Brewsters Italian Cafe
Join us for lunch or dinner near a fireplace in the winter or in our beautiful garden during the summer; slow down with us on a Saturday or Sunday morning when we also offer breakfast. We are open every day, all year round! (Closed Easter Sunday, Thanksgiving and Christmas Day)
We look forward to having you as our guests!
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
pick (2) regular toppings on a traditional crust pizza; upcharge for other pizzas - ask your server
Spinach Artichoke Dip
served w/ rustic flatbread
homemade marinara & meatballs over long pasta
Outdoor dining has wonderful ambiance. Food was very good, overall service was average.
Brewsters is an excellent food. We ate at the patio, great setting. Both the food and service was great. The bruschetta is a must have.
We LOVE Brewster's and particularly the gardend! The ambience is spectacular, hushed, very appropriate music, beautiful weather (you should take credit for that also). I TREAT in every respect. Thanks to ALL from kitchen to mgmt....we appreciate everything you present.
Dennis L. Bowen
St. Joseph MI
Superb food, great staff. Ask for Dan. Sit outside if you can. Best restaurant in south west michigan
Our server was fabulous, the food was fantastic! Such a beautiful setting outside, we felt like we were in Tuscany. We look forward every summer to going to Brewsters! You will not be disappointed!!!!!!
I love Brewster's patio and ambience and the staff is great, but the food seems to be slipping a bit. One person at our table ordered lasagne and he thought it was just ok. I had the mahi mahi and while the fish was good, the couscous it was on was really awful, really awful. I'd recommend the pizza and pasta selections although again the lasagne was just ok.
Food was amazing! Incredible coffee! We’ll be back!
First time at the restaurant and it was such a great experience! Will definitely return in the future.
Food and everything was delicious. Server did the best she could. I think the kitchen was understaffed and too busy because our food took an hour. Luckily we got an appetizer and a bread basket that kept us satisfied til our dinner came.
Food and ambiance were excellent. Very busy, and service was a little slow. Overall, excellent.
The staff is so friendly, the food is delicious and we love the atmosphere. A wonderful local place.
The restaurant is absolutely adorable, so quaint. The food is delish. The price is $$$ ala carte / drinks as well...
Will have to go back!
We were in New Buffalo for the weekend to celebrate 10 years together. Picked Brewsters as we’ve never visited. They did not disappoint. Food, service and ambiance were all excellent. Looking forward to our next visit!
Amazing waitstaff! Seated promptly after arriving and the food was delicious!
This is our favorite restaurant to eat. Service is top notch, food is 5 star. We always bring friends and sit outside in the beautiful patio.
Lovely outdoor garden. Italian cuisine and service second to none!
Excellent seafood pasta entrees. Huge too. We took half home. Nice setting. Great service, especially considering the crush of Labor Day business.
My favorite local Italian restaurant! Apps, entrees, drinks and dessert were perfect!
Brewsters is fabulous. I live in California now, but when in the Midwest always make an effort to visit. Wonderful pastas, service is always friendly. Reservations are a must to get a table.
Something special … sat in outdoor patio where ambiance and service were second to none! Lovely experience.
Lovely late lunch outside on a beautiful day!
Apps were great . But if you are carb conscious at all - this is NOT the place for you. There were no entrees that did not involve pasta or pizza.
We had the fig and prosciutto pizza which was fantastic! We also had the specialty salad with house balsamic instead of honey Dijon. The salmon was delightful and cooked perfectly. The salad was delicious. I would order both again. And their lavender lemonade is yummy too!
Second time at Brewsters Italian Cafe, and
just as we did the first time, we LOVED IT.
Great food and great service!
The patio is outstanding!
First visit. Definitely enjoyed the food and service.
The pizza was awesome, as usual.
Love the outdoor seating. It's always so relaxing. A must place to eat when you're in New Buffalo.
My husband and I shared the “Dinner for Two” with lasagna as the entree. It was excellent Our server, Kathleen, was friendly and attentive. We sat outside and the area has a wonderful ambiance. It made our anniversary celebration complete.
Nice greenery and privacy for patio dining.
Appetizers enough for table of 4.
Food had lovely presentation, great flavors and good value for cost.
Complimentary bread, olive oil and shredded cheese delicious.
Great selection of desserts, even though we did not order any.
Lemon blueberry martini outstanding.
All Staff very friendly, professional and welcoming.
Brewsters is a little oasis. The outdoor patio is lush and welcoming, and surprisingly private. The food is always a home-run, especially the pizzas! And the service is friendly and leaves nothing to be desired. But at $100 for a lunch and beers for 2, we’ll keep Brewsters as that special occasion destination!
Excellent food, service and atmosphere as always at Brewsters
Always love Brewster’s for lunch!
Dinner with my mom and BF. We stayed in
Excellent experience. New York style Italian restaurant with great ambiance both inside and out. Terrific food. Great flavors. Fresh homemade pasta. Great appetizers. Highly recommended.
A bit expensive but worth it. Our waitress seemed a bit overwhelmed but adequate.
We had Excellent early dinner with our baby grandson outside under umbrella due to a short rain. Service and food were all excellent.
Fantastic summer lunch specials. Excellent service. Cannot be beat :)
Was great as always was large group in the same room that made it loud and bit hard to have a conversation but always happy with brewsters service and food
We had lunch on the patio to celebrate a birthday and everything was great! Good value, great food, great service. Really glad we had reservations though, the wait for walk ups was pretty crazy.
Food was outstanding, we had the bruschetta and sourdough pizzas. They were uniques recipes and tasted amazing!
Brewsters Italian Cafe offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (269) 469-3005.
Brewsters Italian Cafe is rated 4.8 stars by 660 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.