We went to dinner Friday night. Our server was very nice and friendly, atmosphere was okay. Our table was extremely wobbly due to the floor which was annoying. Food was okay at best - limited options and very expensive. For appetizers we had the fried calamari and fresh mozzarella- they were okay. For dinner we had the short rib ravioli which was tasty, and the chicken Marsala which was poor. The Marsala came with a greasy bland sauce , mashed potatoes and seasonal veggies- which included a mix of green beans, broccoli, cabbage and carrots .. it did not really go. For $100, I expect to walk away thinking "wow!" Not mediocre.
We ate there 2 times in one week and Amanda was our waitress on a Thurs and she was beyond excellent!! We brought 4 of our friends there on Fri and they loved it and our waitress, whom I forgot her name was excellent also, she was in bar area at our table of 6
Always great food and service!
Simple review, OUTSTANDING, food was awesome as usual
Amazing as always
I had a great time there.....it was a first date!
The New Mill’s Paglia e Fieno is the best dinner in the whole world! The pasta is homemade and has just the right al dente bite to it. The veal meatballs and beet salad are favorites, as well, and their filet rivals any steakhouse in CT, NY, or FL. Wines are available at various price points, offering a great experience to every diner.
Food was awesome service was awesome ambience was terrific
It was our first time there. Our waitress was delightful. The food was great. Will definitely be back. Wish you were open for lunch.
Nice restaurant for large tables. Be prepared to take food home with you. Always busy. Nice bar area, great casual dining. They can handle small or large parties.
I love this restsurant, but the food, service and noise levels were not acceptable. Will try it once more, and then decide if we will return again.
The service was super friendly and accommodating. Our Party of 10 was not easy!
The place to go if you want a good steak. Been there about 20 times and I’ve never had a steak that was not great.
Over the past couple of years, I have gone here about 5 times. Always great food and variety for all palates.
Have been here many times and keep going back. Excellent food and service
The pork chop was excellent. A little salty though. My wife said the salmon was very good. We will go back again soon. Nice atmosphere. Great service.
We always get a good meal here and great service. Try getting a table near the fire place during the winter.
Great food and service
We have tried numerous appetizers and entrees at the New Mill and all have been absolutely top shelf . The filet mignon is incredible , it was cooked perfectly rare as requested and so tender we could have cut it with a butter knife ! Service is fantastic, , nicely timed so we were not rushed , even on Valentine's Day and enjoyed a nice leisurely dinner. Wonderful restaurant !!
Really great Steak! Great Fish. Beautiful bar area!
Bar drinks were awful.
Weird music for this type of restaurant.
Could have been sat in a nicer part of restaurant.
Some tables had linens???
Birthday for my husband
Food was great. Atmosphere was great. The waitress was fabulous. Will definitely go back.
Great atmosphere. Attentive service but never felt rushed. The pork chops and lobster crusted cod were delicious. We had a great table downstairs by the fire. It was a little loud , making it difficult to hear across the table with a big party. But overall would highly recommend
This was our first experience at this restaurant and was very happy from start to finish. Loved the rustic ambiance with all the beautiful decorations. Our server was excellent... Very polite and knowledgeable. We didn't feel rushed at all. A great, great night! We will definitely be back!
I've had dinner at the New Mill on multiple occasions and they are always on point. Great atmosphere, amazing food and quality service. One of my favorite places for dinner.
Birthday it was. A great experience
Great restaurant we don’t go often enough. Food is great. Service great and just all around good experience
We had a great time. The food was outstanding. We were there for a birthday dinner. Would recommend to my friends and family, we will return. I have already mentioned to my colleagues and we plan to have a company dinner there in near future.
Our first time at New Mill, we loved it. It was my husband's birthday. Each year we try to take each other for our birthdays to a place neither of us have been to, and this year I chose New Mill for his birthday. It was fantastic. It was still decorated for Christmas so all of the white lights made it look so pretty. We were informed they're coming down this week so it will be interesting to see what it looks like without all of the Christmas lights. Food was great, lots of great dishes from which to choose. Service was great. We are definitely going to go back!
Food was good for southington. A bit pricey for what was offered. Wait staff was ok. I didn't need someone to pout olive oil on a plate for me. Waitress forgot out bread and i had to ask for it. I had heard rave reviews so i was a bit disappointed
Our apps and cocktails were delicious. My wife’s dinner, not so much.
My wife ordered the chicken Marsala and was disappointed. Our server said our dinners were ready and she was going to get them. Twenty minutes later our dinners arrived. My guess is the dish had been sitting in there for a bit and the chicken had dried out, the mashed ootatoes were watery and flavorless and the veggies had been sitting in the marsala sauce so long they were mushy and unrecognizeable. She took three bites of the chicken and called it a day.
Chances are we would visit again, but most likely just sit at the bar, have a few cocktails and apps.
Another fabulous time at New Mill Restaurant! Our table was ready when we arrived and all 4 of us had a great time with great food, service, and the holiday decorations were beautiful! I can’t wait to come back!
Excellent service and food. Mike, our waiter in the bar area, was attentive but not hovering.
Great service! Excellent food!
Apps were great, entree and service were only fair.
We enjoyed our dinner .We had to ask for a different table at first was sat at the worst table in place but once we moved it was great
Just my favorite place to go out for an excellent meal with excellent service.
We have never been disappointed with The New Mill. The food is always good and very filling.
We enjoy the restaurant very much. The chef is great. Meals are just great