Pierre's Restaurant & Lounge

Fantastic food!! Just wonderful! Staff and ambiance were terrific. The prices are steep. But we still ordered the food and ate 3 courses!! So, it was great!

Fantastic noise level high was due to music and full moon party which was amazing.

I will give them this... it is a pretty setting. We requested a table on the porch when reserving but when we got there we were told there was no table available on the porch because their lodge guests get first priority. We were put inside in their stuffy dining room. We still had a distant view through other tables. Our waitress was notably abrupt and unfriendly. She would not accommodate any request. For example, one guest reasonably asked to substitute roasted potatoes (which were on the menu included with other entrees) for fennel which was included on their entree because she does not like fennel. The waitress said the chef allows no substitutions for any reason. The guest said "OK, then please leave the fennel off" and the waitress said no, it would run the presentation. All in all we would have preferred a casual dinner on the beach at their sister restaurant next door. But, we were celebrating two occasions and thought Pierres would be nicer. By the way , they knew of the celebrations and offered nothing.

Ladies celebrating life and friendship

We requested outside patio but it wasn’t ready when we arrived so we had a drink on the porch to watch rest of the sunset. Great location with casual elegance! Morada Bay Beach Café great for lunch but Pierre’s is for a more romantic upscale experience! I had the yellowtail tuna and my husband had the snapper. Both were the best we had our entire trip. Key lime also very good.

This is definitely not a fish restaurant despite the beach location. Lamb chops were outstanding, but fish (grouper) was lacking flavor, the creamy cause was not complimenting and choice of vegetables was strange to say the least: green beans and potatoes with skin on are more appropriate for meat dishes.

If you want to experience a memorable evening...come to Pierre's

Ambiance is second to none, the sunset is gorgeous. Service was fantastic as well as the food. Best grouper I’ve had and we frequent many upscale restaurants. When we asked about some of the food dishes our waiter was extremely knowledgeable.

We had a wonderful dinner. Peter was informative and fun, awesome service. Lobster with Forbidden Black Rice was interesting and tasty. $40 corkage...ouch.

We dined at sunset and had an outdoor table overlooking the water with unobstructed views. Our server was very professional and attentive. We ordered some inspired cocktails that were delicious.

The menu is oriented towards fresh seafood, but other fare is also present. Our salads, octopus appetizer and local-catch fish entree were prepared to perfection. The wine list was adequate but appropriate for the menu, with a bias toward New World vintages. However we able to find a nice French Chablis that was perfect. One note on the wine service: the first bottle we ordered was a white Burgundy that turned out to be corked. Our waitress acknowledged it immediately and was quick to help us find something else to our liking.

The dessert offerings were also great and paired with a fine port.

This place is not inexpensive, but it is a great destination for a special romantic dinner.

Amazing in every way! Best dining experience in Islamorada.

Great view. Food could be better.

Everything about Pierre’s was excellent. The table linens, glassware and silver made for an upscale table setting. The setting—outside on the deck—at sunset was so beautiful. A delicious bottle of Cab, along with deliciously prepared fresh seafood, made for a complete over-the-top experience. Not to be missed: snow crab claws, curried lobster!

Wonderful food and experience! Highly recommend.

Every aspect of our experience here was fantastic!

Everything was great except for the food, it was uninspiring and lacked originality, with rather bland appetizers and entrees.

Disappointing given the location,service and ambience was excellent.

Fantastic food service was nice presentation lovely

Great food and location

We come here every trip to Islamorada. Consistently wonderful. Lina our server is well known to us and a great asset to Pierre’s. Wines wonderful. Pricey but worth it. We ate late but the views earlier in the evening are beautiful. Bloodline was filmed here and the stories about our cast favorites are entertaining . A must dining experience

The food was very good, however the service was slow. For such a lovely restaurant it was disappointing to have such an inattentive waitress.

Food was spectacular - fresh, interesting, beautifully presented. If you go, bring a credit card with a VERY high credit limit. $75 for a steak! $50 for the lobster entree I split with my friend. A tiny (though delicious) salad for $15. Ambience on the terrace overlooking the bay at sunset was beautiful. Waiter was pretentious. My entree included coconut served still in the shell. When I asked if he could split it open and get the coconut out so I could eat it, that seemed to surprise him. Although he took it back to the kitchen and told me someone who was "the best" had prepared it, I saw no change, and was unable to get at the coconut to eat it.

Great wine, French onion soup, and special Iberian ham!

Restaurant was probably best eating experience ever..our waitress Lena was so attentive and knowledgeable not to mention the manager who was just the greatest..stopped to make sure we were having a good time and found out he was from our home town..you have to experience this place!

Beautiful ambiance, great service, questionable value. My $70 filet was average at best.

Restaurant was extremly elegant
Waiter & hostess was very pleasant & great service
Food was OK
Portions were fine
Just very expensive as check was $250 for a couple & 6 yr old

Great ambiance

Wonderful evening. Nice place to watch the sunset!

The staff and atmosphere was fabulous from top to bottom, the food was exquisite and chef John Delouch came out to chat with us. It was so good, we went back the next day!

Wonderful food and views at Pierre’s. High end dining in Islamorada. Drinks and sunset at morada bay (next door) beforehand make for a perfect happy hour !

The restaurant is beautiful, however service was awful. Not only did we get seated about 40 minutes late but once we got seated it took about 20 more minutes for anyone to bring us a menu. My lobster was great but my boyfriend ordered steak and it was terrible.

The location was beautiful and the food was spectacular! We went for the Full Moon party and it was so much fun! I can’t wait to do this again and will definitely be planning my next trip around this event.

Terrific French cuisine - worth the drive from Key Largo. Parking can be a bit of a challenge as this restaurant's lot is also for resorts other, more casual, restaurant.

The food was great as was the service but the prefixed menu for Valentines day was incredibly expensive.
I was poor and hungry after the lovely evening.

Everything was absolutely amazing, phenomenal food, service and ambiance.

One of the finest places I’ve ever dined at in the Keys!!!

The snowy grouper was so good!!!

Fantastic place for dinner- from atmosphere to derive to food!

Amazing location and ambiance, some of the food is incredible and some is "only" great. Would definitely recommend for a special occasion in the Keys.

Pierre’s is absolute perfection! The lion fish app is amazing, as is their lobster entree! We will be coming back!

Excellent place.Nice ambiance with friendly and attentive staff.Food was really good and lived up to expectations as the dishes were recommended by a diner we met thenightbefore

What a beautiful location! The food,ambiance, and serice were outstanding. Very romantic with a Casa Blanca flair! Looking forward to going again!

The team went out of their way to help us celebrate our engagement, the food was fantastic, and the ambiance perfect.