Brewsters Italian Cafe
Join us for lunch or dinner near a fireplace in the winter or in our beautiful garden during the summer; slow down with us on a Saturday or Sunday morning when we also offer breakfast. We are open every day, all year round! (Closed Easter Sunday, Thanksgiving and Christmas Day)
We look forward to having you as our guests!
Safety precautions
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Popular dishes
Pizza
pick (2) regular toppings on a traditional crust pizza; upcharge for other pizzas - ask your server
44 reviews
House Salad & Soup
mixed greens, croutons, pecorino & parmesan with our creamy balsamic dressing
23 reviews
Lasagna
layered pasta sheets w/ fresh herb ricotta, italian sausage, house marinara, provolone & mozzarella cheese baked golden brown & finished w/ fresh parmesan
8 reviews
Ambitious menu and they nailed it!
This was our 2nd visit and another great evening. Attentive server. Getting a resrvation highly recommended.
Wonderful experience and delicious food and drinks!
Service was outstanding. Appetizer, staff favorite cornbread, was elegant with a warm combination of flavors. Bruschetta was marginal, too bland. Bread was tough.
Our complete dining experience was wonderful! The ambiance, food, and service were all great!
Fantastic cozy little place. Excellent service and delicious food for the price. Christmas music was a tad loud for being in such small quarters but we will be back for sure!
After 20 years Brewsters is still our favorite place to dine. We have had issues and they are very quick to address and make things right. The food quality is always on point and the service is a never miss. We have enjoyed over 100 pizzas and each one seems to be better than the last. Do yourself a favor and visit soon and often.
YUMMY as always! Get the dinner for two. You won't have to cook the next day!
Fabulous food and service as always. Our favorite place in New Buffalo.
Chef Konnor and his staff create a magnificent culinary experience week in and week out and always make menu choices fresh with enticing weekly specials and periodic regular menu changes.
And the staff smiles, attentive care, and service are second to none!
Walking through the front door felt like stepping into a cafe in Italy. The service was amazing and the food excited my tastebuds. I left with a full belly and felt like family.
Super lemon chicken pasta. Also took the chopped margarita salad to go for another meal. Enjoyed the warm hug latte.
Great as always.
Both the food and service was spectacular!
Delicious! Dinner for two! Salad, pizza, Roma and a cookie!
Thank you for visiting and taking the time to leave these kind words, Liz!
Our favorite restaurant! Amazing food, staff, and atmosphere.
Excellent food and service in a delightful setting.
Excellent. Server was very hot, too.
You really cannot go wrong with Brewsters. Great location. Fantastic daily menus with lots of healthy options. Servers are very knowledgeable. The restaurant is clean and just a place you feel comfortable in. Highly recommend.
The staff was very polite and accommodating for our larger group, the food was amazing as always, and I can't wait to come back again!
We have been enjoying Brewster’s for years - no matter the season. Service is always top notch and the icing on the cake to fantastic food.
Always LOVE Brewster's, and the amazing "Dinner for Two" deal! It was the perfect birthday dinner for my wife, with a nice greeting when we got there and again when we left. Love the atmosphere, although a bit dark, even though I understand why.
Great job as usual! service was exceptional, steak was cooked as I liked (medium), and atmosphere was calming...as usual.
We are taken right in at appointed time, our waitress was very attentive but not pushy and the food was delicious!!!
It was a lovely meal! Food was very tasty and just the right amount. Atmosphere was great! Very nice not to have to listen to loud music. Staff was very friendly and helpful. Thanks for a special evening!
I had the shrimp and sausage entree and loved it! Our server was very attentive.
We always love eating at Brewester’s such great people and good food.
Everything was so good. The service was excellent.
Always a great meal. Just a bit loud but it was Saturday. Server was wonderful
Great as always. The staff was friendly, and attentive.
Absolutely awesome. The food, atmosphere, and service make me wat to return.
Food was amazing
Food and service was great! Perfect anniversary dinner!
Fantastic food, great service, and wonderful setting! We will be back!
Went for a weekday lunch. It was quiet, the food was good, and service was wonderful.
Always terrific food and great service!
We always enjoy Brewster’s and was thrilled Kathleen was our server.
We had a wonderful time and delicious food. The service was perfect!
A pleasant surprise. Food and service excellent. Will go again next time in area
As usual great food and service, especially many of the wait staff have taken great care of us for many years
Quality of food was excellent! Out of the ordinary choices in addition to some of the usual dishes you expect at an Italian restaurant.
FAQs
Brewsters Italian Cafe offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (269) 469-3005.
Brewsters Italian Cafe is rated 4.8 stars by 768 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.
