Aunt Butchies of Brooklyn - Staten Island

Food was good.

Great service, our waiter was very knowledgeable. We were there on $10 pasta Tuesdays - well worth it! We will definitely be back again! Hopefully will save room for dessert.

We have been to A B before went back due to positive experiences
Unfortunately this visit was no that enjoyable
Food was ok service not that good waiter pouring water in glass spilled half the pitcher on the table walked away without offering to clean I had to ask for napkins and wipe up myself
Two dinners had pasta dishes no one ever came around offering cheese
When I received my coffee half was spilled in saucer
There was a teen birthday party of around 15 people in main dinning room extremely loud should have been in separate room

Great staff, very attentive. And the food was delicious!

Christmas Eve Dinner - Family Style - Fun, Casual, Delicious, Great Service!

Perfect venue for quiet dinner with friends

I had dinner at the bar. As always, JoAnne was incredible. Great bartender and server. The vegetarian options are great , although I wish they had more. The pumpkin soup was awesome. JoAnne kept the bar alive- well someone has to! Thanks for a great night, great drinks and food ! And to Angelo - “I’ll pesce ...”

Food was amazing. Quaint room. Only downfall was that we wanted the butternut squash risotto which was in special menu and they didn’t have it. Highly recommend this restaurant

My birthday

Food was ok. Service was great. Made a reservation, had to wait a little bit do to parties.

A little disappointing since I had heard such great things. Calamari and baked clams were too chewy, but the mozzarella spiedini was delicious. My husband ordered veal marsala which was not tender and my sister-in-law and I ordered Shrimp oreganata which was overcooked and dry, which made the shrimp tough. As I expected, dessert was great. Caramel cone cheesecake, fried cheesecake and cannoli cream with the broken cannoli shel chips were all fabulous. I would definitely go back for dessert.

9 moms out for a girls night. We'r code the family style dinner and it was delicious. Wait staff went above and beyond. Thanks for a great night!

So disappointed. The gnocchi special lacked flavor. The cannoli chips and dip for two was very good but You got a pile of chips and the tiniest bowl of dip. The service wasn’t good either. They never refilled our water or asked if I would like another drink. With the exception of one other party we were the only people in the place. I really hope this was just an off night because I really like this place.

Great food and service

They turned us away even though we had recieved a confirmation for this reservation. Great place but dont bother with open table since they seem to ignore it

Escarole & Beans was not on menu but I asked the server to ask the chef if it can be made ( they have pasta fagioli on the menu do I knew they had the cannellini beans). The owner came over to me & asked red base ok, of course I said “yes”. It was delicious! Beware: a small bowl is no small portion!

Excellent food and service. I will return soon with friends

This review is based on a pre-set Easter Menu. The variety was great and the food tasted good except that a lot of the food was room temp to cold...would have been excellent if it was served hot. Service was very good. Noise level...ridiculously loud. I felt like I was screaming so the person right next to me could hear me.

I have eaten here before and really enjoyed it...so I would prob go back...but not on a Holiday with a pre-set menu.

Anyone who likes good italian food should come here , portions are great , desserts are amazing ....you wont leave dissapointed or hungry

Food is just wonderful, worker are very pleasant and friendly

Great food and service

Always an amazing time here ! Service, food and ambiance is top notch !!!

Food and portions were great. Also liked that specials posted with prices. Liked able to purchase baked goods separately and cheaper to go.

Crowded but good food

I made a reservation on opentable. When I arrived, the manager stated to the hostess, where the hell did this reservation come from?!?! They told us it that it would be at least an hour wait. Not professional. We left. If they can't accommodate a reservation, they should have blocked opentable or at least called me beforehand.

There were 2 parties going on in the restaurant when we arrived. It was noisy!!! The menu was average. The service was excellent. The food was good but for the price it should have been spectacular..... I probably will not return.

It was moms birthday and we were 10 total in the party and the restaurant was excellent.

Had a nice lunch but took too long to get our check

Great throwback venue... good food , good service , and nice people

The food was delicious and the service was good! Things to keep in mind: the noise levels on a Saturday night do not allow for an intimate dinner so it is ideal for groups.

Cons: Half of my table requested risotto as a side. Unfortunately, they were not told until the dishes came out that they had ran out of risotto. Please let guests know if there are any changes to their initial order.

Everything was very nice for the dinner we had. Food was very good and there was a nice variety to choose from. Will definitely come back again.

Had a nice dinner unfortunately my 545 reservation didnt mean too much as I was seated at 7:00 with no one really acknowledging it until they came to get us

The food was excellent. The service was really good. Will definitely be going back..

Went for Xmas eve - Very good food & attentive service.

Chicken parm was surprisingly good. However, the red velvet cake was not.

As always a great meal. But one compliant we always have to wait even with a reservation.

The staff were very nice, friendly and helpful. The food was delicious.

Was a great dinner evening ! Perfect birthday celebration .. luv the firework for the desert bday 👍🏻

Very attentive. Good food 🥘 delicious desserts. Really enjoyed

I love this place in Staten Island. Lively place good food and desserts. Great for birthdays. They sing to you and you receive a t-shirt. Worth the ride from Brooklyn. Ed meet their with our friends from New Jersey.