We sat at a round table on the right side of the glass enclosed dining area and the one and only complaint we had was that the strong sunlight was shining directly into two of the guests eyes seated against the wall for 30-40 minutes. A window shade or denser and taller trees outside would remedy this situation. Otherwise, everything was perfect.

We had a wonderful time at Maninos for dinner. Nicole at the bar was so personable & our drinks were perfect. Our waitress was very pleasant & our meal was very good.

Perfect atmosphere and quality on the service, attention

Had a great celebration for the ladies bdays.

Amazing dining experience from the service to the food, drinks and ambiance dining outdoors comfortably in October. Our server was extremely helpful, polite and did a wonderful job. The food was amazing, as always.

Have been going there for years. Consistently excellent food and service

As always the food & service were great
Noisy but I guess since we had dinner so late it’s bound to happen-

Consistent very good. Attentive staff. Food very good

Great Staff, Delicious Food. Solminer was knowledgeable and talented as he performed a wonderful bottle opening.

Great evening.

Great service, nice atmosphere, good food

Our server, Destiny, was exceptional. She was very attentive, personable and extremely efficient.
We were seated against a wall so the noise level was more bearable than a table in the center of the room. The burrata special was delicious as were the the baked clams. Dinners were delicious too.
Prices for food are on the high end but cocktail prices were ridiculously high.
Overall, it was a great restaurant and we will return.

Very expensive Manning’s in Oakfale more reasonable and a better menu

It was a very nice evening. The and service fantastic.

Food was excellent. My drink could have been stronger.

Food was great, nice selection, service was great. Wait for table 20 minutes past reservation time. Loud. Pricey, but the food is worth the expense.

Always great food, great service and beautiful atmosphere!

Always a great dining experience...

Mannino's never disappoints! The food, service and decor are all on point. The upstairs outside dining is the way to go weather permitting. The calamari, grilled pulpo and meatballs are all great appetizers. The chicken rollatini, veal chop are great specials.

The food was very good, but it was very noisy and it was expensive italian

Had a wonderful, relaxed dinner with four friends last night. Everything was perfect!

My first time at Manninos and I thought it was absolutely delicious! Can't wait to go back.

We had a reservation for 8 people, 6 of whom had never been there. Everyone was thrilled with the food, service and ambiance. Warm friendly greeting the minute we walked in. Delicious food. Fantastic waiter.
We will be back

I have dined here previously numerous times with friends and family, because of the food and atmosphere were to everone's liking. However, this past Saturday was a big disappointment. My recent experience there last Saturday started out with myself and my guest being told to wait at the bar despite having reservations, and it was a good 15 minutes there (this has never happened before). Then, we were seated downstairs at a table near the bar area and they air conditioning was high and the vent right above me, blowing directly on me. Brought this to my server's attention and she assured me management we turn it down. However, this did not happen. I then had to insist we be moved to which we were outside to one of the few tables overlooking Jericho Turnpike behind the bar; never happened before either and was not the best environment. The service and quality of food not so good as previous. Lastly, they started playing club music in the restaurant at such a high volume (and I do go to lounges and bars and am not a complainer) that I thought I was in a nightclub and not an Italian restaurant. It was so bad I and my GF had to finish quickly and leave. I almost never complain, and don't know if others have noticed the same thing; but under these circumstances I will not returning here. Very sad.

It’s starting to get to expensive don’t get me wrong but I can go buy the water and spend less.

Excellent food and service. Everyone enjoyed themselves

It was a birthday celebration
Eating outside was a bit noisy from the traffic
My friends have issues with stairs & so had to deal with the stairs or we couldn’t eat outdoors.
Otherwise it was a very enjoyable meal.

Good food in the neighborhood.

Truly some of the BEST Italian food on Long Island. Beautiful restaurant with a lively, attractive bar crowd, great service and an owner who is IN the kitchen making sure that the food is always AMAZING. The clams Oreganata are the best ever and rival anything from legendary Don Pepe's. Desserts are grand, creative and DELICIOUS!

We had such a nice time catching up over the years we haven’t seen each other. Laughed and drank and ate! Great atmosphere.

Service was attentive. Food was excellent. The fireworks display for our birthday celebration was incredible. Thank you.

Food was excellent as always

Everyone who works here is courteous and friendly. Food was excellent. Relaxing and enjoyable.

Good meal but pricey for what you get.

If you want the most exquisite steak around, eat at manninos

Took a friend to lunch for her birthday at Mannino's Commack. We were planning to sit outside but the weather was hot and humid so we asked the person seating us inside to find a table away from other diners. She seated us in the back garden room at a corner table and we were very comfortable keeping our distance from other diners. The food was delicious and the wait staff was very accommodating and friendly. My friend's birthday dessert came with a huge sparkler candle. It was awesome.

Always an outstanding experience!

David Our Server Was Amazing! Very Attentive And Gave Great Suggestions On What To Get.

Was supposed to be a special birthday celebration. Asked on reservation and conformation to be sure to celebrate and surprise my guest at dessert. Also requested main dining room - explained I was a regular at Oakdale but had never been to Commack.

Bottom line is worst experience. Sat at worst table smaller than child’s table in worst dining area near exit rather than the main beautiful dining room which I requested as a special birthday dinner and was told I would be accommodated graciously by the hostess that conformed my reservation by phone that day.

Service was blah, could barely understand waiters English, tried to clear table literally every 3-4 mins to push us out and dropped off dessert with no candle or fanfare.

Beyond disappointed / will never eat at either location again.

David our server was excellent and food was delish