City Island Restaurants

Make a free reservation

View all 31157 restaurants in New York Area

Best American Restaurants in City Island

Annarella RistoranteAnnarella Ristorante
(88)
$$$$
American | Saugerties, Westchester / Hudson Valley
VeloVelo
(345)
$$$$
American | Nyack, Westchester / Hudson Valley
The Station Kitchen and BarThe Station Kitchen and Bar
(160)
$$$$
American | Congers, Westchester / Hudson Valley
The Inn at Pound Ridge by Jean-GeorgesThe Inn at Pound Ridge by Jean-Georges
(2852)
$$$$
American | Pound Ridge, Westchester / Hudson Valley
Meritage - ScarsdaleMeritage - Scarsdale
(203)
$$$$
American | Scarsdale, Westchester / Hudson Valley
Sammy's Downtown BistroSammy's Downtown Bistro
(294)
$$$$
American | Bronxville, Westchester / Hudson Valley
Emma's Ale HouseEmma's Ale House
(907)
$$$$
American | White Plains, Westchester / Hudson Valley
HP Special Events at The Culinary Institute of America - Hyde ParkHP Special Events at The Culinary Institute of America - Hyde Park
(125)
$$$$
American | Hyde Park, Westchester / Hudson Valley
Rory Dolan'sRory Dolan's
(61)
$$$$
American | Yonkers, Westchester / Hudson Valley
Boitson's RestaurantBoitson's Restaurant
(392)
$$$$
American | Kingston, Westchester / Hudson Valley
Traditions 118Traditions 118
(182)
$$$$
American | Putnam Valley, Westchester / Hudson Valley
Clock Tower GrillClock Tower Grill
(552)
$$$$
American | Brewster, Westchester / Hudson Valley
Restaurant X & Bully Boy BarRestaurant X & Bully Boy Bar
(2477)
$$$$
American | Congers, Westchester / Hudson Valley
Char Steakhouse - Putnam ValleyChar Steakhouse - Putnam Valley
(478)
$$$$
American | Putnam Valley, Westchester / Hudson Valley
Chat 19Chat 19
(389)
$$$$
American | Larchmont, Westchester / Hudson Valley

Best Italian Restaurants in City Island

Il CastelloIl Castello
(660)
$$$$
Italian | Mamaroneck, Westchester / Hudson Valley
Sergio's RistoranteSergio's Ristorante
(209)
$$$$
Italian | Pelham, Westchester / Hudson Valley
25 North25 North
(561)
$$$$
Italian | Mamaroneck, Westchester / Hudson Valley
Moscato - ScarsdaleMoscato - Scarsdale
(429)
$$$$
Italian | Scarsdale, Westchester / Hudson Valley
Sapori Italian Restaurant - White PlainsSapori Italian Restaurant - White Plains
(731)
$$$$
Italian | White Plains, Westchester / Hudson Valley
Il FrescoIl Fresco
(882)
$$$$
Italian | Orangeburg, Westchester / Hudson Valley
Rosie's Bistro ItalianoRosie's Bistro Italiano
(357)
$$$$
Italian | Bronxville, Westchester / Hudson Valley
Alba's RestauranteAlba's Restaurante
(654)
$$$$
Italian | Port Chester, Westchester / Hudson Valley
Lusardi's LarchmontLusardi's Larchmont
(621)
$$$$
Italian | Larchmont, Westchester / Hudson Valley
Mulino'sMulino's
(783)
$$$$
Italian | White Plains, Westchester / Hudson Valley
L'inizioL'inizio
(622)
$$$$
Italian | Ardsley, Westchester / Hudson Valley
Mima VinotecaMima Vinoteca
(199)
$$$$
Italian | Irvington, Westchester / Hudson Valley
Lago Ristorante and Wine BarLago Ristorante and Wine Bar
(172)
$$$$
Italian | West Harrison, Westchester / Hudson Valley
TrediciTredici
(388)
$$$$
Italian | Purchase, Westchester / Hudson Valley

Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area

HAVEN Riverfront Restaurant and Bar
(228)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Edgewater
Smoke Jazz and Supper Club
(240)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Upper West Side
Serafina 105
(141)
$$$$
Italian | Upper West Side
View all New York Area restaurants
City Island Locals Are Talking About
What are some fun things to do in City Island?
Jet ski boating fishing
S
Shea - New York Area
What are some of your favorite spots nearby?
City Island in general, they really need to work on properly booking customers. Also if the restaurants are full to the capacity, work on other arrangements to be compatible to the crowd.
OT
OpenTable Diner - New York Area
What do you love most about City Island?
The food, and I will always drive from New Jersey to Sammy's
SP
SachaniaP - Miami

Treat your taste buds: Explore City Island restaurants.

City Island Restaurants

Sammy's Shrimp BoxSammy's Shrimp Box
74 reviews
$$$$
Seafood | City Island, Westchester / Hudson Valley

LOVE THE AMOUNT OF SEAFOOD SERVED AND THE QUALITY IS AMAZING! Staff is attentive, friendly and thoughtful. More

OpenTable Diner -
VISTAMARVISTAMAR
9 reviews
$$$$
Latin American | City Island, Westchester / Hudson Valley

The food was amazing and definitely worth while. I have to say that I was impressed with the hospitality received from all staff. They were patient and not like many other restaurants in the area that rush you out. I will definitely be returning in the near future. 👌 More

OpenTable Diner -
Sammy's Fish BoxSammy's Fish Box
508 reviews
$$$$
Seafood | City Island, Westchester / Hudson Valley

Outstanding Food and Service. Traveled two hours from Philly. Well Worth the Trip More

OpenTable Diner -
Sangria CafeSangria Cafe
19 reviews
$$$$
Latin / Spanish | City Island, Westchester / Hudson Valley

Great Experience, great server, nice good looking manger, only complaint would be the service of food leaving the kitchen. Some items on plate were very warn and ready to eats. While other things on the plate came out cold(which could be that they waiting for all of the table foods to come out at the same time.) temperature on food service must be work on but a great place More

OpenTable Diner -
CASA RESTAURANT & LOUNGECASA RESTAURANT & LOUNGE
3 reviews
$$$$
Latin American | City Island, Westchester / Hudson Valley

Always a great experience More

OpenTable Diner -
Escape LatinoEscape Latino
Reviews Coming Soon
$$$$
Latin / Spanish | City Island, Westchester / Hudson Valley

Fine Latin cuisine. Cozy environment. Ladies night Wednesday's 7-9pm. Live orchestra quartet Thursday's after work. Live DJ 10pm Thursday, Friday, Saturday. Weekend brunch 11am - 4pm unlimited Sangria and Mimosa deals.More