Best American Restaurants in Old Lyme

Old Lyme InnOld Lyme Inn
(295)
$$$$
American | Old Lyme, Connecticut
Winvian FarmWinvian Farm
(97)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Morris, Connecticut
The Schoolhouse at CannondaleThe Schoolhouse at Cannondale
(1436)
$$$$
American | Wilton, Connecticut
Oyster ClubOyster Club
(1875)
$$$$
American | Mystic, Connecticut
Millwright'sMillwright's
(1419)
$$$$
American | Simsbury, Connecticut
Present CompanyPresent Company
(525)
$$$$
American | Simsbury, Connecticut
Bailey's BackyardBailey's Backyard
(382)
$$$$
American | Ridgefield, Connecticut
Café RoutierCafé Routier
(1509)
$$$$
American | Westbrook, Connecticut
Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Stamford CTPrime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Stamford CT
(409)
$$$$
American | Stamford, Connecticut
South EndSouth End
(509)
$$$$
American | New Canaan, Connecticut
Grant's Restaurant and BarGrant's Restaurant and Bar
(1521)
$$$$
American | Hartford / West Hartford, Connecticut
Division WestDivision West
(228)
$$$$
American | Hartford / West Hartford, Connecticut
Artisan - West HartfordArtisan - West Hartford
(258)
$$$$
American | Hartford / West Hartford, Connecticut
Washington PrimeWashington Prime
(341)
$$$$
American | South Norwalk, Connecticut
Stonebridge RestaurantStonebridge Restaurant
(590)
$$$$
American | Milford, Connecticut
Bar Americain at Mohegan SunBar Americain at Mohegan Sun
(2241)
$$$$
American | Uncasville, Connecticut

Best Italian Restaurants in Old Lyme

AssaggioAssaggio
(76)
$$$$
Italian | Branford, Connecticut
Tarantino RestaurantTarantino Restaurant
(179)
$$$$
Italian | Westport, Connecticut
Bricco Restaurant - West HartfordBricco Restaurant - West Hartford
(395)
$$$$
Italian | Hartford / West Hartford, Connecticut
Osteria RomanaOsteria Romana
(101)
$$$$
Italian | Westport, Connecticut
TerraSole RistoranteTerraSole Ristorante
(714)
$$$$
Italian | Ridgefield, Connecticut
ApplausiApplausi
(234)
$$$$
Italian | Old Greenwich, Connecticut
Quattro PazziQuattro Pazzi
(333)
$$$$
Italian | Stamford, Connecticut
Valbella ConnecticutValbella Connecticut
(513)
$$$$
Italian | Riverside, Connecticut
Il PalioIl Palio
(889)
$$$$
Italian | Shelton, Connecticut
Carbone's RistoranteCarbone's Ristorante
(619)
$$$$
Italian | Hartford / West Hartford, Connecticut
Ballo Italian RestaurantBallo Italian Restaurant
(3493)
$$$$
Italian | Uncasville, Connecticut
Columbus Park TrattoriaColumbus Park Trattoria
(100)
$$$$
Italian | Stamford, Connecticut
Rustica Ristorante - ChesterRustica Ristorante - Chester
(639)
$$$$
Italian | Chester, Connecticut, Connecticut
Osteria RomanaOsteria Romana
(168)
$$$$
Italian | Monroe, Connecticut, Connecticut
Bricco TrattoriaBricco Trattoria
(1480)
$$$$
Italian | Glastonbury, Connecticut

Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area

HAVEN Riverfront Restaurant and Bar
(376)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Edgewater
Serafina 105
(111)
$$$$
Italian | Upper West Side
Smoke Jazz and Supper Club
(287)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Upper West Side
View all New York Area restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Old Lyme restaurants.

Old Lyme Restaurants

Bee and Thistle InnBee and Thistle Inn
253 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Old Lyme, Connecticut

Outstanding service, perhaps best I've ever had - responsive yet not intrusive. Food was excellent, although a little bland. The addition of the fresh ground pepper to the lobster bisque made a world of difference. VERY friendly place, almost like you have stopped in on old friends. More

OpenTable Diner -
Old Lyme InnOld Lyme Inn
295 reviews
$$$$
American | Old Lyme, Connecticut

I stopped by The Old Lyme Inn on Friday, my birthday to see a Jazz Show at the Side Door Jazz Club which is part of the residence. This has been my go to place since I was a kid growing up on the CT Shoreline and I love the Jazz at the club, but I digress, this is a food review. I wanted a quick dinner before going into the club and opted for the Duck Confit Flat Bread which was an awesome small plate. The confit was very savory and it was dressed to perfection. I have to say the you'd be hard pressed to find fault with anything on this menu, the Chef and staff do an unbelievable job at making and presenting the food. I highly recommend this establishment and the club if you are a fan of great Jazz Music! More

OpenTable Diner -