Open at 4:30pm on Fridays and Saturdays
Friday Only Lunch- 11:30am- 2pm
Pitrelli's is an absolute gem. Quiet, cozy, with superb cuisine. It is evident the amount of effort put forth by ALL staff at this establishment to ensure your meal and experience are both extraordinary. The service is second to none in my opinion. The menu will have you salivating, and the meal will leave you in awe. You feel like family upon arrival until the moment you walk out the door. I would recommend this treasure to anyone and everyone.
Always consistent and very good!! We don’t get there often enough!!
To many small children not well behaved and wait staff didn't seem to mind children yelling and messing with food on table and for as good as the food was the ambience sucked , maybe all small children in one room with families and adults and couples in another for date nite not recommended could not have quiet conversation which is why we chose an Italian resturant and not O Charlie's
Outstanding service and food. I went with friends on a Friday night. Everyone ‘s entire was delicious and nicely presented. Food was hot and plenty of it. Nice wine list. Highly recommend.
We have been to Pitrelli's several times, and have always enjoyed our experience. I personally recommend giving their special dishes a try! On our most recent visit, we introduced another couple to the restaurant, where we dined on New Year's Eve. They, too, were pleased with the ambiance and the menu. Although our service was a little slow, we appreciated the time for conversation and had a wonderful experience. If you're looking for a unique Italian restaurant that's not part of a chain and offers true Italian food, this is the place!
Always a great time and meal at Pitrelli’s
New Year’s Eve
Food was, at best, bland. The host was swearing under his breath before he sat us. The table was an old picnic table with lattice work all around. It took forever for the food and drinks to come...white wine was not chilled...all around terrible experience. The waitress was pleasant, polite and professional if not over taxed...the only good thing about dinner. We will NEVER spend another dime there.
We could have gone anywhere in Cincinnati for NYE dinner, we chose Pitrelli's. Enough said.
Love this place!
New Year’s Eve dinner out, Always a great time
You can't go wrong at Pitrelli's.. The service and food are always excellent.
New Year’s Eve
Crab cakes were cold, timing of entrees were off. Kids ordered a pizza that came out after the adults were done eating... Probably an off night...
Service was average at best...
Not as good overall as it has been in the past. Service needs improvement.
Family Christmas get together
We were looking to try something different for a double date night. Everyone loved their food. The lasagna was the creamiest lasagna I’ve ever had. The herb butter served with the bread was delicious. We started with the calamari. Also delicious. Would definitely recommend.
Great evening at Pitrelli's. Our server Dave was great. Food was very good.
The meal is always a little better when seated in David’s section, otherwise the service is lacking a bit. It was a very busy evening, but still. Staff was friendly. Food was excellent as always.
I wouldn't know how the food is since we were seated and then sat for 20 minutes with no service. We decided to leave and was telling the host about the problem. He said "it is not my problem" and laughed at me.
This was supposed to be a birthday meal for my daughter- we celebrated at Wendy's instead.
If you are looking for no service and smug millennials telling you that no service is your fault, then this is the restaurant for you.
Extremely slow service.
I would not recommend this to anybody. Food fair that's being generous. Atmosphere. None. Very very overpriced!! I eat out 4 to 5 times a week and try differant resturants so I have a lot to compare it to.. I don't usually write a review but want to save someone the same experience
Excellent food. Service was efficient. Always nice to see a hands on owner which makes this restaurant special. Wine is reasonably priced.
We live and work in Dayton. A coworker recommended this gem they found while visiting friends in Mason one weekend. We had a pizza, soup, and a Caesar salad for dinner and they were all delicious! I hear the meatballs and pasta are very good too so we plan on visiting Pitrellis again over the holidays.
My husband and I have date night every Friday and we love coming here
A great, family owned Italian restaurant, really good food at fair prices. Their pizza is fantastic!
We Always enjoy Pitrelli’s for the food and the neighborhood feel. The Mason Cheers
Pitrelli’s serves great, authentic Italian food. We ordered eggplant Parmesan, and a salmon dish with lots of Italian vegetables in it. Both were very tasty and we had all we could eat and still took some home, which we had for lunch the next day. Oh, lest I forget, we had an appetizer of meat balls, and sausages, which were delicious.
We heartily recommend Pitrelli’s for an excellent Italian dinner.
Food was delicious, service was friendly and prompt and the cost was reasonable. We love Pitrelli’s!
Even thou this is an Italian Restaurant, do not rule out the meatloaf at the bottom of the menu. Outstanding and enough for two people. Bar tender and server and owner were all fantastic and attentive....great place.
Always have great food and friendly service
The food is great and the service is also great. We enjoy going to a nice Italian restaurant and this works for us.
Extremely long time to get entrees (45+ min)
Must have hit on an "off" night. We've eaten here oquite a few times before but it just wasn't what as good as usual. Food came out in "spirts" vs. all being served at the same time. Not sure the sauce I got was what I ordered and wondered if that's why my meal came out last. Waitress was friendly and made us feel special, but I think she might have had too many tables to give us the attention we've received in the past. It's expensive so our expectations are high. Will try again and hope that this was just one of those nights.
Food was very safe. Not bad, but not great, just ok.
Always a pleasure. We always feel great when we leave.
Unfortunately we came in when two large parties had come in as well and the kitchen was overwhelmed. The owner made up for it and was very nice.
Love Pitrellis! We go back here again and again and it's always good! They had some new menu offerings on this visit as well as all the old favorites. Food is always fresh, hot, homemade and delicious. You just can't go wrong with Pitrellis. Wine list and desserts are fantastic as well.