Matteo's of Huntington
Friday - Saturday 4pm - 11pm
Sunday 3pm - 9pm
This was our second time dining here. Everything both times were absolutely delicious. I will definitely be a repeat customer. Pasta portions are large, even individual sized ones.
All around excellent. Will be back. .
Another fantastic experience at Matteo‘s. The dinner was amazing and the service was excellent.
Great service and food!
Food was outstanding as it always is when we go. Only downside was we were seated at a table right under an AC vent and it was very cold.
All was great! Awesome!
Great on every level. I never review restaurants but it was exceptional. We were a party of 5, all of us can't wait to return!
Pretty good overall. Great service but food was overly salty.
Very loud and hard to hear conversation at table. Brussels sprouts were hard. Food was good not great. Hit or miss.
After arriving on time we were told that our table wasn’t ready yet. Not at all annoyed we went to the bar. After 15 minutes we could not get the bartenders attention, who was enrapt in conversation at the other end of the bar.
When seated, after about 15 minutes waiter came over, we ordered a bottle of wine which took another 1/2 hour to come! So we were at the restaurant for over an hour attempting to order a drink, to no avail!
We also were seated for over a 1/2 hour before our order was taken.
Food was fine. Not out of this world. But, fine for a moderately priced restaurant.
Noise level of restaurant is off the charts! No music! Can barely talk to the person next to you over the background noise of other diners.
Will never go back!
Very noisy and extremely long wait for meal to arrive- food was very average and cold
The place, the service and the food was excellent. Only drawback was it was extremely "Loud". So loud our party was seated at a great round table and we had trouble hearing one another. Everyone in our party felt the same way. Noise level was too much. It was an anniversary celebration for the three couples and we all were excited about getting together only for it to be ruined by extreme noise. Very loud guest.
Food needed salt!! Restaurant looks nice inside
Beautiful dining experience. Great food & service. Terrific martinis!!
Outstanding service from the moment we walked in to our final goodbye. Food was delicious and the decor was very chic.
Beautiful restaurant, delicious food and very pleasant experience.
Celebrating an anniversary, food was delicious! Good size portions. Great for a special occasion .
Very disappointing night. The wait staff was non attending the food took a long time and was not hot and we did not get what we ordered.
Always a great dining experience! Food is top notch! This time our server was a little inexperienced. Couldn’t pour our wine.. spilled it! And didn’t check on us enough after meals were served. I needed pepper and more seltzer.. couldn’t find him.
Chopped salad was delish. Shrimp dish great.
The food was very good, they had many specials for you to choose from, as well you could choose from the menu. The napoleon was great.
Fantastic restaurant. Delicious food and excellent service.
Pleasant restaurant and staff
Enjoyed the food and the ambience was great! Our server Vincent was excellent presenting the menu and suggesting certain dishes. He was a delight to speak with and all of us had a great time!
Always Delicious Food and Drink along with Consistently Good Service and a wonderful dining atmosphere.
Great Girlfriend Get together!!!!!
We have been to Matteo’s a few times and our last visit, the food was very disappointing. Not sure if we will try again. I believe if you are an Italian restaurant and you can’t make dynamite chicken parm, then you have big problems!
The food was inedible as it was so over salted.
All the dishes were horrible. Penne a la vodka, shrimp and other dish was chicken. Very disappointing.
A beautiful new restaurant and excellent service. Best place to go with family and friends for a delicious dinner.
Wonderful cozy place, service is great and the server was so nice! The food was amazing get the fresh ravioli it’s the best great for a cozy date!
The building and the Decour are beautiful. All of the meal selections we had, there were six of us, was very very good. The maître d’ seemed to be our waiter. The only thing lacking was it seemed that the wait staff and bus boys weren’t really attentive or were only there to clean off tables rather than wait on tables or so it seemed. The left the maître d’ doing a lot of the running around, Although he was attentive. We would all definitely come back.
Great staff. Great food priced well. A pleasure to dine there
Started off with a few glitches;due to an inattentive waiter. Manager took over and replaced the waiter after 30 minutes. Excellent recovery by John, the manager. This was an anniversary dinner and we almost walked out. Will try it again. Great food.
While the food was good and the restaurant was lovely, the experience was not. The Bar Mitzvah in the next room over-powered our "quiet" Sunday night dinner as the acoustical separation between the 2 rooms was non-existent. The lack of respect for regular diners was appalling. If you are going to have diners in adjacent rooms to special parties, have a good sound separation so one does not overcome the other. The party's DJ was way too loud. We couldn't wait to finish our meal and leave. As much as I would like to recommend this restaurant, in good conscience I cannot. What are we chopped liver?
Seated at 4:30, with only one table seated prior to us. drink order taken. Waited 20 min for drinks to arrive. Chose the Prix fixe menu so ordered appetizers and main course at same time. Waited 25 min for appetizers. Waiter was overstressed with 9 tables to tend to, by the time our appetizers arrived. Main course didn’t arrive until 5:50. We had one in our party who had to leave for work at 6 so very aware of the time. We had mentioned this to both Vincent and Anthony who tended to our area. She didn’t have time to eat her meal so took it to go. Food was delicious and nice portions. Then we waited until 7 to order dessert as no one came over to ask if we needed anything including drinks. Dessert took 15 min to arrive. Coffee and a tea bag another 10 mins. Staff seemed very disorganized and chef was busy on his phone texting all the time. Even waiting for the bill took long.
To say we were disappointed is mild. This was our second visit in less than a week and being the first was on Monday we just assumed the lack of service and delays were attributed to it being an off day. Well after this early Sunday visit and seeing these issues are still apparent it will be some time before we return. Shame as the food is excellent.
Didn’t like the peppers as appetizer however everything else was great
Would not recommend, specials are only for certain tables.
Matteo’s food was delicious..great environment..enjoyable dining experience.
Food was great, was there 2x in the last week. Both times, the only complaint I have is the noise level. It is very hard to hear conversations from your table. They really should put some noise-cancelling tiles or something to help lower to noise level. Food and service was great but I missed half of what my friends said, both times. The renovations are beautiful!
Atmosphere was nice, although somewhat load because our table was close to the open kitchen. I was with 3 other people and we all truly enjoyed our entrees.
One issue, the entrees did not come with a side dish. We were there for restaurant week and so it was a price fix menu, but if we wanted pasta on the side we had to pay an additional cost.
Very lovely restaurant, visually appealing with a gorgeous modern layout. Food was amazing (must try calamari, mussels, freshly made ravioli, etc.), all were cooked to perfection. Wine selection was pleasant but wished for a wider variety of specialty cocktails. For deserts, the tiramisu and cheesecake was absolutely exquisite (I’m not usually a fan of desert). :)
Service was a bit chaotic and inconsistent, I wish the staff were a bit more attentive, friendly (most lacked a smile), and overall, I understand perhaps it was an off night for most, due to the high volume traffic and events taking place this evening. I would recommend this location for a large group and live atmosphere. If you are seeking something more intimate and low key, the Roslyn’s location would be ideal.