Food was very good and worth the price. They were out of the stone crab and chocolate chip cookies which was a little disappointing, but the bacon appetizer and filet were very well prepared.

Ordered a small filet and a 12 oz. Got a petite filet for me and a sirloin for my son in error. Did not even offer a free dessert or anything....just asked if it was okay. Did not have time to wait another hour for the right steaks.

Excellent from start to finish. Ordered the Porterhouse for two. Cooked perfectly, great steak! Very good service too. Forget Ruth’s go to NY Prime.

Filet was amazing and cooked to perfection ! The sea bass was just ok. It was dipped in flour and then fried. It was very bland and had a fishy taste.

Absolutely fabulous! Server was excellent and help make the evening more special!

The food was fantastic. The service was top notch and the entire experience was what I expect from a fine restaurant. It is expensive but you get what you pay for

Food was great but everything is overpriced. Service a little snooty. Highly overrated and very overpriced!

One of the absolute best dining experiences my family has had! Rob was a true professional and catered to all our needs effortlessly!

Always the best

Server seemed to busy for us. Even after we ordered bottles. All our food came out at different times. The pictures online were not the picture of the place in person.
(we felt cat-fished.)
Made reservations and they lost our reservation. We were in a seat right next to the kitchen where staff was unprofessional.

Food is outstanding! One of the beat steakhouses I have ever been to. I wish more places would good their steak like NY Prime. All the food had so much flavor and was season too perfection. The only reason I did not give 5 stars is because of the experience we had in the beginning with our seating. I made reservations for myself and my husband on Easter three months prior to our arrive to Myrtle beach. When we arrived and were checking in the young lady was trying to find our reservation. The manager was on the phone and took over the screen to to make a reservation for the person on the phone. At first I was like ok that’s fine. She said I had to get this family in before someone else took this spot. I get it our business has a busy scheduling system as well. The young lady found our reservation and proceeded to seat us. We were seated in the bar area. I was not over the moon about this location, especially since I saw spots open in the dining area. We ordered some drinks and a LARGE family came in. I could hear the woman saying I just called and made reservations (the party on the phone while we were checking in). They were seated right next to us. Now they were in the dining room side and we were in a tiny booth in the bar area. The adults were seated at one table and about 6 kids were seated at a table directly next to us. At this point I was not happy at all. I did not plan on a fine dining experience, out with my husband on Easter to be not only sat at the bar but essentially at the kids table. While the kids were well behaved, I felt as though it was bit an enjoyable experience hearing kids when I was out to dinner with my husband. It was distracting. Now this brings me back to thinking about my experience when we first arrived. We should have been priority over someone in the phone. My husband was able to get out seated moved. The manager never came to speak to us after this happened. It’s really a shame that we had that experience.

Service was perfect!!

Amazing service, good, & ambiance! We had a wonderful time and enjoyed a delicious meal. Our server was kind and helpful and it was an overall wonderful experience.

OUTSTANDING SERVICE!!! From beginning to end the experience was bar none! From the arrival to the departure and all in between. The atmosphere was elegant. The cuisine was divine. The dessert was swoon worthy. Joshua made us feel like royalty. Every attention to detail was given. We definitely will return on our next visit to Myrtle Beach.

Disappointed that everything on the menu sent on your ad prior to Easter was not available.

Excellent as usual. Always our favorite place and go to for a special occasion

Were seated at a table for 2 in the bar. Very small with high foot traffic. Was stated in the reservation this was a birthday diner and nothing was said about it. Not sure if we are going to go back or not.

The service was impeccable and food was phenomenal!

Seating was prompt. Waiter was attentive and gracious. First bottle of wine a little slow to arrive. The rest of the meal service was on time. Three filets and a DelMonico were cooked as requested but the DelMonico had some strings of gristle.
Overall my guests were pleased and our waiter was prompt but not pushy. We will go back but won’t order the DelMonico steak.

Although we enjoyed our nice dinner date night at New York Prime, we made a reservation for 8pm and we didn’t get seated til about 8:15. Then once we were seated we waited til about 8:45 for someone to bring us water and that’s cuz I got up and let the hostess know that no one had come to take our orders yet. A little crazy that we make a reservation for a specific time and then couldn’t even get our table til 15 minutes later then end up having to tell someone we haven’t been served yet? Yeah the service needs a LOT of work in my opinion. The food was great, though.

excellent dining, 5 star but can be noisy, kitchen open to the floor and gets crowded, if romantic date, privacy is limited

Anniversary

Been going to NY Prime for many years, somehow it seems to have lost some of its luster. Not sure if we will go back anytime soon maybe after COVID is over. We’ll have to see, just not as good as it should have been, we were disappointed.

Celebrating birthday with party of 14. Food was delicious as always and service was excellent.

New York Prime did a great job. We had a Birthday dinner and everyone went out to their way to make it a memorable occasion.

Delicious food! Great service! We enjoyed celebrating our anniversary here. We loved the ribeye, the lobster, mushrooms and cheese mashed potatoes.

I had the rib eye filet as I enjoyed marbled steak. It was moist, tender and exceptional. My husband had the filet Mignon as he enjoys a very lean steak. The single sides are large enough for two. The table sides are large enough for a group of four.

We usually visit New York Prime for special occasions. 2-3 times per year. Never had a bad meal. Service is great, the food is delicious, and the ambiance is perfect. A little on the pricey side, buy well worth it on a occasion. I would highly recommend.

They try to up sell to much! Food portions are huge. You don't need to order a whole meal.

We had a perfect drinks and dinner. Had a nice booth table up by the bar that was plenty spaced out and a plexiglass between us and next booth. Felt completely safe and comfortable with the covid situation. Highly recommend this restaurant!!! 🤩

Been here multiple times a like always it’s great and I will be back

It was definitely an amazing experience food was great and service was awesome

Five Star service from the moment we arrived. Complimentary valet was a very nice touch.

Fantastic food, amazing service, welcoming ambiance and delicious drinks.

A+ dining experience in Myrtle Beach!

Great place with great service, wonderful place for that special occasion

Waiter was perfect with knowledge and details. Steak was perfection. Being a meat man, I’ve eaten at steakhouses in Omaha, smith and wollenskys in Boston, manetta tavern, angus barn......New York prime holds its on vs anyone. Start to finish I was beyond impressed.

Best filet I have ever had.we were treated like royalty such a pleasure.

We made reservations to celebrate my birthday. Upon arriving, we were taken to a beautiful birthday decorated table. Our waiter Stephan was absolutely amazing! Food was incredible. We ordered the porterhouse for two and it was cooked to perfection! I ordered the whole Maine lobster and they actually split and shelled it for me right at the table! Wine selection is awesome. We will definitely visit again the next time we go to Myrtle Beach. ❤️❤️

Staff always first class

Food was great

Our favorite restaurant for every occasion. Friendly staff, excellent service and great food.
The Drapers