Brewsters Italian Cafe

Beautiful garden atmosphere, perfect for any occasion ♥️🍷

Once again we enjoyed an amazing Anniversary dinner on Brewsters beautiful patio. The hostess found us a perfect table. The service outstanding. Our dinner and wine delicious. Our favorite dining spot in MI.

Lovely outdoor private atmosphere.
Grilled grouper with polenta was perfect.
Steak salad delicious and perfectly done.
Relaxing soft music outside.

Amazing place you never get a bad meal here.

Always an enjoyable experience!

Absolutely delicious food. We love the 2 for $42 special. Great value for all the food you get.

Always my favorite in New Buffalo. Food/service/drinks/ambience outstanding. Never disappointed!

We always enjoy this restaurant. Great food and staff.

Amazing as always! My favorite place to be! I will be a life time customer!

Seriously, the best filet we’ve ever had. And the mushroom risotto was out of this world!

perfect place during covid 19 one of our favorites

Front of house service was incredibly rude and unprofessional.

Chicken cutlets we not thin, not pounded just chicken breast and too thick.

Specifically asked what the chiefs pasta was and our waitress asked the kitchen - they said linguine but we got papperadel and it was too thick.

In the end we felt very bad for our waitress because she did everything right and asked all the right questions but the kitchen failed her.

Got a reservation for outside table right at 4pm when they opened. Wasn't even outside, was inside in a windowed area.

We had dinner on the patio. It was just beautiful. Very private with many flowers. There were heat lamps as it was a little chilly that night. The food was very good, we had a variety of items and everyone enjoyed theirs. Don't miss the lemon cream cake for dessert. It was the perfect way to end a great meal.

Service and food was excellent. We really enjoyed the grouper special you had Monday evening.

Brewsters was great with accommodations and made a very special day even more special for my significant other and I. Great food and a great outdoor experience.

Lovely outdoor setting; prompt service with attentive and friendly wait staff. Food is always very good. Summer Gazpacho soup is exceptional.

We love Brewsters! We have dined at Brewsters on numerous occasions and never been disappointed. Food, Service, Value, and Setting are outstanding. Highly recommend.

Brewsters is quite simply the best, most consistent restaurant in Harbor Country. Service, food and ambience are always on point. Their patio is the perfect place to spend an hour enjoying the weather with some great food and drink. We have been dining at Brewsters for more than twenty years and have never been disappointed.

My favorite Restaurant to dine in New Buffalo.
The Service and Food are exceptional.
The Outdoor Patio is an Oasis, quiet, beautiful and exceptionally clean.
The menu selection provides me with favorites and I have never been disappointed.
A must stop each time we are in New Buffalo.

such a nice relaxed early dinner on the pretty patio. very generous sized cobb and special salad with excellent service.

Excellent food. Very busy, but it was a holiday weekend. Love the atmosphere, and available outdoor seating.

The outdoor seating was romantic and beautiful. The service was outstanding. The food was flavorful and plentiful. The berry tiramisu we had for dessert was delicious! We will definitely return for another visit. We love this place!

Took my girlfriend to the restaurant for her birthday dinner. Food was good and our waiter was excellent. I was not to happy though when just as we were finishing our desert we were asked to leave because they had another reservation they were trying to get in that didn’t want to sit at the bar. They didn’t offer to move us to the bar so we could continue our drinks we had only been there a 1 hr and 20 minutes. Up to this point I would have gone back again but after being asked to leave I would never return. I was very disappointed we were there to celebrate her birthday and and then we were rudely asked if we could leave. I won’t be returning and I’ll not be recommending this establishment

We had an awesome experience at Brewsters. The food was flavorful real Italian cooking. Nick was a joy to have as our server. We are usually a bit wary of Italian restaurants outside of Chicago area but this rivals anything in the city. Highly recommend Brewsters if you're in the New Buffalo MI area.

Best restaurant in Southwest Michigan! Everything is delicious. Charcuterie board, shrimp cocktail, entrees, specials and out of this world tiramisu brownie dessert (worth the visit just for that!) HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!

We stopped here driving from Saugatuck to Chicago for lunch, and had a delightful visit. Our two children, my wife and I enjoyed different pizzas from the menu, and they were very tasty. The service was extremely friendly and efficient, and if we lived close to New Buffalo, we would certainly dine here regularly.

Our server, Emily, was knowledgeable about the menu, the wine list and she was extremely pleasant. The outdoor seating is clean and comfortable. Thumbs up all around.

Just love dining on the outdoor patio. Kathleen is an awesome server!

Wonderful experience! Great food, and wait staff was very attentive, cheerful and helpful.

Delicious food, wine and dessert! Service was fabulous! Can’t wait to go back!

Amazing as always, excellent food and atmosphere. Service was great, server was attentive.

Great as always...had to take advantage of the last few weeks for the outside patio.

Always get the two for meal. Never disappoints. Take home cookies are the best

As usual our favorite lunch spot in New Buffalo!

Great meal, great service, great experience!

Outdoor dining was terrific. Very well spaced tables left us feeling safe and the flowers and greenery were great ambiance. The food was absolutely excellent for all 3 of us and the service was very good. Combined with the beautiful weather it could not have been any better!

Outstanding Food, Service and Atmosphere...as always!!

This is our second time here and the food is excellent and the overall of it.

It is a pleasure to dine at Brewesters great food and staff!