Butterfields Restaurant
Our new American cuisine restaurant is conveniently located right off the 495 at exit 55 off the Long Island Expressway, near the Sheraton Hotel, Hyatt and Holiday Inn Express. Our restaurant bar and happy hour have the reputation of providing great times and the best live entertainment to be had on Long Island. Our restaurant serves lunch and dinner every day except Sunday, when the dining rooms are reserved for private catering and parties. Live bands on the weekends will entertain you and keep you moving & grooving on our large dance floor. Our delicious dishes are also available through our catering menu as well, tasty lunch catering for your office or party.
Interested in celebrating your birthday, anniversary or other special occasion at Buttefields? Call 631 851 1507 for group dinner reservations (table requests of 8 or more guests).
Safety precautions
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Menu
Food was terrible.
What an amazing experience! We enjoyed everything from the drinks, entertainment, appetizers, entrees to the dessert! Great job guys!
Saturday night 7pm dinner for 4 . Very nice. specials and all were great . They did have live music start at 830 which turned out to be southern rock band . The noise level at that time was pretty high . Im glad we had 7pm dinner so we pretty much just wanted some cocktails and enjoy the music by the time they started. Great night and excellent band
There was no one at the restaurant when we walked in and was right away told by hostess that there is max of an hour and a half sitting. That was turn off to hear when we first walk in considering the place was completely empty.
My mixed drink for $13 was full of ice and no alcohol. Then the wine glass is not even half way filled. So that was annoying too.
They kept coming over with no there to keep asking if we were done with bread. That was very odd. Waiter was nice and food was pretty good. Best part is the ambiance
Fantastic Linguine with clams and Salmon was great as well. Nice cozy spot for a great meal.
This is the place where, I met my now Fiancé on a dating event two years ago! We love this place, the food is always so good. And the service is good too.
We’ll go back and back again. Thanks.
Awesome service
Awesome service
Lots of options for a client lunch out on Long Island
Food and service was outstanding
Food, ambiance and service was great. The best part was the live music by the acoustic Nicolls Road trio - we will definitely come back!
Great time with friends. Outstanding food and service!
Food service and music all good
Great service. Haven't been here since last summer but was glad I came back. The vibe was great and food was yummy
Great restaurant, Food was delicious, staff was friendly and attentive A very enjoyable time .Would definitely recommend
Went at 5pm on Saturday, only 3 other tables and service was slow. Ordered some appetizers , Crab Cakes were dry and flavorless, seemed like they were leftover, Mussels were slightly better and steak tidbits lacked seasoning. Overall expected more given the price
The food has gotten fantastic there. New Chef Delicious Service was great Michael was our waiter.
Great place. Food is fantastic and service is right on point.
Food was excellent, live music made it a little difficult to talk but was enjoyable
Our table was in the corner, outside, as requested and was a little closer to the other tables, than expected. The appetizers were very good; one dinner choice was returned (pork chop) as there was a specific request/directions on the preparation and "doneness". The server was not attentive, but she did accommodate the above error.
Great band Guilty Pleasure, good food and a pleasant host.
Noisy and overpriced. Entertainment was sloppy, couldn’t hear thru the microphone. Limited menu, very pricy alcoholic beverages.
Didn’t have item available that we’re part of why we chose restaurant. Service was nice, but had birthday celebration and server didn’t clear dinner before serving dessert. Only corner tables are next to kitchen or mangers office which was odd. Overall ok, good food and acceptable prices. Will go back with hopes of more streamlined service and ambiance.
Outdoor dining under a tent is pleasant at this institution. Food is good but not exceptional. Service is very accommodating. There is free entertainment
They had a restaurant week special we decided to try. Selections were just ok and my pork chop was dry and tough. Eggplant was a little too crisp. I wish we had ordered off the regular menu. Service was fine but a little sporadic. Atmosphere was good.
Took 30 minutes for water, heard terrible things about taste of apps and wait for service. I left after water incident made rsvp elsewhere.
Seriously service was perfect god was fantastic
The food is exquisite and the service was amazing!! I highly recommend this gem, you will not be disappointed from the drinks apps & entrees, amazing & they are so compliant with social distancing!! I will definitely be returning especially for that Calamari
The hostess was amazing. I find it important for restaurants to tell me the most valued drink on the menu along with recommendations on apps and Entrées. I will definitely be back very soon. The live music was a bonus as well
Food wasn’t as good as it has been in the past. Not sure if they’ve changed owners or chef.
Not our first time, not our last... but the special appetizer was very very expensive!!! Lesson learned to ask for prices when there is only a spoken special list, not printed.
Very nice dinner . Bar was awesome service was fantastic . Will go back again
The food was very good but to pricey for each entree. Expensive steak house prices. $14.50 for 1 oz. Of Vodka is a RIP off. Noise level way to high. From the bar and from the music from a DJ at 6pm.
The prices for lunch have been very reasonable for me in the past. The week night specials seem reasonable as well.
All was great with the exception of the seating for 12. Was very cramped a round table and square table did not accommodate correctly but we made the best of it. The overall experience was nice.
Love that there is fine dinning and dancing / entertainment all in one place...A great place to meet friends or date night...
While the food wasn’t bad (it wasn’t great either) the service was very slow for a mostly empty restaurant. I wouldn’t go back.
We were 2 out of 6 people in the restaurant. ( it was early...5:00). Service was not great. Ordered rigatoni with a cream sauce. Came with huge chunks of short ribs in it....more short ribs than rigatoni. If you like short ribs that is great but I don’t so was not too pleased ordered coffee. They had no half and half for the coffee. The coffee was ICE COLD. Asked to speak to management they took 20% off the bill but was not a great experience. Only good thing was the créeme brûlée I had for dessert.
Nice atmosphere and delicious food. The band was awesome. The Vibe
Went on Burger night. Had a blast! Music was a nice touch and burger was amazing. Friend had the filet mignon and loved it. Server was friendly. Will be back for sure.
Very noisy. Could not hear anyone talking. Food not good and overpriced. Would not recommend for a friends get together.
Thank you for taking the time to leave a review. Butterfields is a popular "go to" restaurant for many Long Islanders. We are disappointed you did not have a good experience. Your feedback has been shared with management. Wishing you the best in 2020!
FAQs
Butterfields Restaurant offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 851-1507.
Butterfields Restaurant is rated 3.9 stars by 40 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.
