Carpaccio of Filet Mignon, Parmigiano Reggiano & Tomato Relish
Drizzled with truffle oil – served with crostinis
10 oz. Filet Broiled to your liking. All of our Steaks are Char-Broiled to your liking with Prime's Signature Seasoning & Served with Fresh Oven Roasted Garlic, Red Wine Demi-glaze and Fresh Rosemary
Jumbo Lump Crab Cake
Fantastic dinner and dining experience. Our server, Moses, was wonderful. The food was delicious.
The restaurant setting was warm, elegant and romantic. The staff were knowledgeable, professional, friendly and eager to please, even accommodating two extra people in our party. The rib eye was exceptional and large enough to split between two people.
If we lived in the area, prime steakhouse would be a regular date night destination for us!
We highly recommend this restaurant!
Dinner was fantastic! Steaks were cooked perfect and the roasted garlic made the dish!
The greatest service and the homemade cheesecake was the best I’ve ever had! The steak and seafood was totally awesome!
The portion sizes were perfect The escargot were delicious as was the filet mignon. The grouper Oscar special was was cooked to perfection.
We arrived 75 minutes early and they greeted us with a smile and cleaned a table for us. The service was excellent and the food was OUTSTANDING!! You must try the crab cake appetizer - it’s all crab and no filler!! Also, the veal chop is incredible!!!! We highly recommend Prime and will be going again!!!
Phillip was a great server and the food was wonderful!
Excellent service. Excellent food. Steak was done perfectly. Lobster was outstanding. Highly recommended
One of the best steaks I’ve had, super wine list & great service. Will dine here every time I am in Key west!!
Delicious meal! Perfect 🍸. I noted our 20th wedding anniversary.. our menu noted the occasion 😍 and a complementary dessert with a sparkler picture PERFECT NIGHT !!!!!
Filet mignon was excellent! Ordered side of fries which were not impressive. But the steak totally made up for that slack. Had a chocolate mouse tart for dessert which was also very good.
Service was phenomenal! Very nice experience.
Outstanding service coupled with wonderful steaks.
Was pleasantly surprised. This place beat some famous high end places I have been to in the past. Great service to the point of it being perfect service. Everything was timed out perfectly. Server attended to every need without being overbearing. Appetizer was unbelievable. The bone in veal chop was honestly the best I’ve ever had. Would do it again when in Key West.
The food was amazing & our waiter was so attentive! The ambience was very nice.
Great selection, amazing food, real fine dinnig ambience, if you sit inside, thoughtful manager. The service from Czech guy named Filip was outstanding as we're his drinks.
Great veal chop . My wife had twin lobsters great. Bread and butter were superb. We love this place and always enjoy eating there.
Prime was awesome. Our server was fantastic and the food was even better!
Waitress Kim was fantastic. Shrimp were the best. Gotta go key lime!!
Visited for my son’s graduation dinner- delicious from start to finish!
2nd time writing this review as the website flaked when I tried to save my previous review.
So I'm going to be brief. Really liked Tony our server...he was informative, dry wit, and patient. He kept a good cadence checking in.
The food was well above average - wife had filet and it was tender and flavorful. I had a special - local fish and crab meat that Tony recommended. It was a good recommendation. my wife's she crab soup was lukewarm.
Place is a little hard to find, tucked away at the back of a mostly closed shopping center, along the waterfront.
The best steak I’ve ever had. The service and the food were outstanding. Highly recommend
Delicious food, great drinks, excellent service! Highly recommended while you are in Key West.
nothing more to add
as per questions great place
waiter ver friendly
The service was good, however, the kitchen really screwed up my order. I ordered a MR Filet and it came out MW. My dinner guest had finished her dinner by the time my new MR Filet was served. When they took my Filet back, they left all of my sides that I ordered. They were absolutely cold when the new Filet was brought out. No manager visit to apologize and the waitstaff at the end was more or less ignoring our table. Having been a waiter for over 25 years, I believe that this was due to the embarrassing situation. The bill for 2 people was over $230 and I still left a $60 tip as this was not the waiters fault but rather the restaurant management.
Great all around food ambiance and service. Excellent choice.
Thx for celebrating my 60th bday with me! It was absolutely delicious and lovely. A dining experience to remember and want to repeat.
We sat at a lovely private table as we were celebrating my husbands birthday. The service and experience was absolutely wonderful and we plan to come back.
Nice eating out on the patio. Service was good. Our steaks were over cooked unfortunately but well seasoned. Drinks were decent.
First dinner out in over a year and I'm so glad we chose Prime. Food is great, service is top notch and it continues to be one of my favorite restaurants on the island.
Food was amazing. Especially the mac-n-cheese. Service was on point.
Great food, nice ambience and waiter Cavell was awesome and very attending!
Was disappointed in the steaks, expected better from a steak house.
Their steaks and appetizers amazing, their drinks superb, the wait staff and management go above and beyond!!
So glad we made reservations for Prime the food was absolutely amazing. Our party does not eat sea food so being able to find a great steak was a must! The baked potato came with all the fixings on the side so you can fix up your potato the way you want. Our waiter was really good and did a good job. The bathrooms were very clean.
We will definitely make a reservation the next time we go to the keys.
Prime is everything you want in a steakhouse! Our favorite in Key West! Never disappointed.
Great food. Great service.
Excellent and nice touch with the special birthday menu! Food was very good
We had a party of 6. All ordered steaks. Best service and steak in Key West.
The food and atmosphere was perfect. The waiter was exceptional and the place was clean and covid safe.
Prime Steakhouse is rated 4.8 stars by 1677 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.