Butcher Shop Steakhouse - San Diego
Book your next event with us
Instantly increase your points with dining rewards
See availability for bonus point tables
Sun 7:00PM - 11:00PM
Mon - Thu 7:30PM - 11:00PM
Fri - Sat 8:30PM - 11:00PM
I go to the butcher shop all the time and is why I plan my birthday dinner which was included in my reservation I was very surprised that not once during the evening was there any mention of my birthday by any of the staff.
Both of us order steak to be cooked medium one came back rare and the other came back well done it was very disappointing. And while the manager did offer to buy a dessert for The inconvenience I would have thought that they would have given me a small birthday dessert anyway.
We have been eating at the Butcher Shop whenever we have a special occasion for the past thirty years. We have never been disappointed until this past weekend. When we made our reservation for three we indicated there was a birthday in our party. The restaurant was no more or less crowded than we'd ever seen it over the years. The waitress brought a basket of bread for the table and a salad for one member of our party. A few minutes later the waitress brought a soup to another member of our party. About five minutes later, she came by with the pepper mill for fresh ground pepper but by the time she arrived, the salad was finished and the soup was nearly finished as well. Two of our entrees were brought to the table. Rather than dressing the baked potato table-side, one of our entrees had a spoonful of sour cream and small amount of butter already dressing the potato on his plate. We waited for our third entree. And we waited. Several minutes later the maitre d' brought the third entree with butter, sour cream, and chives in a little metal cup. The waitress was busy bringing complimentary birthday cake to one of the two other parties at tables immediately adjacent to ours that was also celebrating a birthday that evening. Getting the waitress' attention to request more sour cream was impossible so we gave up and ate our meals before they got any colder. No refill of bread. No refill of our water or ice tea glasses. The waitress came around with a dessert tray but knowing the restaurant would most likely be bringing us a slice of cake for the birthday in our party, we declined any dessert. The birthday cake never materialized. The bill came. We are always generous tippers but we were hard-pressed to figure out what amount to leave as a tip....the cold food was okay but the service was terrible.
Maybe have more staff on hand. But the food and service was outstanding
1. Manager, host seemed to care less of visit....seem more irritated than welcoming
2. Server was overwhelmed and running in circles and slow
3. Ran out of mac& cheese
4. Steaks came out at all different temps, with exception of what was ordered
5. Food came out in stages
6. Parking is a bit of a mess too.
Nope, not coming back. Used to be one of our favorites, but now seems a shell of what it once was....strcuk me as a "before" resteraunt show contestant....
Rebecca is an excellent server. She knows what we want before we even speak! Has a friendly and charming nature.
Overall, I love Butcher Shop. The setting, value and service are excellent. The 'old fashioned' setting is really cool, not many restaurants like this left. The food is generally very good and price great compared to comparable restaurants. The only negative comments about our most recent visit are: 1) I ordered red snapper which I usually like and order whenever it is offered. I didn't think to ask if it was filets or a whole fish - I like the whole fish. It came as filets and though it did not taste bad or 'fishy', it really didn't have any taste whatever. I have a rule not to order fish in a steakhouse, and should have followed the rule, and also should have asked if it would be the whole fish, so 'my bad'. 2) We paid extra for a baked potato (though only $3 since it was with a meal). The potato was very small and seemed very overdone. I didn't know that baked potatoes could be overdone but it was....3) Ordered mashed potatoes for the other meal and was brought vegetables. I decided it was ok and that I needed the veggies anyway, but my husband mentioned it to the server, and she went ahead and brought me a side of mashed potatoes.
Some of the issues may be because we ordered the sunset dinner specials. We had never had this before and weren't even aware of the special but happened to notice them on the menu and since we were there early went ahead and ordered - great deal and also one of the meals was what we were planning on ordering anyway...
We had a nice time. Great food. Spent around $200 for the two of us with tip. A pricey date but worth it.
Valentine’s Day dinner
We had a great dinner but the music from the other room was a bit of a drag on the mood. We were hoping for a more quiet dinner on Valentines Day. But the food was great and our server was excellent.
The food and service was excellent. The decor was terribly outdated. The staff seems pretty unhappy. Maybe they were understaffed that day, since it was Valentine's. Overall though, I would go back.
Excellent as always. Outstanding food at a reasonable price with super service
We went for an early Valentine’s dinner on Feb 13th. It was very disappointing for a place we had been to many times and usually loved. Our reservation was at 5:30. We were seated immediately but no one came to our table for at least 15 minutes. The crowd was light at the time. I ordered a dry and dirty vodka martini.... it came with no olive juice in the drink and two olives on the side! Really? Our salad was served before we had a chance to enjoy our pre dinner cocktails. (Probably our fault - we should have waited to prder food) Being a special occasion, I ordered the king crab legs. For $42, I was disappointed in the quality of the legs. Only one leg (out of a pound) had a meaty solid piece of crab. It was evident they were previous frozen and a bit undercooked. (The king crab legs I get at the Outback are 10 times better!) The baked potatoes on both our plates were so mushy it was hard to eat. Either reheated or over cooked. My husband had prime rib and that was okay. Maybe we got the tail end of the food they reheat for their Sunset specials... not sure. But for the price we paid - I wasn’t happy. It spoiled what should have been a romantic evening.
Everything was impeccable, except the chocolate lava cake came out cold 3 times. But it was still a great time and the service was choice.
Excellent meal as always. Never disappointed, attentive service. My favorite place for steak.
It was your run of the mill steak. I had the New York steak and honestly felt I could have gone to Outback and had the same exact thing for half the price.
We requested the fireside room, and were immediately given a table in that room upon our arrival. The server was very busy, but we did not feel neglected at all. As usual, beverages and food were good (we go here fairly often), and we ended our meal feeling nice and relaxed.
Outstanding as usual. Steaks cooked perfectly. Service excellent.
Everything was great, but the steaks were slightly overcooked and the quality of the meat should have been better. The price point on the filets was too high for a mediocre cut. Overall I feel I payed top dollar but did not get a top dollar steak. Service was great and atmosphere was definitely steakhouse.
Went for a birthday. The birthday person ordered the $49 rib eye. The steak came out so overdone, beyond well done it was mindboggling. Of course it was ordered medium. So the steak was returned to the kitchen, waiter guaranteed it would take 4 minutes. Well took so long, the rest of us had eaten and our plates were cleared away before the birthday persons steak came back. No compensation was given, no offer of free dessert. And worst of all, no reference to the birthday. It was our go to steak house, but no longer. Will never return. Sorry, all you had to do was offer something for the screw up. The only thing we received was a full price bill.
Another great and classic dinner with family and friends! Love the menu and the old school feel of this steakhouse!
5 stars overall but had reservations and took awhile to get seated. It was restaurant week so I get it but overall 5 stars
Steak was flavorfull, the ambiance was wonderful. I would definitely come back again!
Even though we made a reservation, we still had to wait about half an hour to be seated. The food was really good, but my steak was over cooked. We were sitting right by the bar, and another customer was really loud and belligerent. He kept making high pitched noises. It was disturbing to listen to while we were trying to eat.
My wife and I started off with a Caeser and a Spinach salad. For dinner we both had the 10 oz Prime Rib with baked potatoes. The Prime Ribs were very tender and prepared the way we like them. We split a Crème Brûlée which was different but very good. We weren't rushed and the service was excellent.
Went here for restaurant week. It took about 45 min to get our food. When it did finally come it wasn’t even hot. It wasn’t cold either it was just like room temperature. All the dishes we had were not hot. I mean if you order a medium well piece of meat shouldn’t it come out hot or at minimum warm??? I had the sea bass with scallops and it was very boring only 2 scallops and the sea bass was fishy in some parts. Not impressed. Will probably not be back
Food was excellent
Fantastic food, service & experience. I really enjoyed the old school environment of a real steakhouse!
Our server paid more attentive to his other tables and we felt awkward. Pepper usually gets offered for the salad and he never offered it to our table. We observed that our drinks took longer than other tables near us that ordered after us and we had to flag down other staff for assistance throughout the meal.
The fish was good, but pass on the lava cake. It was cold and solid
We both ordered from the Rest. Week menu and had the same items. The bacon-wrapped scallops were very good, but the prime sirloin steak was very tough. The trio of sorbet had only 2 types (they ran out), and the key lime pie was very disappointing. The assist. mgr. said the steak is a "baseball" cut - no idea what part of the cow that came from. I had to send mine back to be butterflied and cooked more. The mgr. also gave us a ridiculous story about the sorbet, saying there's not enough room in the kitchen for 3 types. What a dodo!
Good food and service. Server was attentive. She gave a description of food and offered options.
We went here for our anniversary, on a Sunday night during Restaurant Week. We ordered from the Restaurant Week prix fixe menu; for $40 each I think it was reasonable. My husband enjoyed the shortribs and the lava cake; my sirloin and lobster tail were cooked properly, but the sirloin was a little tough. The creme brulee was enough for two people, but it was not "bruleed" at all--no crackly crust :( Our server was great! We would probably go back if we wanted steak, because it is very close to where we live. But I'm not sure the full price menu is worth it.
Seems like they have a crowd of regulars they cater to and you feel unwelcome if you’re new. Food was average. Salad and apps looked sad, but tasted fine. Créme brulee (no crunchy sugar layer) and tiramisu (didn’t taste like coffee) were very disappointing. Prime rib and short ribs were tender.
Well I’m just going to say I will not be dinning here again.
I would recommend the Butcher Shop to anyone. The food, service and ambiance are excellent.
It's a great spot for special occasions. Pricey, but expect a return on your investment. Food was good; my wine had soured and hubby's drink was weak. Still a fun spot to dine.
If you want a steak cooked to perfection this is the place! Been coming here for many years and have never had a bad experience!
Sunset dinner is a great deal at $24 for prime rib and catch of the day. Upordered the macadamia crusted halibut and it was very good. Prime Rib was perfect medium and excellent spicy horseradish. Drinks were very reasonably priced for cocktails and wine by the glass.
Very disappointed in the meal. I ordered a new your steak & tasted lots of added flavoring but not a good grilled steak taste .... even the sampler platter was just so so, nothing special
Very nice dinner. Thanks