Brewsters Italian Cafe

Everything was better than we expected. Service, the wine, and our pizza was exceptional, delightful, and scrumptious! Wonderful birthday dinner!

Excellent as always! Go every time we are in town, never disappoints!

The food and service was great! Fresh, hot, flavorful food makes this one of our favorites!! We love how conscious Brewsters is about the safe distancing guidelines, even though that minimizes their tables. We will continue to return for their delicious food!!

the fireplace in the small bar adds a note of warmth to the changing season but it is outdoor summer dining that shines...the Special Salad is the best (salmon)with homemade soup offering a nice change each day. pizzas are okay...just.

I usually applaud Brewsters and, believe me, will continue to eat there regularly. But when we were there Friday it was unorganized in terms of seating and disgruntled people waiting to be seated. Our service was very slow, which may not have been the fault of our server. Maybe she had too many tables although that didn’t appear to be the case.

Very good food and service. My friends and I eat there all the time!

Brewster's is one of our favorite restaurants. We love their outdoor patio as well as the bar area.

Great food comfortable booth, enjoyed time with friends. Reservations needed

As usual, quality, value and service were great. Our sever, Kathleen #309 was outstanding.

Our waitress could not have been better - very attentive and then understanding that we 3 women were college buddies trying to catch up so she gave us our space also! Wide selection off menu for lunch and the food was outstanding. Need to order the charcuterie board of looking for appetizer - it could be a meal in itself! Would definitely return. Felt very comfortable with spacing for Covid safety.

The food was great! We sat in a booth with a high back so I felt very safe and distant from other diners. Our wait person was friendly and knowledgeable.

It really was the perfect birthday dinner. Cute table, perfect lighting. Our server was very nice and attentive. We got the dinner for two and left stuffed. Food and cookies were delicious! Already planning out next visit!

Love this place--- 3rd time to the area and we have visited every time.
Staff is helpful and friendly!
They are doing a great job given the COVID craziness. Highly recommend a trip to Brewsters!

Waitress friendly and food was delicious. Very timely and courteous

Great service!

It was our last hurrah for the summer with a group of good friends. Perfect outdoor setting. Perfect food. Perfect weather. Perfect service. We will be dreaming about this evening all winter long.

Everything was outstanding...will definitely be back.

Our favorite restaurant! We have been going for over 20 years!

Fun place to dine while spending the weekend in New Buffalo!

We were on a short vacation to the West coast of Michigan and needed a spot close to Lakeside where we were staying. Service was excellent, food was good, as well as spacing for the current situation. We appreciated the large secluded booth. We liked the shared dinner for two option.

Food is always fresh and tasty. Menu is adequate.

Great service and amazing food. Can't wait for our next visit.

Outdoor patio is perfect for lunch in the fall.

We loved Brewster’s! My husband and I dined as a couple on our weekend getaway to New Buffalo. We sat out on the patio in mid October but with the heaters it was comfortable even on a cool night. The ambience outside can’t be beat—private and romantic among the foliage and flowers! We had a delicious caprese appetizer, my husband had the chicken parm and I had the sausage, peppers and shrimp pasta. The food was great! Highly recommend!

Emily was one of the best servers I’ve ever had. Personable and fun, she was fantastic

Great food! Server was very friendly. Can't wait to go back.

Great food, service, and ambiance! Never had a bad meal here. Always have great service also!

This is not my first time at Brewsters..fantastic every time!
Can't wait to return.

Great food as usual! Only complaint was wait staff did not refill our empty water glasses. Otherwise a perfect outdoor lunch with

Food and service were GREAT!! Favorite place in New Buffalo!!

A fantastic dining experience. We always make a point of eating here when we are in the area and we’ve always enjoyed every minute of it.

Food was excellent. Service was great. Wish I was seating in a less trafficked area but a small price to pay.

The outdoor setting was beautiful. Our drinks were delicious. Starter salad was so fresh. Pizza was delicious. Main course options are very limited (at least by Chicago standards). Dessert cookie was delicious but not Italian. Loved the coffee, best I’ve had in a long while.

My wife and I enjoyed a very nice late afternoon meal. The food and service was
very good.

Great! Our waitress was wonderful, attentive and everything you would want when you are dining out. The food was superb and the outdoor patio is just perfect!

It was great. Everything was perfect. Doing great during COVID

Limited entree menu plus pizza. Food is always good and if any fault is that the portions are too big. We often end up sharing an entree or pizza.

Brewsters is a fantastic restaurant. Lots of amazing food choices. The food is so fresh and we have had the same server the last 2 times. Melissa is an excellent, attentive server. I highly recommend Brewsters as well as Melissa.

Outdoor patio is perfect for this time of year. Great food and friendly service

So fun, great night with friends.