Bring the restaurant to you. Order and pay for food directly on OpenTable.
We are now pleased to offer Summer Dining on our Newly Expanded Outdoor Patio.
-Veranda & Back Patio Al Fresco Seating (NOT AVAILABLE DURING INCLEMENT WEATHER- THIS IS UNCOVERED DINING. ALL RESERVATIONS MADE IN THIS AREA WILL BE CANCELLED WHEN RAINING.
-Private Cabana Dining (Seats up to 10 Guests- No Additional Fee to Dine. Please visit our website for answers to questions. Bookings for these units must be done directly with the restaurant by calling 631-267-5916)
-Open Air Tent Dining
I•T•A Kitchen is a new modern chic dining space located in the heart of downtown Bay Shore. This open concept space has a beautiful mosaic tiled bar, modern brass lighting, with a black and white theme throughout the restaurant. Salvatore Sorrentino formerly of Matteo’s Family Style Restaurants & Andrea’s 25 is bringing the first Italian Fare to Bay Shore Village.
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Contactless payment available
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Every thing was so delicious and amazing from beginning to end from appetizers to dinner….and our waiter Chris the best.
ITA never disappoints! we got to sit outside and enjoy the beautiful outdoor patio. Service and food was amazing!
ITA never disappoints! Their outside is beautifully decorated & you can hear their dj loud & clear! The server Anthony is fantastic- we’ve had him twice now & we’ll definitely ask for him again!
The food from appetizer to dessert is delish!
100% recommend for Italian in Bay Shore!
Food is outstanding. Beyond outstanding actually. Outdoor setting is amazing. Service, however, was unfortunately horrible and disappointing. Maybe it was an off night and they were understaffed? All I know is we had to ask for basic things such as a cup a bunch of times, when dinner was served one of my party’s dinner was forgotten about until we had to ask where it was, etc. Again, the food is amazing and will definitely be back. Hopefully the service last night was an aberration.
Excellent food and service . Our second time here . Drive all the way from Port Jeff - wish they were closer !!
Awesome menu had grilled cheese appetizer out of this world . Freddy gnocchi one of a kind ! The cocktails! Omg fabulous ! Our server Chris was outstanding ! Can’t wait to go back !
Waitress was very friendly and attentive. Had a great evening and the food was perfect.
Food was good, but the service was very slow. Took almost 15 minutes just to get water at the table! Young man who was the runner (I think) had long dirty nails too. Not something I would usually notice, but very obvious as he was pouring the water.
The food was incredible! The grilled cheese app was amazing. Our server Anthony was great and so attentive.
We made an outdoor reservation for a busy Saturday night. Due to the weather, we couldn’t sit outside, but they called us in advance to modify our reservation based on our preferences. We decided to still go and sit indoors at the same time as our original reservation. Based on reviews and pictures, our expectations were high and they were exceeded. Everything we ate and drank was delicious. The wait staff was fantastic. We look forward to returning in the future!
it was very fancy i liked, def recommend and would want to go again
Always the best! The food is amazing and I love that you can order things that aren’t on the menu. They are always so accommodating! Service is impeccable, Ryan the manager always aims to please. Their outdoor patio area is beautiful and a nice way to enjoy your evening!
Took my wife here in a date night and the food was amazing the service was great overall a very good dining experience and we will be going back
The place smelled musty and felt damp from the second you walked in. They sat us at a table next to the window where the cushions haven't been cleaned since 2015. The bread they gave us before appetizers was damp and definitely stale. We ordered the anti-pasta platter which had deli sliced provolone, canned black olives and wilted arugula. The chef has clearly phoned in in type of authentic Italian dining trading it in for pathetic, cheap alternatives in order to try to save a buck. I ordered the Vodka Chicken Parm serves over penne. The vodka sauce was flavorless. My wife had the linguine with clam sauce. It was over a pound of pasta swimming in a watered down sauce. She barely touched it. Everything was so bad that we did not order a second round of drinks and chose to skip dessert all together. We will never come back to this place and we will tell everyone we know to avoid eating here as well. Downtown Bayshore has so many other great eateries to go to. 0.0 score.
I’ll start by saying the food was excellent. They seemed to be struggling with staffing issues. Our waitress was stretched thin and didn’t have much knowledge of the menu at all. We had to ask several times for simple things, like a fork or some extra bread. The phone and online orders are constantly ringing at the hostess station and is quite annoying. We will give them a second chance because of the food.
Excellent food and ambiance, staff very nice. Loved the outdoor space, perfect for a date night.
The bartender Ashley was amazing! Super friendly, helpful, & attentive :)
Randomly came to this restaurant, and was blown away. From the friendly and helpful staff, to the delicious food, everything was perfect. We will definitely return.
This is our new go to spot!! Everything was amazing. Food , service , ambiance.
The food was fantastic - get the pesto truffle ravioli. Truffle is not overpowering and flavor is incredible (get extra bread to dip in the leftover sauce and thank me later)
Fourth time here and ITA never disappoints! My friends loved it! The food is delicious and the service is great! We had the two antipasto platters! The baked clams, shrimp and calamari platter is a must!!
Everything was so good and the aesthetic was so nice. Strong tasty drinks and delicious food.
Trifle Gnocchi was lite and delicious, chicken picante outrageous fresh nice flavors, all other parties were very happy with their meals. There priced right and portions are just a little extra, for others to taste! Our waiter Chris again was outstanding and knowledgeable about the dishes, he was very accommodating. Can’t wait to go back.
Julio was amazing. The food as always was delish. Will be back again and again!
You have to get the homemade ricotta gnocchi. It is to die for! The food is absolutely amazing.
The food is very good, but the service is very slow.
We enjoyed the atmosphere definitely. The food was very good but the service wasn’t the best. The last time we were there was the same problem. It’s too bad because the price we paid for 2 people, which was close to $250, we should’ve had much better attention and service. Other than that, it was good
Met friends for dinner and enjoyed the experience. This is the second time we’ve dined at ITA and we weren’t disappointed. The food was very good and the service was great! Love their linguine with white clam sauce! One suggestion is better chairs would make it more comfortable.
ITA has been on my list to try and was so excited to finally get to go for my birthday. WOW! first off the place is beautiful inside and outside. The food and drinks were out of this world! We will 100% be returning and can’t wait to try more things.
Branzino special was delicious!
Had dinner out back in a cabana, very nice atmosphere. The apps and entrees were delicious.
We will be back!
We sat outside, which was very nice. The food was good, not great. Server was lovely. The one dessert ordered took over 20 minutes to come out, so without asking she deducted it from our check.
Every time we come here the food is amazing, service is awesome!
Wondersful staff. Attentive but not annoying. Food was delicious. Each dish was yummy. Drinks were on spot. Watermelon and pineapple drinks were refreshing.
Food was delicious!
This restaurant was dark & dingy. The picture on the website that shows a nicely decorated area, is one corner of the front window & has one table for 2.
The rest of the restaurant gives a feel of being in an unfinished basement. Walls are black, previous floor was torn up & nothing put over it. It is now, patchy concrete.
Table rocked back & forth. Waiter was very difficult to understand when he was telling us the specials.
I ordered a veal chop, that was described as breaded & pan fried. It was so dark and looked more like deep fried. I did not eat it. Brought it home, but it will wind up in the trash, along with the $44 it cost.
My cappuccino was mostly foam. The gelato was thick & heavy, not the consistency of any gelato I ever had before! I really don’t know what it was.
It was our Anniversary & wanted to try somewhere new. We will not be going back!
My drink was good. I had the Italian Margarita.
I went for my birthday and the food was ABSOLUTELY amazing! The waitress was so nice and gave amazing recommendations! 10/10 would recommend this place to everyone! definitely one of my favorite spots ☺️
Excellent! Food was great and the service was amazing.
The food never disappoints and the ambience was peaceful. Exactly what was needed to end the week.
food excellent however for a quiet sunday night the service was slower than expected, but that did not take away from the experience as we were in no rush
ITA Kitchen does offer delivery in partnership with Uber Eats. ITA Kitchen also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 267-5916.
ITA Kitchen is rated 4.5 stars by 340 OpenTable diners.
ITA Kitchen does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://itakitchenbayshore.com/?wc-api=wc_stripe.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.