Lobster Shepherds Pie*
6 oz. Canadian tail sautéed with wild mushrooms, fresh spinach and a splash of chardonnay over garlic smashed potatoes
Crab Cake Lovers
Maryland Jumbo Lump crabcakes with our blend of seasonings and a side of our caper remoulade. VOTED "BEST CRABCAKES 2014" BY DELAWARE TODAY MAGAZINE
Shrimp and Scallops over Pasta*
Jumbo Shrimp and Scallops sautéed with grape tomatoes, fresh spinach, basil pesto garlic and white wine then topped with grated parmesan
Our server Chris was excellent. He was friendly, polite, and attentive. Both the rack of lamb and the New York strip were cooked perfectly as ordered. The cost of dinner with drinks and dessert was reasonable. We would definitely return to Nantucket.
We celebrated a friends BD and enjoyed the whole evening. Everything was perfect!
We had dinner for six people to celebrate my Mother's 95th Birthday. We had 5:00 PM reservations so were able to get Happy Hour prices on drinks, soups, salads, and some appetizers. We all agreed that our dinners were delicious. The service was outstanding. The restaurant is a bit pricey (but so are other good restaurants in the area); I would definitely recommend Nantuckets for special night out.
Food was absolutely delicious and our service was top notch.
Good food at a reasonable price. Dining room was very noisy and the waitress had too many tables.
Overall great food and ambiance. Would be 5 stars but clams were sandy and manhattans not the best.
We are on a mini vacation and Nantucket’s was recommended by a friend. We were not disappointed. Our waiter was excellent(forgot his name) and his recommendations were spot on. The food was excellent. We had a leisurely dinner with little to no wait considering how things are these days!! I would highly recommend Nantucket’s!!!
Prompt service, wide menu, friendly staff and great atmosphere.
Great seafood and the service was impeccable!
Waiter was excellent, food great and came quickly.
Excellent food great service restaurant for exceeds which you would expect at a resort like Ocean City or Fenwick Island my wife and I thoroughly enjoy the experience and did not find it to be overpriced but was reasonable considering the entire environment
I have been to Nantucket restaurant many times in past 25 years. Always a pleasure
Nantucket's always delivers a wonderful experience. We were treated exceptionally from start to finish. The pork dish was delicious and presented beautifully. The filet done perfect. Can't wait to eat again soon.
Great service. Chris was fantastic as our server. He was very attentive and personable! We enjoyed it so much, I just made reservations for this Wednesday night again!
Was highly recommended by two friends and I would do the same.
Great food and service.
A little pricey but worth it.
We had such a good time and food the first time we went back three days later. Service was excellent and helpful suggestions and just the right amount of come back. Took advantage of the happy hours specials and enjoyed delicious food at a discount. Highly recommend to anyone coming to Fenwick Island, Be sure to check hours and opening.
Loved our dinner at Nantucket's. Food and service were fabulous. Can't wait to return!
Scallops, Salad, and Cod were wonderderful. Cocktails were excellent. Grits under shrimp and grits were boring and wild rice was flavored like Rice-a-roni. Service was excellent considering the staffing shortage at the beach.
Outstanding dining experience. I would recommend Nantuckets Restaurant and will return next trip to the beach.
Nantuckets is consistently exceptional. My husband is very finicky about Caesar salad, and said theirs was one of the best he’s had. My Mom’s steak was cooked perfectly. DH and I both had fish and it was perfect. Professional service, no sign of the troubles so many restaurants are showing these days (if they have them, they’re managing them well) and we very much appreciate being able to make a reservation when so few places still do that in the resort area.
Great food and service. Will be back soon!!
Met friends for happy hour on the bar side. Always a favorite place to go - great food, interesting menu, fabulous decor, and great service!
great place for special occasions. we had a great dinner
I could not rate this restaurant any higher. Food was excellent, the ambience was lovely, and our waitress Kate was phenomenal!!!
This is consistently one of our favorite restaurants. Always delicious food/drinks, lovely ambiance, and excellent service. 5/5 recommend!
It's our place to go for almost 30 years!
Thank you Susie, Delany, and I don't know the names of!
A great place to celebrate our wedding we will definitely be back
Excellent as always all around!
Good food, reasonable service under the circumstances that there are few people working.
Great service and good food. The atmosphere is lovely if you’re looking for a romantic dinner place. Loved it.
While our meal was fine and up to Nantucket's standard our seating was not as requested. We booked through their website which connected us to Open Table. Open Table offered us the option of regular seating or high top. We indicated we wanted regular seating but on arrival we were told we were getting a high top. When we complained about this the staff did look to see if they could find any alternative in the dining room. Unfortunately they did not.
We were told the problem was caused by using Open Table. We have not had this problem before and since it was on their website as the option we see it as their problem as well. My wife is a little over 5 feet tall barely reaching the foot rest never mind the floor a more than $100 meal loses something in a noisy bar room. While the food was good as always we will think twice about booking this way again.
Upon arrival (party of 6 adults), we were told that because we reserved a "standard" table via Open Table, the restaurant could NOT guarantee a table for us in the dining room. Instead, they offered us stools in the bar area. We argued with the owner (who was incredibly nasty and condescending), that on the user-end, if we choose a "standard" table via Open Table, that's what we reserved and we should be given that table (or it shouldn't even be an option on Open Table). After a heated discussion, where she continued to blame us for her issue with Open Table, she finally found us a table in the dining room. The food was good, but the attitude was nasty. We are from NYC, and this place has no reason to be condescending. They'd last 30 seconds in a real restaurant scene. Never again.
The food was creative & excellent and the service was outstanding.
Very comfortable experience. Good good. Excellent wine and cocktail list. Excellent dessert.
Fun venue, high top table in friendly bar area. Food was very good. Overall very good. We would go back.
Was told upon arrival that we were going to be seated in Pub room. Not what we made reservation for and did not want to sit at high top table in busy bar area. Moved to dining room table right by the door. It wasn't terrible but lousy table comparatively. Service was fine but our server was working a different room and we were only table in dining room for her. She did fine but it just seemed like we were an afterthought. It had been years since we had been here. It was okay but not nearly as impressed as previous visit. Food was very good but overall experience lacking.
We got a high top table in the Pub and enjoyed happy hour specials. One of favorite places to go in the Fenwick area!! Crab dip, Ahi Tuna, Steak salads all very enjoyable.
Nantuckets Restaurant offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (302) 539-2607.
Nantuckets Restaurant is rated 4.7 stars by 2033 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.