New York Prime Steakhouse - Myrtle Beach
Our new private dining room offers individual or community-style table options for up to 35 guests. Offering our full dinner menu and 4 prix fixe menus to accommodate a minimum of 25 guests. Exclusive access to the main dining room is also available for luncheons from 11:30 a.m. No room fees.View Private Dining Details
Service and food were excellent. House salad was very good
The service was truly outstanding, starting from the choice between black or white linen. For example, the server surprised us with a 5th oyster Rockefeller, even though the order only came with 4, because we were a party of 5. I had the sea bass, and it was incredible. Even though it was a steak house, I had a fantastic meal of all seafood. The rest of my party loved their steaks. I would definitely return.
They do it right ALL the time. I've been dining there since prior to Open Table and has always been a family favorite of my family for the past 15 years! Ask for Chuck.
we had a great and romantic dinner here while visiting myrtle beach. our server lee was fantastic and knowledgeable about the food and wines. we enjoyed great wine and the ambiance of the restaurant. we pretty much tried the entire menu! enjoyed oysters rockefeller, shellfish bisque, the sea bass, filet mignon, mashed cheese potatoes and the creamed spinach. everything was wonderful and portions were huge. service was very professional. we finished off the evening with a delicious banana pie and coffee. i would definitely recommend this restaurant and will be coming back!
My husband has talked about New Your Prime for years, but we were only able to go together just recently. I must say, he did not exaggerate! The atmosphere was everything that you would expect of this type of establishment, the bar cozy and friendly, the martini wonderful. I must mention that the staff were amazing each and every one, from the bartenders to the servers. My husband and I ordered the chopped salad to share, followed by the filet, with spinach and onion rings. The salad was fine, the filet very good. Now here I must interject that my husband is a Grill Meister, and it is extremely difficult to find a steak that is as good as what he can make at home: New York Prime came the closest of any restaurant to date. The batter for the onion rings was not especially to my liking, rather hard and bread-like, but they were very well cooked and tasty. The wine list has something for everyone's palate and budget. We had so much fun that we ended up closing the place down. Definitely one of the BEST places to eat in a town of unexciting fast food chains and seafood buffets. We will be back!
They do not have many sides to choose from so basically all you are eating is a chunk of steak as your entire meal. For your steak they do not offer ANY steak enhancements or toppings. Not even aju, the most standard steak enhancement known to mankind!!! You literally just eat a chunk of dry steak. Aside from that it is extremely expensive for what you are getting. $62 for a steak is fine when being able to get enhancements or toppings and getting to pair it with great sides, but when the steak is all they offer, it is not work $200 for 2 people.
Stratospherically priced steak houses need to be great. New York Prime in Myrtle Beach is not. Food was OK. Service was OK. The room needs some serious attention. Dark, but not in a good way. And it has just been beaten up over the years. Needs a complete refresh. And the bathrooms. Oy. This was a return visit after many years based upon solid recollections. Time has not been friendly to NYP.
Lee was an awesome server and the food was great. A little expensive overall (200$ for meal for 2 with drinks and dessert) but the quality of the food was on par. Will revisit on future trips.
It was our 51st anniversary and since I had never eaten at New York Prime, I thought I would give it a try. I am certainly glad that I did.
I gave them a heads up on the event and they sprinkled the table with little red and silver hearts, and had a nice card for us. Nice touch.
The drinks were very good and reasonable.
Although pricey, the food was outstanding. My wife had a petite filet, medium rare and it was cooked to perfection. I had the sea bass and I can say unequivocally, it was he best piece off fish I have ever had anywhere. I soon as I bit into the first piece of fish, the price didn't matter. That's how good it was. I was we had room for their desserts but we were stuff. I would definitely recommend their onion rings. Unbelievable! I ordered a baked potato that could have fed a large family.
We have no complaints. Im looking forward to our next visit.
The quality of food, service and atmosphere is unmatched in Myrtle Beach. NY Prime is always a stop for my husband and I when we are in town!
Best steak ever. We make sure we go here whenever we are in town. Great food! Great service!
Excellent food and server was very attentive!
Bobby the server was amazing...food matched.
Yet again we had a wonderful evening at New York Prime! The food and service was outstanding and we look so forward to dining there again soon!
Excellent in every way. Love that place.
Dinner was average. Service was excellent.
Chris was an excellent waiter excellent food and service
Overall we enjoyed our visit, but my boyfriend wasn't a fan of his steak. While we both knew that the steaks were prepared "Pittsburgh" style, he found that his NY Strip tasted mostly charred and found it hard to taste any of the actual flavor of the meat. We both agreed that my petite filet was much more flavorful. We shared the cheesy mashed potatoes. The service was excellent. I probably won't go back because of the price though. While it was very good, I'm not sure I could justify the prices of any of the items on the menu.
Living in Myrtle Beach 2 years the best steak dinner coupled with excellent service
Great food and service. Always good, always consistent
From pulling into the parking lot the valet was friendly and happy to see us.
We were seated promptly and greeted by Eric our waiter for the evening.
Eric was fantastic.
Drinks and appetizers were ordered( oyster Rockefeller , baked shrimp and thick cut bacon.
It was amazing.
Dinners included barrel cut filet, sea bass and a Delmonico steak.
All were cooked to perfection.
Sides were great
Dessert was 2 pieces of banana cream pie- big enough for all 4 of us.
Dinner was such a great experience, we are retuning next week again!
We only wish we lived closer!
Wonderful dinner with family while in the area for vacation! Jeremy P was an outstanding waiter who answered our questions and gave us wonderful recommendations. Worth every penny! We will definitely be back.
Ridiculously overpriced. Been to many restaurants with superior food for a fraction of the cost. I won't be dining here again.
Always excellent service and outstanding food. New York Prime never disappoints.
Food was great as was our waiter Stephan. Perfect anniversary night
Mike was great .he was patient and informative. Food wss cooked to perfection and delicious
Three of us went to celebrate all three of our birthdays. Our table had one birthday card on it. New York Prime is a very expensive restaurant which we knew before we went. Very disappointing in that they offered no complimentary appetizer, bottle of wine, dessert or anything else to celebrate our birthdays. Expected more from a restaurant of their class.
Thank you for a great experience at NY Prime for our anniversary. The complimentary vallet was a nice addition. The food tasted really good.
We are from Columbia SC and have a place at Hilton Grand Vacations in Myrtle Beach. Whenever we visit, we always eat once at NY Prime. Absolutely the best steaks we have ever had. Never disappointed. A little pricey, but well worth it. Can wait til next time.
Our group has been eating at NY Prime for around 15 years and it remains at the top of our list for nice restaurants in Myrtle Beach. The food both steaks and seafood is as good as I’ve found at any of the nicest steakhouses in the country. The service is always fabulous and waiters experienced and highly knowledgeable of everything on the menu. Paul, was our waiter and he was outstanding. We dined on June 19.
This was my second visit to NY Prime. I may go back another time but not on a special day. This was father's day and we found it too noisy and cramped. The food was good but not great as it was the first visit (Easter Sunday).
Pricey, but best steak ever!!
Sides are a little lack luster
Apple pie was amazing
Hands down, best restaurant in Myrtle Beach. Far better than other chain high-end steakhouses
Celebrated our anniversary here. Good food, service was phenomenal. They made our table extra special because they knew it was our anniversary. Open concept dining room with tables close together would make it difficult to have a private conversation.
The steaks and sides were excellent - some of the best I’ve ever had. Ambience was a little weird... the service aims to be high class (and the prices support this). My husband had to send back his Sazerac (the bartenders decided that an absinthe rinse was more of an absinthe pour and I could smell the anise from across the table) and had to remind the waiter to bring the glass of wine he’d requested with his main course. Otherwise, the service was fine. I couldn’t help but feel we’d gone back in time a bit as there was not a single female server (nor did I notice any servers of color), just white men. I can’t remember the last time I was in a restaurant with such little diversity among the staff.
As for atmosphere, it was odd to be seated in a “fancy” steak house near a bar with two televisions, surrounded by other diners who ranged from resort casual (which seems appropriate given the setting) to, quite frankly, a little slovenly (shorts and baseball caps). I was also disappointed that cigar smoking was allowed inside, albeit limited to the bar. I wouldn’t have enjoyed that under normal circumstances, but as a pregnant woman, I’m particularly sensitive to that odor.
Excellent food and service..... Highly recommend for business or personal with family and friends
You never can go wrong with the steaks here. They are tremendous! We go here every year when we're here and the only disappointment was the bread - it just seemed a little dry or stale, although who cares when you're eating prime steak!
We went for our 5 year anniversary and they had decorated the table with heart confetti, candle and bottle of wine. The wait staff was great and the food was amazing!
As usual, our meal was great! Lee E did a great job taking care of our group of 7. Food was excellent. Loved the baked shrimp appetizer. Also, the banana cream pie remains one of my all time favorite desserts. Food and service here never disappoint!