Safely accommodates all pandemic recommendations while still offering great food and service.
Delicious food, great service, lovely patio atmosphere!
Always a great experience!
Everly was very careful about safety from coronavirus transmission. I was impressed and appreciative of their efforts, which included a table of clean pens, hand sanitizer, and sanitizing spray, all employees wearing masks, social distancing of tables, and the option of using an online menu rather than a traditional, shared menu. Plus the food was great, as always.
First time dining in a restaurant since the pandemic. Staff was very friendly and did a great job explaining the efforts used to keep everyone safe. The Saturday brunch menu had lots of choices. Good food, even better service.
Bloody mary’s could use some work. But absolutely loved my gnocchi dish! Along with the kimchi carrots, so delicious flavorful and spicy!
Food was good, service was excellent (and I’m a tough grader) - friendly, attentive and helpful.
I always love Everly. Great food, especially with the new menu refresh (although I will forever miss their Grouper Reuben.) Good atmosphere too, I would recommend sitting outside if possible as their bar opens up to the outdoors.
Wonderful staff. But, but lovely patio. The team is doing a great job setting up the restaurant/patio to maintaining social distance. Amazing avocado toast and delicious cocktails!
Such delicious food, beautiful atmosphere, friendly and accommodating staff!
They had great safety procedures in place, we felt very comfortable dining there. We come in a lot and the food and staff are always awesome. Looking forward to going again soon!
I’m impressed that my daughter who doesn’t like vegetables, and myself, a longtime pescatarian , could find 2 apps and two entrees to happily split and she thought everything was delicious and asked, “ how did they make vegetables taste so good? “😀
It was my first time venturing out recently and felt comfortable with the safety measures they’re taking. Great service and cocktails as always!
First time out for months because of COVID-19. Appreciated safety measures. Excellent service. Fun to be served! Sat outside, so there was some noise, but didn’t matter. Highly recommend.
server was great and so was bartender. The salad was great and my partner's chicken was awesome.
We had a lovely dinner for four and when our server realized that one of us was celebrating a birthday, she brought our shared (delicious flourless chocolate cake slice) dessert with lighted candle. AND they comped the dessert! Classy...!!
The food never disappoints here. We each had a kind of salad (his kale and beets; mine Brussels sprouts and kale). They were both delicious but quite distinct from one another. Very attentive service. We're glad that this is a restaurant we can walk to (in the warmer months).
Great food. I really enjoy the atmosphere here and the brunch menu is varied and delicious.
The service and food is fantastic. We love the atmosphere and staff. One of our favorite restaurants!
Lovely experience, excellent food, delightful service, great environment!
Every time I am in Madison I ALWAYS make time for a visit to Everly! It never disappoints!
Everly's food and service is great. But don't go for week-end brunch unless you can tolerate noise.
I was expecting better. It wasn't poor, but I had heard rave reviews. Maybe it was just a bad night. The highlight was the Brussels Sprout appetizer. Next time I go I will eat two of those for dinner! We did wait 20 minutes past our reservation time, so the desserts were comped, which was nice, but the desserts weren't all that good. The Creme Bruleé was more like pudding, sorta grainy. The chocolate cake was pretty dry. I'm pretty sure these aren't made in house.
I hope that next time I can write a better review, and we will give in another chance.
Prompt service, excellent food and a friendly staff
2nd time having weekend brunch. Love this place! Bacon and Eggs Bloody Mary...what more do you need to know?! Great mix with bacon infused vodka, a deviled egg and cheese curd. Oh...the best part? A thick cut piece of bacon. Bacon at Everly is fantastic. All brunch items we have tried are outstanding in portion size, presentation and flavor. Can be very busy and only knock us there is not much space to wait in their foyer. Parking can also be difficult as it’s in a strip mall with other businesses. Over...very pleased with Everly and highly recommend!
Everly has become our new go to place in Madison, especially if we are headed to an event at UW. Great vibe, great service and great food. Highly recommend for a great casual dining experience. The Brussels Sprout Salad is the BOMB and my wife LOVE the roasted chicken.
WE love the host -- Ben! He is always so welcoming!
Premium prices for sensible portions. Very spicy! Must make reservation if you want wheelchair seating as mostly booths and high tables.
I was pleased with the menu having varied options for vegans. I would recommend this restaurant in the future.
Loved this meal! The veggie burger is amazing and pro tip add a fried egg!
Another great experience! Everly is always consistently good. We went Valentine's weekend, and it wasn't any more crowded than it usually is. The good was great. I had the shrimp and grits, and the shrimp was very fresh! Wine is always good, and we enjoyed dessert as well.
We enjoy the food and atmosphere at Everly; the bartenders and wait staff are friendly and pleasant. We enjoy sitting at the bar, but most recently when we were there, it appears there are one or two too many stools at the bar, so that it was very crowded once all the stools were occupied, and a man next to me brushed against me several times due to the crowding. This diminished the experience a little.
Food and drinks were good.
Awesome experience, love the ambiance and our server Emily was delightful.
A great deal of the food items can be made gluten free, which is really nice.
We will absolutely go back to Everly
Great vibe, great food. Server was excellent. Highly recommend the Brussel Sprout Salad, awesome
Really enjoyed the whole experience from the drinks to the appetizers to the main meal. Will definately come again. Appreciated the vibe and relaxed atmosphere.
First time visiting Everly with my wife, daughter and her friend. We had a reservation but it still took a couple minutes to get our booth. No big deal. The place was packed. Our server was very attentive with drink orders, food orders and water refills. The bacon and eggs bloody Mary was phenomenal. Great bacon in general! Food overall was very satisfying and very well executed. They have a team of food runners who bring all entrees to the table at the same time. Nice touch vs one diner waiting for their meal while others have been served. Value for the money was good. Overall we had a very nice time and with the location being very close to Edgewood College, we will be going back often! Parking can be a bit tricky.
This is our favorite weekend brunch stop, hands down! Recommend reservations! Get the Hangtown Fry and the hot cake! Oh, and the mint iced coffee!
This place it always great! I have eaten here whenever we are in town, and it is always a great experience. Food is fresh and prepared perfectly, waitstaff if polite and helpful
I love Everly and we've had nothing but great experiences in the past. However, we went for brunch this past weekend and I was so disappointed. The service took awhile and our food was not good. My eggs benedict was undercooked and had no seasonings. And our medium-temp burger was cooked to rare.
Such a great night with a girlfriend! We did the happy hour menu and highly recommend the tuna fried rice and truffle fries. We’ll be back!
Everly offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (608) 416-5242.
Everly is rated 4.6 stars by 282 OpenTable diners.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.