H2O Seafood & Sushi - East Islip
Book your next event with us
Very disappointed with the service, food, and the over all experience at H2O in East Islip. I expected a lot more coming from the Bolsen Group.
Found plastic wrap in the food like it was taken from the freezer to the microwave. Disgusting
We have been coming here for quite a while. The food is always excellent! This last visit was not so good as service was extremely slow and a few mistakes were made by the server. They didn’t even give us our doggy bag so I didn’t bother to ask. We were very disappointed to say the least. A diner has better service.
Outstanding, great service and excellent food....I highly recommend you to try H20....,!
Our brunch this past Sunday to celebrate my wife's birthday was spectacular! Service and food were fantastic. We'll be back!!
Came here for New Year's Eve. The 4 course meal was such a good price I couldn't pass up on it. The food was well worth the money. I'm coming back here again for another dinner
I came here for NYE and I was very disappointed with the rushed service and quality of food. Typically I’m impressed with both the service and food here but I should have known better than to go out to a priced fixed meal. I would have thought the experience at a Bolson Group restaurant would be superb but it was not. It was disappointing
Always delicious, creative food. Sushi is inventive and so fresh. Service is wonderful. Love the popovers!
Food was very good. Service was not great. Bussers kept trying to take our plates when we weren’t finished. They also served our main meal while we were still eating our appetizer.
The best service I had was when I first got there at the bar. The bartender was wonderful.
H20 is truly a gem in E. Islip. The Boehlsen restaurant group has done it again. Enjoy coming for happy hour or dinner with friends. Always top notch.
Have eaten here several times and the food is always consistent!
Our overall assessment of our dining experience is somewhat below average.
The interior design and finish is nicely done and contemporary keeping with an upbeat vibe.
The service is excellent and in keeping with a good Manhattan dining experience. My dinner did nor appear or taste fresh. We ordered your stuffed flounder with scallops and crabmeat. The fish was dried out and the stuffing featured bread crumbs. Not a good value for the dollar. Salads were good and apps as well but very small in portion for the apps. From our observations to sit at the bar and order sushi and a cocktail would be the way to go.
Good dinner and service. Reported a large bone in my lobster salad and chef offered a free dessert for both us to make up for it.
Everyone was very polite and attentive. Went for a Birthday dinner, waitress was very personable. I had questions on the wine list and she quickly had someone come over to explain the menu and even offered me some tastings. Food was amazing with great flavor depths, plus the service was quick. The chef even came out to say Happy Birthday. Highly recommended for a great dining experience!
Wonderful, fresh food. Service was amazing. Lobster was fresh and the creme brulee yummy.
The chef really understands the sensitive, discerning palate! I savored every bite of each course of my meal! We both enjoyed the whole experience.
I have eaten here in the past and the food was great. Monday is lobster night but the lobster was dry and over cooked. The was ,bread tasteless and the stuffing was just unseasoned. It bothers me to spend money and not enjoy my experience. Not impressed with food at all.
always love to eat at h2o. actually our favorite for many years!
The service and food was excellent. The staff was attentive without being pushy. The food was cooked and seasoned just enough.
Great dinner! Loved the food and the service. We had the anniversary special with wine pairing and it was great. Monk fish appetizer was awesome and so was the salmon entree. Save room for the donuts, so good.
We had a great experience!! The nicest service, very good food!! We’ll be back!!!
The entire staff was wonderful and our waitress did a fantastic job seeing that all of our needs were met, even before we asked. They made me feel special on my birthday!
A little pricey for our budget, but we will return again!
H2O was an unexpected delight! We made a reservation with another couple to try out their Anniversary Dinner Menu. The selections were very appealing and we had a difficult time settling on our choices. And the wine tastings that went along with the menu were varied and all that we tried were very good. Our server, Ashley, was very attentive, knowledgeable and efficient. Her recommendations were spot on! All four of us were absolutely pleased with the experience. We will be back.
Everything was "acceptable " but not excellent. I made a reservation in the morning for 7 PM and they gave us the last seat in the back by the door! The waitress came over to ask various questions multiple times and interrupted our conversation a lot. The food was okay. I didn't want to take home what we didn't finish so that tells a lot.
Food was delicious and the service was wonderful. Highly recommend the H2O roll and the Chilean sea bass. Also the jalapeño margaritas are delicious.
We frequently overlook H2O which is around the block from us when trying to decide where to eat out., but will ensure this gets put back in the rotation. Ate here on a Friday night, train was delayed so we were 15 minutes late, no issues being seated. Great cocktails and attentive service. Had the cajun dusted shrimp which tasted great but could have used more heat for my taste. Overall a lovely place for date night.
It was great. Service was amazing.
Celebrated my 40th birthday with a brunch. The staff was amazing, the food was great, and they gave me a generous gift for my birthday which was completely unexpected. I highly recommend this location!
Three times a charm. Can’t stop, won’t stop. We were so impressed with Restaurant Week food and wine, we went for the third time in two weeks. Had sushi appetizers and stuffed flounder. Once again, great food, wine and service. We are addicted.
The food took way too long to come out when the place was super empty.
It was so good the day before, went again for the Restaurant Week menu. Had the chicken with wine pairings. Again, great food, great wine, great service and value.
By far my favorite restaurant on the island. Outstanding service, food is always top notch, and our waiter even remembered us from a couple months back when we were here. Would highly recommend to any body looking for an overall amazing restaurant.
Went for Restaurant Week. Had the steak with wine pairings. Excellent food, wine and service.
Food was very good, a bit pricey . We are upstairs, it was a little
Loud but overall it was a good nite!!
Food and Service was amazing. Ashley, our server, was very sweet & never missed a beat. Hopefully, you're as lucky as we were to have her when you dine there. Sandra stopped by our table and was very accommodating to our requests. The dining setup was odd but overall we had a great dining experience.
Great food & service - surprised to get a
$25 gift cert for my b’day!
A great value for restaurant week -- 3 courses with wine pairings! Delicious preparations!
We have been to H2O several times now. Always a great time. Sushi and seafood and service are spot on. look forward to going again.
We had a terrific experience at H2o. Our server Danielle was terrific, she was attentive while not being intrusive. The sushi was delicious, fresh and we'll portioned. I highly recommend this restaurant.
The service was great but the food was just average at best. We had lobster thermidor which had dried out lobster meat and a watery sauce, disappointed.