Don's Pomeroy House
Flat Iron Steak
eight ounce center cut, yukon gold mashed, lump crab, asparagus, barnaise sauce
Maine Lobster Tail
five to six ounce cold water tail, fingerling potatoes, asparagus, champagne beurre blanc
baked crab cake, maine lobster-corn relish, smoked tomato beurre blanc
Brief lunch for two inside. Great service. Food was very good. Love the ambiance.
Great food, even better service!
It was a great experience and we will defiantly go back.
The food and service exceeded expectations. Each course of the meal was very enjoyable. The waitress was very pleasant and personable, providing wonderful guidance as to menu item questions. We had an overall OUTSTANDING experience.
I had the surf and turf. Lobster was awesome! Filet mignon was unseasoned and dry, the vegetables weren’t real good either. Overall I’d give the food 3 out of 5 stars. Price was pretty steep for the quality.
Absolutely Fabulous Restaurant. Great Service, Wonderful Food, Great Atmosphere. If you want a great upscale experience this is the place you won’t forget. This is my second time visiting. The first was just as good. So happy we discovered this gem!!
This was our third visit in two months. Everything about this restaurant is perfect; from the restaurant itself (a beautiful old home), the food, the service, the friendly as well as professional staff, as well as their covid precautions. For those that enjoy patio dining; the patio is beautiful and is a very large area; clearly an area that is well-planned and not just thrown together to advertise "outdoor dining."
This restaurant is fantastic!! I've eaten here on several occasions and it gets better every time.
We went to Don's Pomeroy House for our 1st Anniversary and it was fantastic. My wife loved her seared scallops and my braised short rib was outstanding. We got the calamari appetizer and it was better than it sounded on the menu! Because it was our anniversary, the waiter brought out a complimentary giant eclair for dessert. It was generous and delicious. We don't have a single bad thing to say about Don's Pomeroy!
We have always had a good experience here. Food has been excellent and the servers are always friendly.
Table spacing was borderline for being too close, but otherwise OK. We had a very nice time!
This food was served with quality service in an upscale environment. It just melted in your mouth! Don’t skip the chip and dip appetizer. Although as a result we couldn’t finish the delicious dinner, we have a wonderful leftover meal the next day. The lobster tail was cooked to perfection.
Great ambiance, great service, intimate atmosphere. Always our choice for special occasions.
Very intimate setting. We sat in one of the bookcase booths indoors. The wine we had was amazing. I got the chilean sea bass at the recommendation of our server and it was delicious. The crab cake that came with it was one of the best I've ever had. We live in downtown Chicago and we were visiting family and this restaurant is just as good as any in the city.
Everything was great. Loved having the unique experience of dining in a historic house. The food was absolutely delicious. Loved it. Will definitely be back for another special occasion.
It was a wonderful experience, food and service were excellent!
All four of us had something different and all 4 meals along with 3 different Apps were all excellent- food all came in a very timely manner and the waite staff was a 10 plus-
If we did not live so far away (MENTOR) we would go back frequently
Went for a celebration send off, loved the drinks, food, and server was polite and funny.
My wife's dinner was excellent. I made the mistake of selecting the Lake Erie something or other, with brussels. The breading? was rock hard and the sprouts were dry as snuff.
Our waitress did not return to ask how the meal was and no one filled our water glass until we were about to receive our surprise desert which was great. I really should have flagged down someone to have my meal replaced,but motored on and finished half of it.
I should have had the lobster that my wife had. She said it was delicious! Our waitress did give us a discount and apologized,
I will make a better choice of dinner when we return. We have had many good meals at the House in the past and I am sure we will in the future.
Wow, What a Surprise Experience. Never having had the pleasure of experiencing this Outstanding Restaurant I was blown away with their Outstanding Food, Drink Pours, Wine Selection. This is a True Gem in that area of Ohio. We will make this a returning restaurant for sure.They even made special accommodations based on my guest being handicapped. I truly can recommend this place for any dining enjoyment experience you might be looking for.
The food was fantastic as usual and the service was amazing, would def recommend to a friend!
Outstanding service, outstanding food, a good weekend crowd, we will be back.
Romantic place for a anniversary. Food was delicious and service was superb
This was our second time dining at Don Pomeroys. We came at an in-between time for lunch and dinner, and the servers were so sweet to allow us to order from the dinner menu. The food is outstanding and the service was some of the best I've had in the area. This is a great place for a romantic meal!
As always, the food and service was great. Our server, Tammy, is one of the best around and always makes our visit enjoyable. We will be back again soon!
The food is spot on. Everything from appetizer to desert was cooked perfectly!
We ordered The surf and turf and the Chilean Sea bass both were very good
Food is worth every penny. Great date night with my wife. Service was personal and friendly.
Great food, great service, excellent job with Covid 19 protocols
A first class dining experience.
The older I get the more I appreciate this place.
Food wasn’t great. Nothing was seasoned. It was a Monday so they were generally slow. The steak was definitely not worth the $40 charge and the surf and turf was just ok.
Great place to go to. Food and service was great. We’d definitely go back again.
Love everything about this place! Well worth it the food was amazing, servers were very friendly. Oh again the food the chef did a perfect job!!!
Wish our waiter was more attentive...took a long time to get courses served
The food was excellent, but our server was very distracted and inattentive. When we asked for a wine recommendation he just pointed to the most expensive glass on the menu. We had to wait about 15 minutes just for bread to be brought to the table even though there were only a few other diners in the restaurant.
Always treated first class. Only restaurant my wife and I will go to.
Shrimp amazing Lobsrer tail perfect
Wonderful! Food and service was excellent! Our family had a lovely time and we even stayed past closing and didn’t feel rushed at all.
Excellent place to celebrate our 22nd anniversary. The food and service were both excellent. They wished us a happy anniversary and brought out a giant complimentary eclair. Will definitely go back.
Don's Pomeroy House is rated 4.8 stars by 1552 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.