Obviously things are quite different now. Limited menu hard to get attention of staff due to their desire to social distance.

The restaurant has done a good job balancing social distancing guidelines and the restaurant experience.

Over priced, bland food, small portions, dirty floors

Scallops were overcooked, rubbery and tasteless. Very disappointing.

Tough to really give a review during Corona pandemic, but restaurant was empty, service was slow and the food was average at best. Hopefully things get better as the world opens back up

Came in for a birthday. I realize they just opened back up,and there was maybe 2 other tables full, but the food was not up to the same level as our last visit. Crab cakes seemed to have more filler and even had shells in them. My wife’s scallops were over cooked. Had to ask for bread twice and not once was my daughters drink refilled. Nothing special about this meal. Disappointing given the prices we paid for the meal.

Overall it was an excellent experience and we didn’t feel nervous at all being out supporting the restaurant during this pandemic. They did an excellent job.

They just opened and we were one of two couples in the whole restaurant.
Always a good experience at the Fishmarket.

All staff were wearing masks, the social distancing seating was well implemented, and the food and drinks were delicious!

It was great

Everything was pretty good until the waiter disappeared and never came back. We left cash on the table with a good tip, though

Anniversary

First official night for restaurants in Columbus. Pretty quiet since it was pretty quiet in there. Glad to see the place open.

A excellent experience. the server should be more polite in his interruptions. I was there visiting with my daughter , whom I have not seen since Thanksgiving, I was abruptly interrupted many times. otherwise, a very very fine experience.

My swordfish was prepared exactly the way I wanted. It was delicious.

Great birthday dinner and our server was phenomenal!

Honestly I was super disappointed....we went to dinner for my husbands birthday. We didn’t have to wait, not because of the reservation but because it wasn’t busy. We paid over $120 for two people without alcohol and the food was no better than I could have made at home. The best thing about the meal was the peach tea! The scallops were overcooked and nothing we ate was wow! Apparently my expectations since it is a Cameron Mitchell’s restaurant were too high. I felt bad as my husband had been wanting to try the restaurant for a really long time and when we left he said “welp, not all its cracked up to be” we could have had a better meal for a lot less money.

It seemed a little pricey, food was fabulous though. Service was a little slow.

We were seating immediately and waited on just as quickly. Our server worked hard to make sure we had all that we needed. The food was so good and there was plenty. I finished my leftovers the next day for lunch and it was still really good. We will definitely go back.

Took my family there for celebration of two birthdays....it was a Saturday at noon and no one was in the restaurant....by the time we left, perhaps two tables had been filled....prices exorbitant for a Saturday lunch to find out we could only order off the dinner menu.....so that was a bit much.

We were celebrating a birthday. The food was great. The service was mediocre. We had to repeatedly ask the waitress to refill our drinks. We bringing boxes to our table, she offered to box one person’s leftover, but when asked to bring an extra box she dropped the box off in front of the other person and walked off. The experience we had with our waitress was awkward.

Excellent across the board!!!

My husband and I went for our anniversary. This was our first time here and it was a marvelous experience. The food was amazing. My husband ordered the New York Strip, it was cooked perfectly. My husband generally uses steak sauce but this steak didn't need it. I ordered the Spicy Crispy Shrimp appetizer which was so yummy, and the Fishermans Fry. The fish was the freshest I've had in a long time. The batter on the fish was perfect, not too thick and cooked through. My husband paired his steak with a red Federalist wine that complimented his steak perfectly. I had a BlackBerry margarita that was so delicious and well balanced. The restaurant was clean and up to date. Our server was attentive but not intrusive and had a friendly disposition. All in all this place is well worth the money.

Best seafood, you can get this far from the ocean. The Carrot Cake was terrific and shareable.

We were a party of four. Three of us had no issues with any of our items. One in the aprty required her entrée to be without seasoning, and so indicated when ordering. That was not the presentation and the server wasn't particularly keen on either returning the entrée or checking back to determine if it was acceptable as presented

Excellent meal.

The food was mediocre and my martini was served to me half full. The waitress tried to rush us through our orders and meal.

The food was inconsistent. Cedar Plank salmon, lobster bisque and gumbo all very good. Stuffed shrimp were wet with grease with rubbery overcooked shrimp served lukewarm.

Very good food, but definitely a bit on the pricey side. Service was excellent.

Pretty decent seafood place. Wait staff is okay, not awesome! Food is good.

Our server Jeff was the best part of our night. It was a wonderful experience overall but Jeff’s outstanding service and personality were the highlight of our experience. Would absolutely go again.

We have been to the Fish Market many times, and always enjoy it. Service was excellent, food quality terrific, plentiful, tasty, and served promptly.

Our server Jeff was wonderful. He was attentive, accommodating and took the time to interact with my hard of hearing mother celebrating her birthday. The food was outstanding.

Overall, it was just a bad experience it was my dates first time there and his fried cod was wet on the inside. Our drinks were watered down!!!! Watered down!! When we left and Wales passed a worker she didn’t even acknowledge our departure.

Birthday dinner for my dad. My mom said it was one of her best meals ever and they had a vegan option for me. We all left satisfied. Thank you!

Excellent service and food.

Very disappointed. My scallops were over cooked and my mixed vegetables weren't cooked enough. Quality has gone way downhill from our previous visit.

We went for my daughters birthday ..it was really cold
In the restaurant..like the air conditioning was
Running...she wanted carrot cake for dessert but
It was frozen..she had to get it to go !

Seafood is always fresh and delicious. Good selection of menu options.

Very nice atmosphere with professional service. I would be careful when choosing a dish. Some options aren’t prepared as described on the menu. They must have a cook that loves spices. Crab cakes are very spicy and other items can contain too much of the wrong seasoning. Needs a little balance.