We come often, and really like everything! Usually I get the Hogfish, but this time I had the Filet and the toppings and it was outstanding. I'd give the filet a 10 and the sauce made if at 12~~!! My husband had the cobia and said it was also excellent. I always have the crab martini and he has the tartare.
I love the Boulevardier also!!
Usually we ask for Tom, but he was not there, so we had Tanner. We have had him before also, and he is a great server too. Very attentive and friendly and efficient!

Excellent food and excellent service.

As always, Mystic Fish never disappoints. The friendly welcome to our departure everyone is wonderful. Our server Tania is exceptional. She remembers our favorite bottle of wine. Our appetizers, salad and entree is always delicious. The atmosphere is warming

Our waiter was very helpful in us deciding what to get. I cannot have wheat and his suggestions were good. The Cesar salad was very fresh. Both of us had the grouper and it was delicious.

Delicious fresh entrees with excellent service. Always a great choice!

Stake was very tough, service was fine ,had a 100.00 gift card from a customer and couldn’t pay any part of the tip with it cannot understand that so was not a great experience for my wife and I.

Excellent food and service. Will be back.

Our favourite fine dining place in the area. Great Bermuda chowder and Ice-cream/gelato

OMG. The four of us all ordered something different and all dishes were Delicious . Our server was very helpful and good. We love dinning at Mystic Fish.

Mystic Fish is our "go-to" restaurant when we have out-of-town guests visiting with us. We've been going here for several years, and can honestly say that we've never had a disappointing meal there. The seafood is always fresh and expertly prepared. Their hogfish is wonderful, and not something commonly seen on restaurant menus. Never tried it? You need to fix that. Mystic Fish serves this delicate, moist white fish panko-crusted and pan-seared on a buerre blanc sauce.

Mystic Fish is the beat restaurant in the area.
Food terrific
Service excellent

Great food and service. We chose to sit outside due to covid but still a good experience.

No shortage of creativity in the kitchen, with fresh local seafood dishes and filet mignon cooked to perfection.
Baked oysters with leeks and Pecorino cheese breadcrumbs and crabmeat stuffing in artichokes, and inventive salads as well as a well done Caesar salad, are easy to complement from a good wine and cocktails list.
Great fish creations ( sea bass, grouper) and pasta dishes give you lots of choices. This makes you start plotting when you can come back to try something else on the menu.
We have enjoyed sidewalk dining three times. Reliably delicious food and intelligent helpful servers.

The food is amazing and never disappoints. Lobster tails melt in your mouth, Chilean Sea Bass is amazing and no one does mashed potatoes like they do. From appetizers to desserts this place is the bomb.

Perfection as always. Very consistent all around!

Great food and service this is a great restaurant

Great seafood and other unique options. Excellent service also!

Fantastic restaurant great service great food. What else could you ask for.

Great food great service

We have never been disappointed in Mystic Fish. We go there for every special occasion. Food is excellent, service is good.

The food was excellent! The outdoor seating is next to the parking lot, but we were happy there was any outdoor seating available, as we still are reluctant to eat indoors. They have tried to make it more like a patio and since the weather was perfect, the whole experience was very enjoyable. We were there a few weeks prior for a birthday celebration, outside, and it was just as good! This is our new favorite place in this area.

Food we ate, 1/2 rack of lamb, was delicious. Vegetable were fresh. We will definitely return.

Great food and service. Highly recommend. They were very accommodating and the menu had a lot of options. We ordered multiple small plates and tried a great variety.

We were seated promptly at 7:15. Jill came right over and said she would bring the water glasses. The order was taken and bread was brought to the table. Everyone enjoyed their chosen meals, from chicken to fish to paella! We will definitely be returning.

Fantastic! Would highly recommend!!! Can’t wait to go back and try some more fresh fish!

I'am never disappointed!! I always try something different and I'am always delighted with my entree.

Always perfect!!!

As always, Mystic Fish is a great experience. Everyone's fish was super fresh and perfectly cooked. Service from Cailee was outstanding.

Food was terrific as well as the service and atmosphere was great wonderful experience

This is the place! Quiet, comfortable, great service, and fantastic food each and every time we visit.

We have been to Mystic Fish many times and it is consistently great.

Amazing service and food every single time. Highly recommend.

Nice and interesting.

Mystic Fish is always a pleasure full experience. The food is outstanding. We love the early bird specials.

Spontaneous Date Night & although we booked the last spot available, not once did they make us feel rushed. We had tapas, cocktails & shots, both alcoholic & espresso, and everything was delicious! Service was great as always. We have been coming here for over 15 years and we are never disappointed. Thank you for a wonderful night 😊

Food and service were top notch. However, tables were too close together and all seats were filled. There was no social distancing. Employees were all wearing masks. Of course, customers are not wearing a mask while eating and drinking. That’s where space between tables becomes essential during the COVID pandemic. I look forward to returning once the pandemic is under control.

Always fabulous food and service!

Our waitress was excellent. Even though it was early dining, she did not rush us as it wasn’t terribly busy. Also, my friend lost her bracelet, we called when we got home, and the busboy had turned it in. Thank you!

the beet salad was the best I've had anywhere. It was a great pairing with the black grouper.

Did not disappoint