Good service, for the most part, but needed to ask for more water 3 or 4 times before it arrived. (This was restaurant week, after all, so possibly more crowded than usual.) We both thought the food was excellent! The baked clam appetizer was divine, the eggplant parm was perfect and the sole atop broccolini was scrumptious. The desserts -- tiramisu and cheesecake - couldn't have been better. It's a noisy kind of place, but it's a pleasant noise. We will be going back there soon. Nice that they have valet parking!
My family and I went to celebrate my birthday. The chicken parm was very good, fried calamari was very good, but the filet of sole was not very good. The manager was concerned we were not happy with our meal. I would go back to eat the chicken parm. Cheesecake and Triamisu was also good.
Had an excellent meal during Huntington Restaurant Week. Each of our dishes was prepared and served to our liking. Service was excellent as well. Will be back!
Food was delicious. We sat at a bar table and there was a very rowdy crew at the bar. Our waitress was a bartender and a little less attentive than we would have liked. The food was outstanding. We will definitely be back.
Restaurant was very loud. Food was prepared well but lacked spice or tastiness. Large portions.
The service is top notch, our server Jennifer was attentive and made excellent recommendations. The entree was well prepared and the sides were large enough to share.
They have an excellent and varied wine list
Love, love, love Matteo’s. The food is delicious, the service is excellent and the restaurant is beautiful.
they were very crowded and were behind over 1 hour in seating and the service was not up to par. also the food was being rushed and did not come out well prepared as they normally do. Try to go when they are not so busy as we did on a Saturday night
Matteos in Huntington is delicious. The chicken francese and penne alla vodka were unbelievable. Can’t wait to go back. Highly recommend!!!!
I keep going back hoping it gets better. Food nothing special and tasteless. Service wasn’t get.
Our Waiter Henry was very attentive and was a pleasant experience
Usually Its a good meal...this time it was off....Ravioli were cold....Calamari weren't tender....couldve been an bad night....
The staff was friendly and proffersional
Delicious food, excellent service. Our favorite Italian restaurant.
3rd time at Matteo's since it reopened. Food has been excellent every time. PEI muscles are always reliable. Veal Marsala, Red Snapper and pasta dishes were all very good. Portions are all very large. Single portions of most dishes can feed two and the family style options are good for four. Only negative is the noise level. They need to deal with the acoustics.
Very disappointed. Waiter didn’t understand all of my daughters allergies. He mixed the orders and really didn’t know how to take the orders.
Excellent experience from warm welcome to dessert...
Huge portions ! We will definitely be back soon with more people. Our server Ally was knowledgeable and attentive
Had a wonderful experience dining here! My boyfriend and I decided to celebrate Valentine’s Day here and it was absolutely fantastic! Not only was the food fantastic but the service was incredible. The staff was very attentive and friendly! Already can’t wait to go back!
Great food and service. Such pretty decor.
Good comfort food. Zucchini linguini worth trying. The rice balls were really good.
service was very poor- took nearly 30 minutes for the entree to come out, pasta was cold and had to be reheated. Better in Roslyn.
Delicious and extensive menu, excellent service and beautiful ambiance.
The service was excellent. The food was excellent. The decor was nice. The gas fireplace was beautiful. The problem was the noise level. It was a Saturday night and the place was so loud the four of us at our table literally could not hear each other at all.
Matteo’s is the best. Beautiful restaurant, excellent service and the food presentation is amazing as well as delicious. We love it!
The octopus appetizer was really good, but we ordered a dozen baked clams that were absolutely tasteless. We sprinkled salt on them (we never use table salt) just to add some kind of flavor. However, the linguine with white Clams entree was delicious. Overall portion size was pretty good. We asked our server to “space” the meal and he did not. The entrees came out 5 seconds after we finished our appetizer.
Good meal-value, but we felt rushed by our waiter. Kept pushing us to order, when we were engaged in conversation. Asked us to order desert before we were even finished with our main course.
Accomadating to where we wished to be seated, service was excellent, food was delicious, great cappacino, noise level a bit high. All in all lovely place, would go again.
The place is recently remodeled, table service is generally excellent, tonight we ate at the counter that overlooks the kitchen. Even there the service was exceptional.
The personal pizzas were delicious, thin crisp crust with fresh ingredients, the cold antipasti plate was very good.
Place is very nice. Hostess very nice, waiter very abrupt. Food was good, veal chop delish as well as pasta with marinara n mozzarella
Remodel came out beautiful, ambience is terrific, and the food was great. Service could not have been better. We will be returning many times.
After over 3 years of rebuilding Mateo's didn't disappoint when finally reopened.
Love the new Matteo’s. Food, service and ambiance are amazing.
Great service, great food, great value and food selections for restaurant week menu. Overall, a perfect evening at beautifully newly re-furbished dining venue
Food is amazing and service is good. The only reason I say service is not great is because this place is always packed which never plays well for the servers!! Its a great dining experience for 2 or 10! We have yet to have a plate of food we didn't love.
excellent food with great service
very comfortable tables. never feel rushed
Went for restaurant week... Amazing deal .. best italian food I've had at a restaurant in a very long time.. the ambiance and decor was beautiful .. wait staff was so friendly .. will definitely be coming back for more !!
Food was delicious as always, service was impeccable, ambiance was beautiful! My new favorite!
The food and service was excellent. Our servers Jennifer and Greg we're attentive and friendly. The made wonderful recommendations for our meal.
The steak was tender and perfectly cooked. We really enjoyed the mozzarella selections and the tiramisu was delicious.
This is the second time I have been to Matteo's and the service has been awful. The first time was close to the opening so I figured the staff were new and needed time to adjust. Well, it is now quite a few months later and the service was still terrible. It took 20 minutes for someone to come over to take a drink order and give us water, at least 20-25 minutes in between courses and 40 minutes for dessert is arrive after we placed the order. We finally asked for the check prior to dessert so we could leave as soon as we finished. We were ready to go home at this point as it was a Wednesday evening. We had a 7:30pm reservation and did not leave till after 10pm. Too long!