H2O: Seafood & Sushi

H2O is a Smithtown gem, the seafood is always fresh and the chef is creative in his presentations.

Overall experience was very nice. A little pricy...but so goes nice dining.
Great table, great atmosphere. We will return. Brought family visiting from VA, they loved it.
3 of the 4 meals were over the top fantastic. I personally ordered Lobster Bisq and was a little surprised it was 100% puree and no lobster pieces. I also ordered the Fish & Chips, which I expected the fish batter coating to be crispy, however it was kind of soggy, although great taste.
Donald Mueller

We brought friends, it was there first time and Steven made the whole night exceptional, from when we walked in , until it was time to leave . The food and service was amazing , we’ve been coming to H2O for about 7 years always happy just wanted to let you know !

Great service and food fair prices we enjoy
Going there great specials during the week

Always great food.
Always great service!

Have eaten there on many occasions and the food was outstanding. This time the Bronzino was like shoe leather and the special Halibut was very dry. Disappointing. On the upside the service was superb.

Nice evening with friends.
Music outside while we enjoyed a cocktail together.
Great dinner inside with excellent food and service!

Will go there again!

It was my third visit to H2O in Smithtown. It’s always a pleasure, mostly because of the friendly servers. They make having dinner comfortable and fun.

Stephen our waiter was excellent and cery professional. Made the experience really nice!! Food was great and atmosphere was also great!

Food was good but not exceptional. Hadn't eaten there in a while and forgot the noise level was pretty high.

Our waitress was terrific. The food was excellent and we loved the live music.

Wednesday wine dinner
Delicious swordfish entree, yellowtail crudity appetizer and creme brûlée’s cheesecake for desert with north fork wine pairings.
Outstanding

Decided to have an early Sunday dinner of surf and tyrf for two. No surprises. Excellent as always.

Nick was our server and he was amazing. The only downside to our experience was that we requested outdoor seating in our reservation, but when we arrived there was only indoor available unless we were willing to wait. This was disappointing and I’d have to reconsider before reserving here again if I want to sit outside.

What great food choices from the menu. We ordered so much and loved everything . I can’t wait to go back

Our dinner was very tasty and of good quality. The wait staff was extremely accommodating, professional and friendly.

We went on a Sunday for the Surf & Turf special. The food and service were outstanding!

We celebrated our anniversary with great service and delicious food!

Anniversary

Always great food and service superb!.. Our go to!!!!

We all had the halibut special - it lacked flavor, disappointing given the price. It was the first time I have ever been disappointed there

The staff were great! We had a wonderful dinner.

One of our family favorites! Love the surf and turf!

Delicious meal and great service

Our waiter Nick was amazing. We went on a Monday night yet he had great energy and made some nice recommendations.

Wonderful food and atmosphere. Service was on point and I will be back soon. The surf and turf was awesome

We LOVE h20 all the employees are great. Very well run and always a pleasure and delicious

Service was indifferent at best. main items took over 30 minutes to arrive. They did apologize but it took 15 minutes later to finally arrive. Also staff could have given price on the 3 pound lobster (70$)
I still would have purchased as it was a gift to my guest but it would have been better to know in advance.

Ron the manager couldn't be nicer and accommodating.

Food was fresh and excellent. Recommend that you save room for dessert

food was delicious. I had tuna, my husband had sushi and lobster roll. We loved the popovers and the wine was delicious. We also enjoyed the waiter. Pleasant and not overbearing.

Birthday dinner

It was my daughter’s birthday. She was offered free dessert but declined because were all so full from the meal. They even offered to box it so she could take it home.

Food was excellent and service was OUTSTANDING !!!

Outstanding wine dinner. We were also visited by GM, Ron, which gave us the opportunity to share our positive feedback. Superior service and food make this an excellent choice, particularly for the Wednesday wine dinners.

We were seated near the bar, which wasn’t excellent for noise level, but it is hard to quibble when everything else was outstanding.

Wow Wednesday night pre fix best dinner deal on long island!

Food is so so .. and very pricey for what we get .. almost close to 100$ per person.. feel like it wasn’t worth it at all .. price is as high as Manhattan .. but service is good and nice ..

Food was mediocre at best! They ran out of the specials at 7:30, then ran out of Swordfish! Lobster Roll we ordered was soggy and very disappointing. They have been much better

Service was great and food was delicious as well!! Thank u