Awesome food, cocktails and vibe.

Great experience! The staff and food were great!

Great food, but hard to talk over the noise level.

Excellent pizza, service and pasta!

This place is great. Service is always on point, great wine selection, and food is on point. We’ve never been disappointed whether it’s a date night or a family night, always satisfied.

The margarita pizza and mushroom pizzas were great.
The eggplant parmigiana appetizer was great.
Pesto lasagna was delicious, but quite small.
They had the music turned up a bit too loud for my taste and, although I like dim lighting, it was a little too dark for me.
Great place overall!

Pizza was good but a little doughy. Had the calamari shrimp appetizer which was very good. Service was fast and friendly.

As ever, the service was outstanding. While we were sorry to see some favorites disappear from the menu, the food we got was delicious, fresh and creative. The air conditioning felt like it had been upgraded, and we were all comfortable. The place is known for their coal fired Pizza‘s but don’t miss the octopus, the chicken, and the Bronzino- all superb.
Unfortunately I keep forgetting to take pictures before I dig in! Yummy yummy yummy!

Just all around wonderful place to dine!

Easily added to my list of favorite pizza spots. The pepperoni was flavorful, plentiful and crispy! Rigatoni ala vodka was perfection as well.

The food here is so incredibly delicious. It is mostly wood fired pizzas, and they taste just like the pizzas we had in Italy. Their lightly fried zucchini flowers are delectable. The rigatoni ala vodka is homemade pasta w a very delicious sauce. Everything had a slight gourmet flair without being fancy. Our favorite new restaurant.

Great time. Good food. Good drinks. Not expensive

Great new pizza alternative for Huntington! Perfect crust
Imaginative flavor profiles. Great salads. Imagine dynamite rice balls!
Full bar! Go for the pizza, amazing!

Noise level was extremely high, especially as the restaurant became more crowded.

Exceptional service by all servers and staff. Frank goes above and beyond to make sure each table is enjoying their meal. You can't go wrong with anything on the menu!

Awesome food, great service & cool vibe.

Cannot say enough good things about 1653! From the pizzas and pastas to their expertly crafted cocktails and specials, you really can’t go wrong! The pesto lasagna is literally what my dreams are made of. Look forward to keeping this as a regular in my restaurant rotation!

Second time here, always a warm and welcoming experience. The Rigatoni Vodka is the single best dish of any restaurant in the village!!!

Food and service were very good…however…. The restaurant was extremely loud… the music was distracting and the room was dimly lit…

1653 Pizza Company has become my new 'go to' restaurant in the village. Frank always greeting the tables, making you feel not only welcome but appreciated. The food is incredible; Must try the Pistachio Pesto Lasagna & the Eggplant brings me right back to my Sicilian grandma's kitchen. Love love love this place.

Food was fantastic. Definitely one of our new favorite restaurants in town. Can't wait to return.

We were met with a smile and a gracious host .
We ordered several pies to share . Each one was delicious

Great dining experience all around!

If you are looking to eat some fresh and authentic Italian food and have a well made drink, all at a reasonable price go to 1653 Pizza Company. The service and overall vibe of the place was also great. I will definitely be back!

Great atmosphere and yummy food!

Food was great, and so were the drinks! We will be back for sure.

AMAZING Food/ atmosphere/staff!

Tasted the octopus, Parma Pizza and Pasta Carbonara - all winners - craft cocktails and wine list also great

One of the few places in Long Island to have an authentic clam pie. Well worth a visit

Scrumptious Neapolitan Style Pizza, hip cocktail list, comfy vibe and awesome service!

The food and service was fantastic! We can’t wait to go back BUT will only return when the weather gets cooler. The restaurant is extremely hot and it makes the dining experience uncomfortable. It felt as if there was no AC in the place, it was cooler outside than In The restaurant.

An outstanding addition to Huntington Village! Always consistent, the service is amazing, such friendly staff. The food is a whole different level of amazingness. This is a must try and definitely somewhere to go on a routine basis for a great meal, fabulous drinks and fun atmosphere.

Great food, great service and a fun place! The owners are very welcoming and the atmosphere is upbeat with feel good energy. This is my new spot to go to on Long Island!

This is hands down the best pizza on the island! Comparable to top pizza spots in the city. The pies are a fairly unique combination between classic NY pizza and Neapolitan. The crust is incredible, especially if you get a slightly burnt pie. To top it off, the owner is incredibly nice! Service could be improved, but it’s not a dealbreaker by any means.

Great pizza. A little loud for conversation.

Our table was ready early, and the staff was very good about sitting us and letting my fiancée and I wait at the table. We had two amazing Negronis and looked at the menu~ our group’s favorite was the Clam pie, but the Chicken, Pesto Lasagna and the tortelli were all huge hits! Great food and perfect for a casual yet classy vibe~ you want to share everything because everything is so good to prevent missing out~ highly recommend!

Awesome food awesome ambiance

Great addition to huntington. Some of the most creative and delicious pizza on the island, but don’t stop with the pizza. The pastas as my 13 year old said “ it taste like someone’s grandmother is in the back making the pesto “ and that’s not even his favorite. Try the carbonara. Love the organic wine selections and there is a great cocktail team behind the bar making incredible elixirs. It’s a once a week stop.

The food is absolutely amazing, each dish truly was remarkable. The staff is also extremely accommodating and hospitable, not to mention the ambience is really cool. Will be back, Frank truly knows how to operate a terrific ship here.

The pizza was fantastic. The crust was outstanding. The octopus app was so tasty with such a great flavor combo. Eggplant parm so good also I loved your sauce. I judge a place on their tomato sauce and this was notch! Can’t wait to go back!