Previous times it was definitely a 4+ experience, this last time I was there everything was off . Except the lava cake at the end , very disappointed.

It was pricey but the food was delicious!

Amazing food and great atmosphere, I would definitely recommend this restaurant

Food was amazing. Felt very safe with the partitions they had up and everything was very clean and guest were 6-feet apart which I appreciated. Our waitress was friendly and very attentive.

Always a great meal and great service. We have been there quite a few times and always the same so far no bad experience's. Staff is always so nice.

Food was amazing, quick and easily - Brussels sprouts were odd but all other items were really nicely done

The waitress made the dining experience very enjoyable. Food was a bit salty but would order something different next time.

Excellent as usual!
Brought a person that had never been there before.
You've earned a new customer.
Will be back soon!

Great food !!! Good sized portions, enough to share.

Our waiter Tim was excellent the food was good not outstanding. For the price it should of been outstanding. Be careful because the tip was added to the bill something new so I didn’t realize and double tipped.

I made a reservation for my son's birthday on Thursday 1/14/21. The great thing was it was a pre-fixe menu option that was awesome. 1 ordered off the main menu and the other 4 off the pre-fixe menu. Our table was full of food and we shared our sides and deserts. My only issue was upon entering, I told the hostess I made a reservation for 6 under Hodgins but 1 was not feeling good so we left her home for everyone's safety. Later, I received an email asking why I did not show up. This was upsetting as I would not want them to disregard any future reservations. We should have a check in feature upon arrival on app!

Very nice atmosphere excellent service food selection was good. My New York strip steak tasted excellent but it was at the right temperature yet chewy and grainy I was not very happy my two dining companions had just a shell steak which was excellent the flavor and very soft I’d say better than my Strip steak.

Awsome food

Our dinner was fantastic as was our waiter. We will return again in the future.

Food was delicious! Service was great! They did a great job keeping tables more than 6 feet apart!

Exceptional service. Unfortunately, nothing good to say about the steak.

Great private room , they did fantastic with social distancing and food recommendations . Everyone especially loved the octopus and mixed drinks !

Dined here a few times. Best to make a reservation. Steaks are worth the price.

Eaten at many Steakhouses and the Porterhouse for 2 was definitely the worst I’ve had definitely not worth the price

Server toook a lil long but he was super good !!! He was pro. Judy busy

Had tagliatelle which was delicious. My husband had the spaghetti with sauce and he loved it.

Every meal was delicious! The after dinner drinks were also wonderful!

The dinner and device where great.

My dining experience was a bit unfortunate. For a reservation of four, we all agreed the brussels sprout dish was too busy and very salty. The most disappointing part of my meal was my ribeye. Unfortunately it was extremely tough and grizzly. Even before it hit my mouth every cut with the knife was met with resistance. Almost every bite I had I experienced inedible chewiness from grizzle to the point where I was removing pieces of steak from my mouth and set them aside on my plate. The flavor was good. But imagine my disappointment when you have a $60 steak that you expect every bite to be tender and juicy. That was a very big letdown, because we looked forward to dining there and enjoying some wonderful steak.

We love to dine there, food, service and atmosphere.
Service and staff are great.

Absolutely flawless experience made exceptionally special by Zach and Tim. The NY Strip, the Ribeye, the Bibb salad and the Caesar were as incredible as always. First time having a side of Mac n cheese and we can’t wait to order it again. Thank you for making the entire dining experience as great as anyone could hope for. Can’t wait to be back!

First time there and it was amazing! Delicious food, fabulous wine, excellent service!
The restaurant was exceptionally clean, everyone was professional and pleasant. Our server, Robert, was so nice and incredibly knowledgeable. We will definitely return!
Highly recommend!!

Always good. Never a bad experience. Friendly staff. Will visit again.

A great dining experience. Out Waiter Robert was top notch. The Cesar Salad and aged steak was out of this world.

The food was excellent as always. One of my favorite steakhouse.

Miranda our server was amazing, service was outstanding. Food was great

Our party of 5 was introduced to this restaurant by their New Year's Eve price fix menu. Chestnut soup, polenta&mushrooms, strip steak and loaded baked potato was delicious. We couldn't make it to dessert!! Staff very attentive even if a little inexperienced. They more than made up for it with grace and good humor. We will def come again when we regain our appetite!!

We went for New Years Eve; Service was outstanding and safe environment, food was great but because of fixed menu missed our porterhouse steak ... the steak was very good but I have had better at this restaurant. Overall outstanding - we love Cellaio's.

Waiter was wonderful. Food was cold. Even went some went back to heat up still cold. We eat here all the time. New Year’s Eve was very disappointing

Service was superb, maybe the best that I’ve experienced. Good was delish but the dessert, salted caramel budino was exceptional

Excellent as always!

What a great place to eat would recommend to everyone

Had a great meal as always. No eggplant caponata but we survived lol!!!!!

Great wait staff !!!!

Felt comfortable eating there during Covid times !

Thank you

My wife and I LOVE coming here. Exceptional service out of this world food!

This restaurant is always consistently good. The food is cooked to perfection and the service is friendly, competent and professional. Always make it a point to visit when going to the Resorts in Monticello!