Catello's Italian Art Cuisine - Pendleton

My order was not what I was expecting. The flavors were there but the size of the shell fish was very small. I expected a little better especially for the money.

Food was excellent it was my girlfriend's 1st time there and she was very impressed.

The food was average and a bit overpriced. The seating area was so small and close together. I felt like I was sharing my dinner with the whole restaurant.

Cozy little restaurant with wonderful service and food. The warm bread was amazing and the olive oil is too. Highly recommend this place.

Food was good. Staff was informative and friendly.

No soft drinks. Water, tea or wine.

This place never disappoints! Always great food, service and atmosphere. We drive 40 minutes to eat here and totally worth it.

Excellent Italian cuisine. I couldn’t have been more pleased with our experience. The homemade pasta was perfect. The sauce was delicious. They clearly use the best ingredients. The tiramisu was heavenly. The service was great. The atmosphere was cozy and intimate. I highly recommend!!! Will be returning.

Something different/new to try. Food was delicious

Celebrated my husband's birthday (notified the restaurant of the celebration, but no mention was made or congratulations given). But, the highlights first! The bread was insanely delicious, as well as the burrata antipasto. They were out of the caprese salad, so we didn't get to try it. We ordered the gnocchi bolognese and Iberico fettuccine. The gnocchi was good. The Iberico dish was very strange. It seemed like some cheap pork chop cutlets served over greasy undercooked pasta. The pork did not have the typical marbling of Iberico pork and was overcooked and dry. The pasta was stiff and difficult to eat, especially because it was slippery from way too much oil poured on top of the dish. Too expensive for what it was. Dessert was strange, but tasty. Tiramisu but more like a custard. The lady fingers were so dry I could barely get my spoon through them. Definitely not traditional tiramisu. The cappuccino was the best part of the whole meal. Delicious imported italian espresso beans. I would give them one more chance to earn a repeat customer. Service was excellent.

The pasta was homemade and delicious. You can tell that this is authentic Italian food. We loved the burrata appetizer. Dining space is small and a bit tight for true distancing during these Covid times. I understand that they are expanding the dining space in the future- do this should help.

I couldn't have picked a better place for a date night, though I never would have known the place existed if not for a recommendation from a friend. Small, quiet, excellent food and presentation, great service, and authentic ambience. Pendleton is lucky to have a place like this.

Wonderful experience! Top notch service, cozy atmosphere, and amazing food!

Birthday celebration. Very small, quaint. Food was good. Menu could use explanation. Nice ambiance.

Excellent food and dining experience’

Great food and service. This was our first time here and we will be back.

I hope I didn’t say the noise level was too high. I gave all stars that it is just perfect. We love this restaurant. Quaint atmosphere and friendly staff and the best Italian food! It marvels the wonderful food we had when traveling to Italy. The food is not only delicious but artistically presented.

I have been to Catello's a dozen times, and I have never been disappointed. The food is exceptional, from appetizers, dinner, and desserts. Nice wine selection too. And the service is always just right. Small, quaint setting...although they will be expanding soon.

Cute little local spot. Great food, excellent service, reasonable price.

Outstanding! Food, service and atmosphere were amazing. Cannot believe it has been 3 years since last visit. Will return soon.

Lasagna Bolognese was ample in quantity, good temperature but seemed to be shy on seasoning. Content of serving seemed a little too smooth; expected it to have more texture.
Salad - excellent. Wine - delicious.

Everything is delicious... wine, cheese, bread, pasta, dessert! Fantastic experience for a special occasion or just date night.

Very nice portion size. Lasagna was delicious. Love the homemade pasta.

This restaurant will not disappoint you! The food is authentic Italian from start to finish.
Katja is an incredible server— friendly, professional, and knowledgeable regarding the menu.
Everything was outstanding!!

The best authentic Italian I’ve had in the U.S. This place is a true gem!

Literally the best Italian food i've ever had. We most definitely will be returning.

Thoroughly enjoyed our dinner

Excellent, delicious!

My fiancé and I love going to Catello's! Authentic Italian food and atmosphere, great for a date night or just any night out. The staff is very professional, quick, and polite. Katja always is eager to assist in any way she can. I highly recommend Catello's

What a great find! my friend just moved to Fort Wayne, so our group was looking for somewhere between Indianapolis and Fort Wayne to dine. We were thrilled with this find. Very authentic!! They make their own pastas and cheeses! Everything was awesome!!!

Good place... nice and cozy...I would visit again...

Great spot. Very small. Very friendly. No complaints. Will go back.

Love this restaurant! Ready to go again! Amazing food

First time and can’t wait to go back to try something else

Catello's offers the best pasta, and the best Italian food I've ever had in my life. This is my new favorite restaurant, knocking places like Ruth's Chris and Salt on Mass Ave out of the top spots.
The restaurant is quaint and cozy with a warm and inviting ambiance. If weather permits, sit outside. Inside is lovely too, but the noise level creeps up a tad. The wine selection is excellent. The server and assistant server are both wonderful.
The food...the food is where the magic happens.

This is the place for authentic/incredible Italian food and amazing service!!
As usual Katja provided impeccable service— offering terrific wine selections in addition to delicious food options.
We love this restaurant!!

Our first visit and definitely not our last. Food and service were both awesome!!

Was pleasantly surprised. Our waitress was right on, very perceptive and informative. I am from PTown originally and it is nice to know that you can have such a good time taking a lady there. Good Job all. Food was killer!

Food was amazing. Best Italian food I ever had. Will definitely be back .

We enjoy Italian food. This was our first visit. The style of this establishment’s pasta preparation is not something that we have had before this visit. It was very al Dante.

Delicious food, great atmosphere, and excellent service!