Brewsters Italian Cafe
Join us for lunch or dinner near a fireplace in the winter or in our beautiful garden during the summer; slow down with us on a Saturday or Sunday morning when we also offer breakfast. We are open every day, all year round! (Closed Easter Sunday, Thanksgiving and Christmas Day)
We look forward to having you as our guests!
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
pick (2) regular toppings on a traditional crust pizza; upcharge for other pizzas - ask your server
House Salad & Soup
mixed greens, croutons, pecorino & parmesan with our creamy balsamic dressing
layered pasta sheets w/ fresh herb ricotta, italian sausage, house marinara, provolone & mozzarella cheese baked golden brown & finished w/ fresh parmesan
We love the food, and the service is ALWAYS fantastic. Can’t wait to go back.
We try to visit Brewster’s every other week, we always have great prepared food wether it is appetizers, their specials or off the menu. Melissa is one of our favorite servers there.
Dinner for 2 a great deal.
Exceptional service, food, setting.
Early 5:00 dinner beat the 7:00 rush.
Best menu in New Buffalo! Love the food, the setting, everything.
Wonderful food and service! We always dine at Brewster’s when we are In Michigan.
Frequent this restaurant whenever in the area. Never disappoints. Always a first class experience in every way.
Brewster’s food is always amazing, but their staff makes them stand head and shoulders above other restaurants.
Everything went very well. Great food and great service.
We requested seating in bar. Was not available to us when we arrived on time even though there were empty tables in bar. This is one of our favorite restaurants so we were disappointed in not being seated as reserved
Great night out with my wife to just enjoy each other‘s company on a date! Our server is always fantastic and the food was delicious. One of our favorite spots to have dinner or a great lunch! We will be back again this month. Thank you for providing great food and wonderful service every time.
Perfect. Perfect. Perfect. There’s just nothing else to say. #ouritalianrestaurant
Must try meatballs and royal cookie! Always have good food and service here. Wish they'd bring back 14 Hands cab, though. They are the ones who got me hooked on it! (By the glass)
We both really enjoyed our dishes! The ambience was great and it never felt too crowded or loud. It was easy to focus on our meal/conversation. Our server was really nice :)
Seated promptly, food was great and the service very good.
Have ate there many times without issue.
Very accommodating when we asked for a later reservation time due to bad weather our guests ran into on their way to our home. They were delighted with the food, atmosphere and service. Thank you!
Wonderful service. Excellent food.
Experience was absolutely amazing. The food and the service is so good. Shoutout to our waitress, Caroline!
Best Time Ever!!! Got together New Years Day with family since we were not with them for Christmas. Had 1:00 reservations! Perfect time to go since they weren’t too busy yet! All had ‘Dinners for Two’ which is such a great deal! Food was Excellent! Our waitress, Kim was Outstanding! When we ordered a drink & they realized they were out of Southern Comfort, Kim ran across the street in the snow, to Barney’s to purchase a bottle!!! Now that’s Service, Over & Above!!!
Can’t rate them high enough! At least 10 STARS!!!
Brewster's is ALWAYS great. The food, the staff, keeps us coming back year after year.
Spent New Year’s Eve here like we do most years and it did not disappoint! Fabulous food and service!
My favorite in New Buffalo. We had a beautiful NYE dinner with an amazing ambiance. It was actually our first time eating indoors and it did not disappoint. The food is amazing!
Had a most enjoyable New Year’s Eve lunch. Food was very good and Kathleen’s service was outstanding.
Amazing food and great service!
I love to dine at Brewsters! The food is amazing. This is one of the first places I suggest when someone asks for a recommendation. We were seated in the wine room. I had never been in that room before. I really liked it.
Delightful, intimate, Italian restaurant. My only suggestion would be that they serve a beef/pork free soup as a daily soup option.
We loved the relaxed feel and the staff were great. Everything we tried was delicious especially the margarita pizza! We will definitely be back!
Great meal and service. Always a good occasion to visit Brewster’s.
The food and service was awesome. We loved the fireplace. Our only complaint was a patron in our room that spoke very loudly from the time we arrived until she left.
The food was amazing and the service was on point. Definitely will be coming back, soon!
Celebration of family love! Great service and delicious food!
Great experience always. Food service bar drinks are consistently great
Lunch was amazing, as usual. It is our favorite place to go for lunch, the food was great and the service is always great.
Love this hidden gem!
We were seated beyond the bar in the area with wine bottles. Food was plentiful and delicious for the Couple Sharing. The ambiance was cozy for 4 of us. We’ll be back again!
Excellent Italian food and everything is homemade. Great cheeses and sauces amke everything taste too good! Try the rustic steak salad it is my favorite!
As always the service was outstanding and the food was delicious.
Kathleen is a fantastic waitress.! She is friendly, fun and tries to honor every crazy request we give her.
Food is always excellent! And we have to take a latte and a cookie for the trip home.
Had such an amazing dinner last night. From the cocktails, appetizers, then dinner…..yummy yo it all!
Melissa our server was wonderful and was so helpful!
We will drive an hour just to have lunch here
Without a doubt the best restaurant in the New Buffalo area. We have been going there for years. Food, service and staff are excellent. The daily specials do not disappoint. Highly recommended.
Brewsters Italian Cafe offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (269) 469-3005.
Brewsters Italian Cafe is rated 4.9 stars by 817 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.