Modern Coastal Italian
Book your next event with us
So wonderful! From the food to the service, everything was the best. Shout out to our great server Jackie, who was very helpful and welcoming.
Our server, Dallas, made a great dinner absolutely fabulous.
Would go back in a heartbeat. Utterly delightful. Loved happy hour oysters, calamari, martinis and more.
Great food and lovely atmosphere. We liked it so much, we went twice. Don't miss $1 oysters on Tuesdays.
Great find! Excellent food, homemade pasta, fantastic wine list, great wines by the glass, friendly, stellar service - could not ask for more. OK, maybe an ocean view but I had a partial view. The food is so good that it is definitely worth the visit. We stayed at the Hotel Del Coronado and ate at the highly overpriced restaurants there. Prices here were comparable, but the food was so much better, beyond compare.
Great ambiance and friendly service. Nice little restaurant.
A pleasant surprise! A balanced restaurant with impressive plates and superb service.
Fantastic food and service! We went for my son’s first birthday and had a great time. Our waitress was amazing and food was top notch. Would recommend to anyone
My sister and I had a lovely dinner at the restaurant. The food was delicious, the ambiance was very calming and comfortable and our server, Nekysa, was amazing! Very efficient, friendly and helpful with the menu. I would definitely recommend the restaurant to someone looking for a great dining experience.
The only negative I had was the hallway going to the restaurants and the restrooms themselves. For such a classy restaurant, that area was like going back in time. If possible, I would definitely put some effort into continuing the ambiance of the restaurant.
Excellent in all respects. Our server was very knowledgable in all aspects of the menu and our wine selections and very pleasant. Overall a very nice experience.
Fresh food. Sophisticated. Delicious.
Loved our round table for six. Our waitress was excellent and the food melted in our mouths. The oysters on the half shell - yummy! Six friends from CHS Class of ‘60 enjoying a wonderful evening. The restaurant is beautiful! Try the Bryan cocktail, yum!
Great cocktails and wine
A few oysters
Diver scallop appetizer
Shared Cesar salad
Loved the place
Great service too
Best dinner in Coronado! Great service and delicious food.
Exquisitely prepared foods; well thought out menu; knowledgeable, friendly and well mannered wait staff; a true gem in the land of showy establishments without substance. Would love to have this restaurant back home on the east coast!
The food was great as well as the service. You won’t be disappointed with any selection on the menu. That said , the choices were a bit limited. And, there doesn’t seem to be a lot of choice for small children on the menu.
This place was great. The food was awesome (great appetizers and great, house made pasta). And the service was even better. We will be back soon and many times.
Best restaurant in Coronado for food service and ambiance. Have brought friends and family and celebrated events there.
The restaurant was generally quite good (especially the service), but we made the mistake of showing up on a Friday night, when they apparently always have a singer "entertaining" the patrons. The noise was absolutely DEAFENING, so much so that we were going to leave until they offered a table in the very back. I've already developed a terrible ongoing issue with tinnitus (constant ringing in the ears) ... a chronic condition often caused by being exposed to extremely loud noises over time. Why so many restaurants fail to understand the dangers of of these explosive amplifiers is well beyond me. At least turn the music down by at least 50%, as there's no need to propel us through the walls. Completely ruins a meal to be exposed that!! So if you're brave enough to head to Martelia on a Friday night, be sure to bring along some noise-cancelling headphones!
The overall experience was good. There was entertainment in the small bar area. The singer was very loud and could be heard throughout the restaurant. Made it difficult to carry on a conversation.
The food was wonderful. The service was great.
We went on a Friday night. Made it in time for happy hour at the bar before being seated at our table. Fantastic HH specials including $20 bottles of terrific Italian wines. Smoked negroni, lobster stuffed squash blossoms were other treats we enjoyed. Pasta dishes for dinner were creative, comforting, delicious. Right size portions. And really good live music! Going back for sure.
Fabulous food and service!!!
Maretalia doesn't disappoint. This was our second visit from Santa Maria CA.
First time to try Maretalia. It was great! We had a great experience! We had reservations and we were seated right away. We really liked our waitress. She was very sweet and helpful! I wish I remembered her name! The scallop appetizer was so so good! We had a great Banfi italian wine and our main courses were excellent as well. It's actually a really big restaurant! Several different areas/rooms they seat you in. Our room was a bit quiet and we would have liked a little more "atmosphere", but overall we loved it and will be back!
The food was okay and the service was pretty good but the menus was pretty limited. The noise level was extremely loud. Very expensive for the food they serve. Gave it a try but wouldn’t recommend it.
This is my new favorite restaurant in Coronado.
Great service from Lauren and Dallas, and others. We were treated like good friends.
Everything was delicious.
Food was great and the service was better! I would recommend it.
Although I generally hate fixed price holiday menus, the chef at Maretalia hit this Valentine menu out of the park. Add to that the outstanding service and it was the perfect dining experience.
Valentine’s Day fixed price menu was very expensive for enjoyment received. Entree was too rich, was average, and dessert was sub par. All this for an $85 fixed price. We didn’t order drinks that night but the total cost was over $200. Based on this evening, not my kind of restaurant.
What an incredible night! The staff was AMAZING, great food, and beautiful atmosphere!! Thank you!!!
The restaurant is beautiful, and the food quality is excellent.
Bruce & Ignacio were spectacular! They took great care of us and the food was excellent!
I love this restaurant. It is modern and inviting whether it is family or an exciting new date. The food is delicious and fresh. The staff are friendly and accommodating. The setting is both inside and outside. I have dined here for different occasions and I have enjoyed myself thoroughly.
Food was amazing and service was great with friendly staff.
We think your food is outstanding and personnel helpful and welcoming. We are becoming regulars (live in Coronado), brought out daughter in for dinner and will be bringing 2 different sets of friends this Friday and Sunday for dinner!
Keep up the good work!
Had a great dinner with friends. Excellent food and drinks.
I highly recommend this dining experience!
Travis was outstanding and the fresh pasta was great. We are locals and will return!
Wow, could not be more impressed with a restaurant! We were welcomed and engaged in a welcome conversation by the Maître D’. After being seated, we were told immediately our cork fee would be comped because we are new residents to the island.
Our server, Travis was welcoming, friendly and informative. We weren’t rushed but Travis was attentive and available. After an amazing meal of lobster stuffed squash blossoms and shrimp with campanille and lobster malfadine, we were given tiramisu on the house!
Everything was top notch, we have a new fave island restaurant!!