Food and service was excellent. Had NY strip with a truffle mash. So good. My husband had the panco pork chop which was excellent and my dad loved the seafood linguini. Best meal I had all week in the keys.
We loved it. Seemed a little underutilized. We appreciated the complimentary celebratory dessert.
We went for Mother’s Day and the restaurant was quiet due to storms. Our server was a doll and made our experience 5 stars. The food was delicious and appetizing. Nice portions a d delicious!
We had a great group dinner on our last night in town. Our meals were delicious and we had great service. We will definitely be back on our next trip to Key West!
Very good service and fresh fish.
We sat inside and the restaurant was beautiful. Our server was very attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. I had the NY strip and lobster tail and it was perfection! The bread and conch chowder were also very delicious! Great wine list!
Awesome location. Food was delicious and service was spectacular!
Nice outdoor atmosphere. The wait staff is attentive and accommodating. We both had seafood, fresh, delicious, and local.
‘‘Twas a lovely dinner we had at One Duval—the ambiance tropical, the service professional and unobtrusive, and meal exceptional. It was a better deal before the 40% price hike, however.
Not sure why this place gets such great reviews. Food was ok for the price. Ambiance was nice but you can’t see the sunset. Service was good. So many other places to go in key west though.
Sitting on the edge of the ocean under a star filled sky having delicious seafood, made for a lovely evening. And, original key lime pie with meringue !!! Not whipped cream. You must try it.
3/17/18 great spot for a fantastic dinner. Close enough to the action on the street, but private and incredible food.
We enjoyed our evening at Duval One. The poor weather, very windy, meant that we had to eat inside, and unfortunately the tables were cocktail tables, ie lower than eating tables, this is not a comfortable eating position for me. But the food was great, and the service was attentive.
Wonderful experience!! The food was delicious!
We found this restaurant on open table. We were seated on the patio overlooking the harbor. Though it was dark, the setting was very relaxing. Our waitress was very personable and bubbly. The food was all very good. We had everything from crab stuffed grouper to lobster to soup and salad. All in the party thoughly enjoyed our experience.
Beautiful setting lovely evening!
We had a beautiful view from our dinner table—boats going out to see sunset, birds, the beach—it was delightful. The locals ‘ special offered something for everyone, and at an amazing price, too. The shrimp fettuccine was superb; the yellowtail got raves, as well. Caesar and caprese salads were fresh and beautifully presented. The service was excellent, just like everything else about our experience at One Duval.
What an incredible dinner! From start to finish it was the best. Our server Linda was super and we’d be happy to repeat the whole experience.
Not sure why this restaurant even accepts reservations. When we arrived we were informed that there were actually no tables available outside, which is really the only reason to eat there, and we were put inside at what I would describe as a cocktail table at best. The inside room smelled awful. Totally a musty mildew smell through the entire place. We were the only people in the inside. After 10 minutes of sitting there and waiting for someone to at least take a drink order, we finally gave up and left. Totally awful experience. I rated the food a one only because I could not leave it blank. Food might be good. I guess if I had a chance to order something, I might have given it a different rating.
One Duval is great place for dinner very nice stuff great experience
Great dinner ; ambiance
We had reserved to eat outside but it was windy and cold and moved inside ... glad we did as inside was cozy and unique ... loved it!
Great experience all around. Service was great. Food was delicious. Nice presentation. Large portions. Highly recommend!
Outstanding fine dining food and service. Exceptional food presented beautifully and cooked to perfection at the right price. They had a special NYE celebration menu and you can still order dishes from their regular dinner menu which is great as other restaurants are not flexible with their menus. Other fine dine restaurants in Key West were charging fixed $95 to $125 per person for their NYE 3 course dinner. Not here thankfully as guests are flexible to order as little or as much as we wanted. Set by the sea front was a beautiful setting for views over the ocean during the day but we booked to sit inside for our family NYE dinner as it was dark outside with no views. Inside room was just as beautiful and intimate, quiet enough for conversation. Our server was excellent with great attention to detail I felt this place was not pretentious at all. Our final bill was on the money for a special occasion and was worth every penny. My only complaint was we booked to sit inside for dinner at a specific table for 4 in their busy dining room but they wanted to seat us in the breakfast room where there was zero people. This confusion was quickly sorted and we sat at the table we originally booked. Glad we booked the peaceful One Duval for dinner and was ready to party with all the mad revellers on Duval Street to bring in 2018!
Food was good, staff was very nice. Value was good because of their special offering with entree and either starter or dessert. They are understaffed due to Irma so please be patient. Drinks were great too
Always have a great experience and terrific food! Cody is such a sweet waitress!
Wonderful food. It has a beautiful water view and location. Hope to visit again.
Excellent food and service. Cory (sp? Female) made the evening. A very enchanting young lady that made our last evening in Key West the most memorable. We thoroughly enjoyed the evening and meal.
The premiere restaurant at the Pier House resort. Has both indoor and outdoor dining. A good menu and good food with attentive service. Recommended for a special night out.
Went to Pier House Restaurant for Thanksgiving Dinner. The dinner was great.
The food was fantastic and the view was even better. This was a last minute scramble to find a restaurant and found a real gem. I would go back again.
Was there for our anniversary and thoroughly enjoyed everything about it.
Didn't have full menu was under construction never told us before booking
My son and I were on vacation in Key West and had our last dinner there before leaving the next day. The food, service, and atmosphere were all excellent. It was a great way to end the trip.
Family vacation! Lovely ocean view, food was well prepared but not incredibly memorable. Service was friendly and helpful. However food took a long time to be ready despite the restaurant being less than 50% full. Its a little too quiet as its located in the inside of a boutique hotel.
Very nice dining experience
Vacation meal, one server for outside patio but he did good job
Slow bringing drinks but besides that great service
We did not end up dining here. Several wine options were not available and left us with a very limited wine list. We chose to go elsewhere.
It was our 1st wedding anniversary and the service was attentive, courteous, and polite! They made us feel so very special with a free key lime pie that was awesome! Highly recommend and we will be back!
Fantastic experience! Very attentive servers and fabulous food. We had the scallops and prosciutto appetizer and the seafood pasta. Really cool atmosphere.