Old Surrey restaurant is always very good. This time the meals were partly a bit less hot as they should have been, but still very good and very tasty.

First time here. Seen this place since we moved to Canada in 1996. But for some reason we as a family never went here. Then when I found out it was fine dining, I was hesitant to come here at first. Fast forward to today and here I am with my gf having a 3 course meal.

First course: Beef Tenderloin Tostada - wasn't anything too special, it kinda tasted like fancy corned beef, I'd still eat it

Second course: Classic Caesar Salad with romaine hearts, parmesan & and freshly baked croutons. - they make this table side, and when they asked if we liked cheese, they used the entire serving of cheese that they had, this was delicious

Main course: Filet Mignon Wellington - this was my frost time having a beef wellington and this did not disappoint. The meat was very juicy and the pastry was a nice addition.

Dessert: Fall Harvest Walnut Brownie with pistachio ice cream flambeed tableside with Amaretto caramel - they flambeed it table side, fire! What else can you ask for, this was surprisingly not as sweet as I thought it would be. The peach was also a nice touch

Drinks:
(1) bitter orange rosemary cider - I am not a cider person but this was refreshing, the gf liked this a lot

(2) Whalley Wonka martini - this one paired well with the dessert especially if you love chocolate. This was made with vodka, creme de cacao, Kahlua and frangelico, very yummy

Service was amazing, staff was very friendly, chatty and very attentive.

Would definitely visit again

Best seafood and 5 class service. I go there often as it always better than the last.

After almost two years of not being able to go out to dine, we wires happy to return to one of our favourite restaurants. The service, as usual, was exemplary. The food, without a doubt, was delicious. Our biggest treat is to watch them prepare our Caesar salads at the table. My steak was done to perfection. My husband's meal was equally delicious. We are definitely going back in December for my hubby's birthday.

Excellent food with an old school vibe. Everything tasted great and appreciated the table-side menu items. A fun retro dining experience. Everyone’s meals were fabulous. The scallop appetizer was divine. First time going but will be back. A lovely dining experience in a surprising location

Had a wonderful Anniversary celebration, was our first time here and will most definitely return. Food was great, staff and service also great! Thank you!

It was a great event no. Great food. Great service

Always outstanding. Great to be able to go there again.

I would say this is the best place around to go for a special occasion. Service and food is absolutely amazing. Will be back soon.

The staff were so nice and attentive. Quality service. Friendly staff. Quality meal. Highly recommend

Steak, seafood and pork were all good. I asked how many scallops were in the appy..I was told 5 and there were 3. Veggies bland. $10 for local bottled beer is just crazy! Given that, I would still give them another try

Absolutely fabulous evening enjoying the Fall special. We have been here numerous times, and it never disappoints.

Went here after living in Surrey for years and always wanting to go. The atmosphere was romantic, service was nice and food was good. Only negative I could say was it was a little too quiet.

Loved the individual rooms holding only a few tables each. Lovely ambience with vintage elegant decor and easy
listening music. Service was polite, efficient, and friendly. Wine list was decent but the draft beer list needs some good craft breweries in it. We had the scallop appetizer which was delicious and my husband enjoyed his pepper steak though wasn’t a big fan of the veggies. I had the Halibut Special with a dill cream sauce. The fish was perfectly cooked but unfortunately I found the sauce bland. I can see why they still draw diners, and they are probably one of the very few restaurants to offer “vintage” favourites such as Chateaubriand and Cherries Jubilee. However, they could do with some modernizing in their dishes as to presentation and taste.

Absolute disaster of a meal!!Both my son-in-law and I gave our prime rib dinners back as they we so salty they were not fit for consumption by any creature on this planet!
The scallop appetizer was bathed in an unsavoury cheese cream sauce flavoured with Sambuca that masked any flavour of the shellfish.
My daughter and wife had the Fall Special featuring Beef Wellington that was average at best.All meals were presented with Brussel Sprouts that were not cooked and uncutable by any means.Potato croquettes,beets and cauliflower were fine though only two of our party ate them.
After mentioning the terrible state of the food,we were informed that one of the waiters was substituting for the main cook who asked for the night off from his duties.I find it incredible that this occurred on a Saturday night with a full house and no trained replacement was able to serve a dinner of quality that customers come to expect of this expensive restaurant.
We have patronized this restaurant for over 30 years and feel betrayed and insulted by paying over $342 for food of such inferior,disgusting quality!
If this is the best that can be done,you won’t be in business long after cheating your longtime patrons!!

The chef's special, Halibut was excellent! Cooked to perfection.
The Fish plate was a 10..The baked Oysters were the BEST I've ever eaten.
Service was a 10 also. We were very lucky to have the Owner of the restaurant come to our table, as I've been going there since the opening in 1974. All and all a great place to be when you want exquisite dinner at it's finest. I'll keep going back....
Love The Old Surrey Restaurant Cheers!!

Had never had the opportunity to go to this special restaurant. Boy were we missing out! Everything was fabulous and we have already told so many people to give it a try. Can’t wait to plan another visit when we have a special occasion. So nice to be treated In luxurious surroundings and get dressed up for a memorable meal

Try it once and you will surely fall in love. A place that cannot be forgotten. Elegant but affordable for everyone. Dishes from the French menu. For everyday and festive occasions!

Well we greeted and seated quickly 7:45pm reservations, then the waiting began 40 min for Appie scallops were tasty but very rich sauce and a little to sweet for me , I had the prawns over cooked and under seasoned, then waited a very long time, even our waiter made a comment ( problem in the kitchen ) as other tables around us who were seated 1/2 hr after us got theirs main course before us . I had the halibut tasty and my husband had the lamb very good and well portioned. Didn’t have dessert as it was almost 10 pm

This is my go to restaurant for any special evening.

Regular customer prior Covid. First visit since. Disappointed with the limited choice offered for $75 Fall Special. Ordered the Mussels & Beef & would not recommend either. Dessert - Brownie seemed dried out & hard to cut with spoon. My favourite restaurant but this meal did not meet my expectations. Service & ambiance was good.

This is the only place I know of in BC where you can still get a Caesar salad prepared at your table -- and it was excellent! The service was first class professional and the servers worked like Swiss precision together. Amazing actually!

Food is beyond excellent and service quality is something all restaurants should aspire to

Very good food, service, and ambiance. Would recommend to a friend,
Will be back again

Excellent food, service and and lovely atmosphere always.

Great ambience we were in the library room. Pricey but good for a special occasion

We have been enjoying The Old Surrey Inn for many years. It has been consistently very enjoyable. The Fall menu was fantastic and our server was was funny and gracious. We will be back!

Food is very good. I just do not like that the tables are so close together.
No privacy. I could hear the conversations next tables to us.

I had a great experience at the Old Surrey Inn Restaurant. Beyond expectation!

Beautiful food, lovely decor, elevated service. I recommend completely

Food was great , staff were great and the price is right. What more could you ask for ?

A very nice restaurant in Surrey, that serves very delicious food, along with very good service. I would highly recommend it.

This restaurant is a Surrey fixture. It is the place to go for a celebratory dinner or a wedding proposal. It is NOT old school. Dining selection is first rate. Everything is cooked to perfection. The chef creates an every changing prix fixe menu that is remarkable in its creativity. Solid and well priced wine list. As good as the food is, the wait staff is even better. There are very professional and seem to anticipate your needs. Cannot recommend highly enough.

Great experience, excellent food and atmosphere A true gem in Surrey.

Service, food and atmosphere were excellent.
Thank you for helping us celebrate our 25th anniversary

Comfortable, quiet and reliable old-school classy place. Loved it.

Great experience, perfect for celebrating a birthday, anniversary or something special.

Had a Great Meal with My Wife - The Ceaser is to die for - my Ribeye was Fantastic!

Have been going to this Restaurant for over 20 years and have never had a bad meal or experience

Always an enjoyable night out with great food, excellent service and delightful ambiance.