New York Prime Steakhouse - Myrtle Beach

This place is AWESOME. I would recommend to anyone anytime.

Been in the area off and on for years and managed never to eat here... man I missed it!!!
Great restaurant all around. Steaks were outstanding and cooking them Pittsburgh style is unique! Highly recommend you visit for business dinners or a special occasion but probably not the best choice to bring the grandkids on a beach vacation...
Great and attentive service, good wine selection, especially Cabernet.

We were visiting from the Bay Area and took our Mother, who lives in Myrtle Beach, there for her birthday dinner. Since we live in a area with lots of great dining options we are a bit harder on rating restaurants.

NY Prime is hands down the best dining experience we have ever had in Myrtle Beach. The quality of food as well as the service were both outstanding.

We highly recommend NY Prime if you want a great meal. Both the beef and fish that we were served were perfectly cooked.

While the prices here are on the upper end for restaurants in the Grandstand area, the quality of food and service are truly bargains.

We recommend NY Prime without reservation.

We had our 10th Anniversary at NY Prime. It was unbelievable!! The food was to die for and the service was incredible. These are not your average servers. They are consummate professionals who have perfected their craft. My husband as and I worked in the restaurant industry for many years and have never seen such harmony between waitstaff, bar, and kitchen. Neither of us could come up with a single thing we would change about our experience there! Il

Best steaks in Myrtle Beach.... We go everytime we visit the beach...

Check is the best waiter! The lobster is tender and tasty. Steaks are cooked over wood and they’re perfect.

The meal was awesome!

Service and ambiance wonderful. Both our steaks were charred so badly that all we could taste waste the burnt exterior. Inside both steaks were cooked perfectly but the burnt taste was so overwhelming that neither of us could actually taste flavor of steak. For the price, I expected something more sensational.

I've enjoyed NYP since it opened. I've never been disappointed. I promise, it's as good as a steakhouse you'll find anywhere...not just in Mytle Beach!

Great steakhouse, however I've had better steak at less cost. The rib eye was a bit sinewy for the grade of meat it was. However, with that said the steak was delicious. They keep the restaurant fairly cool so dress appropriately. I recommend to the chef that he change up the menu a bit and get rid of iceberg lettuce in their chopped Italian salad.

We ordered a porterhouse for two...sublime.
Service on point and gracious.

Wish I could have been hungrier and ate more, everything was 5 star!!!

Wow! If you are in the mood for a great steak, this is the place! So glad we found this gem! It reminds me of a fine N.Y. steak house. When we arrived, we were greeted by a friendly young man at the Valet parking. When we walked in the door, we knew we were in for a treat! The wait staff in their little jackets and ties were all eager to please. We started with a cranberry nut bread in a basket, followed by a chopped salad (anchovies on side) which was delicious. Then the main event ... a petite filet and a petite N.Y. strip ... both cooked to perfection! We ordered a side of mixed fried and onions. Not impressed with onion rings ... potatoes good though. We decided after that we really didn’t need a side. And then ... white chocolate banana cream pie! Please treat yourself to this restaurant .. you will be glad you did!

Was absolutely Amazing!! Just went there for our honeymoon dinner drove down from Cleveland Ohio and looked them up on google months before we were to be here, got there and the atmosphere was awesome old school dinning all nice and the waiters were all dressed nice and wearing pink ties for October breast cancer awareness , they all were very nice and then the food! Wow!! The cheesy potatoes were out of this world! The asparagus was huge! And the STEAK! Wow! I mean WOOOWWW!! Spot on probably best steak I have had and we go to a bunch of steak houses! Hope I get to come back sometime!
Jason&Erin M.

Fabulous as always. Going back later this week! This place never disappoints.

Best steakhouse in town, by far. Felt like I was in a New York City steakhouse.

The food was outstanding along with the service. We loved finding this restaurant and will definitely visit again the next time we are in the area. The only negative for us was that it was so loud. We had hoped for more conversation during our meal.

Whether it's an anniversary a birthday or New Year's Eve New York prime is the most exclusive steakhouse and restaurant in Myrtle Beach they serve a 28 day aged steak, Chilean Sea Bass, Lobster, Stone Crab and so much more.. Amazing wine list champagne and yes you can get the best and most expensive liquors ..VSOP only the best at New York Prime..
We go for all our Special Occasions &
New Years is great...
You really get the Best Steak...
We average around a $200-$250
4 Wines (glass)/ martinis alcohol DRINKS or a bottle of wine..
Baked Shrimp app.
12oz Filet
Sea Bass
Side - Brussels sprouts
Dessert

Its is worth every dollar...

Great place, service, and atmosphere. Sea bass was Best I Ever Had, but New York strip steak ordered medium well, had to be sent back four times to get it right. It was rare the first time. For me, that is unacceptable for $150 plus meal. I was surprised they still charged for the steak.

Food, atmosphere, service & servers were all wonderful.

We had a large party vacationing in the area. Service was excellent and food was phenomenal! Highly recommend you will not be disappointed!

The experience from beginning to end was GREAT! Good drinks, good music and Paul our table captain was a pro! We'll be back.

We love the bone in ribeye. Best steak on the beach!!
Wife loves the dirty martini with stuffed olives. Always a great dinner and place to celebrate special occasions. Highly recommended!!

Top Notch steak house. 5 star quality and service. Great atmosphere and wine selection

Another fine meal at New York Prime. In the many times we have been there, we have never been disappointed. Always a memorable experience.

Had house guests

I had very high expectations when I went to this steakhouse and I have to say that I/we were extremely disappointed with every bit of it! Shrimp cocktail was mushy, Rockefeller oysters had fake bacon bits, Brussel Sprouts were totally burnt - and although the steaks were cooked medium as we ordered them the taste was terrible as we had to see and taste an unappealing piece of meat that was burnt (crunchy black burnt) in the outside. I ordered a petit filet and my fiancé ordered a ribeye - I swear these two pieces of meat were identical in size, thickness and presentation.... BURNT!!!!

I am from Poughkeepsie, NY - Hudson Valley Area - and with being the the CIA is there we certainly have outstanding restaurants and with that you learn to develop recognition of what an outstanding meal should take and look like - which for me has no price limit.

This place has 2 stars tops for me - and as I mentioned before, I know what a great food experience looks/tastes like! Photos?!? I should’ve definitely taken pictures...

Everything was cooked perfectly and the service was on point. A great spot to celebrate our anniversary.

We had a great anniversary dinner at Prime. We frequent this restaurant because of the service and food quality.

My wife and I vacationed in myrtle beach for our anniversary. I wanted to take my wife to a nice dinner, the night of, and I chose this place off of Opentable reviews, and I am thrilled that I did! Perfect!! Fabulous service, great food, and ambiance was spot on for our date! Definitely go back for sure.

Meal was very good. Didn’t like the char on my steak almost made it seem burned. Also order dessert, coffee and tea. Dessert came we were done with dessert when waiter arrived with coffee and tea. To me that is bad service. It was getting a bit busier but the waiter had two assistants and how hard can it be to pour a cup of coffee and a pot of hot water. That’s why not five stars as well as being on the expensive side.

Wonderful New York atmosphere and very classy. Sinatra would love it here.

One of the best ribeyes I’ve ever had have eaten at Morton’s, Capital grill and the Palm. New York Prime in Myrtle Beach is simply better.
Thanks for the service on my wife’s birthday.

Our favorite steakhouse anywhere!! Jermey is the best!

Our second time there and just as we remember it! Our food was wonderful! We will be back!

We had another wonderful meal at New York Prime and fabulous service from Mike! We hope hurricane Florence will stay further North so there is no damage to this fantastic restaurant as well as our beach house!

Steaks were fantastic... Chicago style carmelized on the outside and had our filet med rare... Cooked perfectly! Waiter was vaery attentative and provided exceptional service (Steve). Side dishes and salad are large so they were split tableside. Great experience and definitely coming back.

I love a great steak, but I really live a great sea bass and Prime is top notch, always get the sea bass, the best.

The steak was delicious, service was outstanding and all was reminiscent of the excellent steak houses in New York City. Very authentic and worth the trip.

Best steak we've had in a very long time. Cooked to perfection and the sides made everything a joyous experience.