Best Steakhouse Restaurants in City Island

Lovely place with making food and excellent service.

I had Chicken Scarpiello and my fellow diner had Short Ribs. The complementary Grappa was delicious. The steak looked phenomenal. I asked the people who ordered it how it was and they said "great". This would be a complete 5 Star experience except for the brown whisky selection which has a few...See More

Luis A. And the team made our dining experience exceptional. Luis’ service, personality, attention, and dessert recommendations were on point! You cannot go wrong with any of the choices on the menu. Service can make or break an experience and Luis did not disappoint in any way. The staff even...See More

One of the better experiences I've had in a Steakhouse. The owner Pete and his team did a fantastic job in providing the kind of service you would want other restaurants to emulate. Every dish we ordered like the appetizers Grilled octopus, raw oysters, fried calamari, the entrée such as Ribeye,...See More

Food and service as always very much up to high standards

Simply the best!

Service good. Food ok… porter house for 2 def priced more than most steakhouses. Doesn’t come out sizzling. Not worth $150,,,,

Our server, Lorenzo, was caring and knowledgeable. The food amazing. We have become Lenny fans at two of the three venues. We have not been to the third which sadly was damaged during the recent storm. Lenny dropped by our table which felt gracious. The food. Oh the food. Romaine lettuce dressed...See More

I hadn’t been to Christo’s for many years and was very favorably impressed. Their steaks, appetizers and accompaniments rivaled any of the steakhouses in Manhattan.

Another one of our visit’s to Morton’s Steakhouse pleased the entire table. The steaks were cooked to perfection and were flavorful. The sides and desserts were similarly delicious. In addition, the service was excellent - prompt and attentive without rushing or delaying. I look forward to my next...See More