Brewsters Italian Cafe
Join us for lunch or dinner near a fireplace in the winter or in our beautiful garden during the summer; slow down with us on a Saturday or Sunday morning when we also offer breakfast. We are open every day, all year round! (Closed Easter Sunday, Thanksgiving and Christmas Day)
We look forward to having you as our guests!
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
pick (2) regular toppings on a traditional crust pizza; upcharge for other pizzas - ask your server
homemade marinara & meatballs over long pasta
Spinach Artichoke Dip
served w/ rustic flatbread
Had a nice evening on the patio. Food was good and as described, service was prompt and friendly, ambience was lovely. The host was also really friendly and nice! Thanks Dan, our server.
We have gone to Brewsters for years, driving 40 miles each way to do so. Always worth the trip. Great food, nice people, top notch ambiance. One of our favs
I took my parents out for Mothers Day dinner, and everything about our evening was phenomenal. Brewster’s always knocks it out of the park, and this was no different!
As always, great food with unique menu and the service was excellent.
Ordered the charcuterie tray and the meatballs which came with either soup or salad. All were delicious and we are foodies. Had to take desert home we were so full
Perfect lunch for Mother’s Day! We enjoyed everything and the drinks were delicious
Always a positive experience! I highly recommend!
Our new favorite Italian restaurant.
Have recommended to many and will continue to do so in the future.
Food was delicious! Could use more seafood options.
Fabulous chopped margarita salad and warm hug cappuccino. It was worth driving over an hour to get there.
Good food, good service, not very crowded so it was reasonably quiet.
Good service, nice menu with a wide variety of choices, attractive decor
Excellent as always. Wonderful service and Amazing food.
I lunch here almost everyday. Can’t say enough about the food and staff. Amazing pretty much covers it.
Such a lovely, tucked away spot. The service was delightful and the food very good.
The food was just so so. The chicken special had very thin sauce and little to no seasoning. The specialty salad had salmon and it was cooked within every ounce of its life. My daughter ordered pizza with arugula and, after it was made, we were told that they could not serve the arugula (this would have been great to know before we ordered) on the pizza. The dessert was overly sweet yet flavorless.
We were placed in a dark back room.
The highlight was the service.
This place is the best. Never disappointed when we visit, Food is delicious and wait staff is great. Love the outdoor patio.
Enjoyed lunch with the one I love. Food and service was excellent.
Service was excellent and food is always good!
Great food, service, and atmosphere! Would definitely go back
Always good service and food at Brewsters! Will definitely be back!
Brewster's is always a wonderful experience. Haven't been since before the pandemic. They didn't miss a beat. Utilized outdoor dining to keep it as safe as possible. Gardens are beautiful, service is always excellent, as is the food. Highly recommend.
The food and service were fabulous! We were just celebrating 2 birthday's in the family and I put that on my reservation but we were seated right by the front door, which had very little lighting and where all the traffic seemed to be. We were okay that no one sang Happy Birthday but why ask if you aren't going to do anything special?
Wonderful. As always.
Great menu; newly decorated areas evoke a big-city atmosphere.
When we arrived there was a note on the door the restaurant was closed April 25 and 26, sorry for the inconvenience. We had driven over 20 miles to have dinner and, thankfully, were able to find another restaurant in town which was open and which we sincerely enjoyed. Hopefully next time Management will notify their online reservation service of unexpected closures because we certainly will not know if the establishment is open given our experience.
Great food, and service as always. Seating was setup in accordance with current COVID policy, which was still very nice.
Brewster’s has become one of our top faves. This time however, they sat us in a room next to the kitchen which we didn’t even know existed. It just wasn’t the same “feel” and had a lot of noise and activity because of being so close to the kitchen.
What a wonderful place to eat and socialize. We go at least once a week and sometimes twice. The food and service is exceptional and never disappoints. Can't wait till the outside opens for the summer.
Delicious as always. Great service!
My favorite place to eat. Ever!!
Love everything and the staff is super fantastic!
We enjoyed the 2 for 42 option. It was all delicious and our waitress for excellent
The food was good, especially my fig and prosciutto pizza. Two people in our party ordered salads and the servers forgot to bring them out.
Excellent food and service. Kim was our server and took great care of us. She was not pushy nor did she try to rush our party.
The food is a bargain.
From getting seated right away to the lovely a-tentative waitress, Bloody Mary’s were great and food was hot.
Ambiance of Brewesters is great for taking first time friends.
Brewster's always has excellent food and service, and we enjoy the relaxed, casual atmosphere. Over the past year, we've been very pleased with both take-out and dine-in meals.
Always a nice experience at Brewsters. Atmosphere, food and service. Can't go wrong.
Wonderful experience, great food and great service.
Amazing food and service! Had a spectacular time. A must go to in New Buffalo!
Brewsters Italian Cafe offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (269) 469-3005.
Brewsters Italian Cafe is rated 4.8 stars by 415 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.