- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Contactless payment available
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Spaghetti & Meatballs
nonna's meatballs x 3, shaved parmesan
($2+). Gorgonzola, shaved parmesan, mozzarella, ricotta ($2), fresh mozzarella ($2.75) burrata ($4), goat ($3) vegan cheese (coconut based; dairy, soy, nut free) ($3)
sun-dried tomato, parmesan, pesto cream sauce
Our waitress was very good. I decided I wanted some extra red sauce. She was quick to respond and bring it to my table. She’s an asset to your restaurant! Thanks. Ted
Absolutely delicious food! Everything was amazing! The suggested wine was perfect too. Service was great! We can’t wait to go back again!
Always excellent and consistent. Pizza was superb as were salads. Service was exemplary.
Great pizza, wonderful service, nice ambiance.
Everything was superb! From waitress, food, and wine. Also their lemoncello 🍋🍸
Was at 100% indoor capacity. We had to wait 35 minutes after our reservation to be seated.
Wonderful food. Great ambience. Waiter gave us lots of time. Will definitely go back.
Service great. Pesto chicken penne had too much pesto for my taste. Mushroom ravioli is the winner!
Diavola was exceptionally good Italian food with a fun and easygoing atmosphere. Our server was knowledgeable and kind, and dessert was delicious. Leftover pizza made for a great lunch the next day. We will be going back again!
Food and service were great! Tables were a bit close together for my comfort zone during Covid.
Very nice restaurant, prior reviews helped us choose and didn't disappoint. Older establishment, quaint. Food was very tasty and flavorful, smell was great tease as we waited eagerly. Well done.
Diverse menu, plenty of options.
We recommend and think you will enjoy.
This was our first visit to Diavola, and we loved it. The staff was friendly and attentive. The food was delicious. We will definitely be back!
Great food & service
We love our local pizzeria! Great atmosphere and delicious food!
The bartenders and service was exceptional. I’d recommend getting a seat at the bar. It’s full service and you’ll be happy you did.
Service was excellent.
Everything was great.
Great service and great food. Would highly recommend. Everything we ordered was amazing.
Loved the creative pizza options. We had the pesto and pear and the Funghi.
The Funghi was definitely deep in truffle and mushroom.
My two complains are that we were celebrating a birthday, which I mentioned in the reservation and no one recognized my friends birthday. That would have definitely made it worth dining there for his birthday.
The ice tea tasted off. The server was busy and I didn’t feel like making a negative comment on my friends birthday, but he definitely did not get a refill because it was off.
Food is usually awesome. I ordered Margarita pizza, not enough sauce. Bland but wine awesome!
Amazing experience and incredible food! Will definitely return!
Pizza excellent, salad a little small for the price. Service attentive
Service was great but our dinners took a really long time. We were pretty close to the table next to us and the noise level was on the loud side. Food was all tasty except for a caprese salad that was made with tomato’s that weren’t ripe. Server did remove this from our bill- not a big deal. Patio looks nice. We’ll go back in warmer weather.
Such a great place. Excellent pizza! The real pizza!
Just wanted a nice place for a date night, and the ambiance was perfect! Pizza and wine complimented each other wonderfully. All around positive experience and will be back again!
Incredible peach Bellini and very good service. The meal choices were good, the traditional calzone and pasta dishes were well received.
Always good. Love the pizza.
Diavolo is consistently great. One of the best in the neighborhood. I’ve been several times and they have never missed!
We were in town from out of state and finding gluten free pasta made in house was a great surprise. We were staying in an area with many restaurants but opted to make a longer drive to eat here. Our family of four ordered and two pizzas, spaghetti and meatballs all came out with large servings. My dinner of gluten free pasta came out and was the size of a tapas sized meal or if I had ordered off a kids menu. Very disappointing. What was there was good, but I left hungry. When we asked the sever, he just said, "Yea, our gluten free portions are smaller." Not only smaller but at an additional cost. This small plate of a dinner should be communicated to a patron when ordering. In addition, we were sat at the same time as our friends at a different table. We ate and paid before they even received their food. Their appetizer was never even delivered. We were both disappointed in our servers and the lack of any friendliness of staff. A $100 meal out and we won't be making the drive back again.
I confirmed a reservation for a table and we were seated at the bar. There was no acknowledgement from the wait staff of the birthday that was recorded as the reason for dining on the Open Table app.
The rustic pizza was delicious. The lemoncello frozen dessert was a perfect end to a meal that had some attractive spice to at.
Expensive for very good, but not great, pizza. Still worth a visit. Split one of the pizzas though. That and a salad and then you'll have room for dessert
Always fabulous! Great pizzas, apps and pasta. Nice dinner out without breaking the bank. Highly recommend!
Stopped by this gem while visiting a friend in Indy. The food was great and the service was wonderful. Would highly recommend.
The pizza was very good however I was very disappointed about the additional charges for minor requests. For example the salad had very little dresssing and I was charged $2.00 for a small amount of extra dressing on a small salad.
There were other up charges that just ruined the entire dinning experience.
I would suggest raising the price of salads as opposed to charging for extra dressing, and may I also suggest advising customers of up-charges when "extras" are requested.
Being nickled and dimed is a horrible experience and exposes the company culture.
Great pizza - ingredients are fresh and the crust is homemade.
The restaurant was very crowded even with covid guidelines still in place. Tables are too close together
Such a great experience. The food was amazing and our service was perfect.
Great food good stop for Butler parents to take students for a quiet meal..good service and food was great!
Diavola offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (317) 820-5100.
Diavola is rated 4.8 stars by 378 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.