New York Prime Steakhouse - Myrtle Beach

We had a great anniversary dinner at Prime. We frequent this restaurant because of the service and food quality.

My wife and I vacationed in myrtle beach for our anniversary. I wanted to take my wife to a nice dinner, the night of, and I chose this place off of Opentable reviews, and I am thrilled that I did! Perfect!! Fabulous service, great food, and ambiance was spot on for our date! Definitely go back for sure.

Meal was very good. Didn’t like the char on my steak almost made it seem burned. Also order dessert, coffee and tea. Dessert came we were done with dessert when waiter arrived with coffee and tea. To me that is bad service. It was getting a bit busier but the waiter had two assistants and how hard can it be to pour a cup of coffee and a pot of hot water. That’s why not five stars as well as being on the expensive side.

Wonderful New York atmosphere and very classy. Sinatra would love it here.

One of the best ribeyes I’ve ever had have eaten at Morton’s, Capital grill and the Palm. New York Prime in Myrtle Beach is simply better.
Thanks for the service on my wife’s birthday.

Our favorite steakhouse anywhere!! Jermey is the best!

Our second time there and just as we remember it! Our food was wonderful! We will be back!

We had another wonderful meal at New York Prime and fabulous service from Mike! We hope hurricane Florence will stay further North so there is no damage to this fantastic restaurant as well as our beach house!

Steaks were fantastic... Chicago style carmelized on the outside and had our filet med rare... Cooked perfectly! Waiter was vaery attentative and provided exceptional service (Steve). Side dishes and salad are large so they were split tableside. Great experience and definitely coming back.

I love a great steak, but I really live a great sea bass and Prime is top notch, always get the sea bass, the best.

The steak was delicious, service was outstanding and all was reminiscent of the excellent steak houses in New York City. Very authentic and worth the trip.

Best steak we've had in a very long time. Cooked to perfection and the sides made everything a joyous experience.

Ordered medium rare delmonico and brought to me well done. I was asked to cut it right down the middle and it was well done. Was told I was definitely right and they would get me one that was right. Everyone was finishing up when I got my replacement steak. It was tough to cut and with many tendons thru it, but it was medium rare. Ate part of it and took the rest of home for the dogs. It definitely was not a “Prime” steak. When My husband cut it up for the dogs the next day , he agreed it was very hard to cut.
Wedge salad with crab and shrimp was fabulous. Creamed spinach was disappointing. Cheese mashed potatoes were very good .

We have been to this place twice now and each time the food and service is second to none. The steaks are perfectly cooked and the char on the outside make them taste like no other steak. The side come in single of family sizes and taste as good as the steaks. I would recommend this place to anyone for a dinner date of other special event.

Been eating here for at least 20 years. Great meal and service as usual, never disappointed, best steak ever!

Delicious from start to finish. not kid friendly but a wonderful dinner experience.

I live in Horry county and enjoy restaurants in and out of Myrtle Beach. When I am willing to pay the exorbitant taxes charged in Myrtle Beach (11% +) New York Prime is where I go. The service is always good if not excellent. The beef and sides are always good if not excellent. I can count on them to have good wine and cocktails. Valet parking in 90+ weather is also nice.
Enjoy!

Missed our reservation by 39 minutes, the first woman we spoke to was very rude and acted like we disrupted there entire night, even though there were only a few groups in there. She rolled her eyes, and gave us attitude until who I assume was the manager came over and told her what table to put us at. She then seats us, attitude the whole way, and just walks away... the server was fantastic! He and his help made sure we were fat and happy! It was very cold in the room they sat us. Bring a sweater as it always seems to be this way. The steak is charred on the outside which doesn’t really taste all that well, but the inner layers were great. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND the shrimp appetizer, yumm. Probably won’t be back as the price we paid in the long run was not worth it. Ruth’s Chris is right down the road, less expensive, and better quality food as well as atmosphere.

Everything was first class. It was everything they said it would be. My meal was delicious, cooked just the way I like it.

Anniversary was well recognized. Thanks

Great food and superb service. Steaks can't be beat.

Very good for a non big city steakhouse.

Food was very good as well as 5he service but pricey

Great place to eat. Hands down the best in Myrtle Beach.

NYP is top 5 steak places I have ever been to. I I have been to a lot WW. GREAT STAFF.

First class service, First class food, every time.

Try the Sea Bass, good chance it will be the best you've ever enjoyed. Staff was fantastic. Tip of ghe hat to the chef, everything ordered was prepared perfectly. We had nothing from the bar, nor desserts, our check for 3 adults was 195 plus tip. Worth every penny. Be our first and last meal next time we come to MB.

Best place in myrtle no one even comes close .. .. have been going for years and all year round

Customer service was impeccable. Ambience and background music was great. Only one compliant the steak was so salty and drenched in butter.

Delicious sea bass and steak! wonderful service! Our waiter was amazing and very personable and accommodating! We will definitely be back again!!

The BEST PRIME STEAKHOUSE IN THE COUNTRY!!!!! It is worth every penny

Always fantastic food and the service is really good. We were celebrating a friends birthday and they did a fantastic job. It is expensive but worth it.

Wonderful dinner! We both had the 8 oz filet - cooked to perfection! Enjoyed our asparagus and onion rings also. Did not order anything else since we were on vacation and didn’t want to have leftovers!

Very expensive and no options for children other than an over priced steak. I have a picky special needs child and they had no chicken or “kid” options.. gotta get with the times..

When we first arrived the service was awesome got even better when we sat down for dinner .Our waiter was very knowledgeable and courteous , covered the specials and answered all of our questions without missing a beat !! Food was awesome and we were more than taken care of by the staff . We will DEFINITELY go back on our next trip to Myrtle Beach !

Food was not good.
$184 spent for a steak that was tasteless and underwhelming. I would not recommend to anyone.

Fantastic food and superb service -- we will returning !!

My husband and I ate here for our anniversary. I was pleasantly surprised when after we sat down we were given an anniversary card and cute hearts were sprinkled in the middle of our table, very sweet touch. The food was amazing! The petite filet was cooked perfectly and was very tender and tasty. The 5 pieces of asparagus was pretty stingy especially because everything is a la carte and pricey. The cheesy mashed potatoes went well with the filet. For a special occasion we’d dine here again when we come back into town. I wish the menu had more to offer.

Dined here for the second time on a busy summer Saturday evening. The service was impeccable and prompt. Our waiter was both professional and personable. But the food was the main attraction. We had the filet and rib eye...the char was perfect and added such great flavor to the meat. Chopped salad was crisp and fresh...everything was just perfect! Highly recommend!

Service and food were outstanding! We look forward to going here every time we are in Myrtle Beach! Excellent!!