Mystic Fish

We loved our meal.
Only complaint... our salads were served right after our drinks arrived. I prefer a leisurely cocktail and then my dinner.
Next time I will mention my preference to the waiter.

Mystic Fish is our go to Date Night place tp eat. We love the quality of the food and service. Living in Tampa means we are 19 miles from the restaurant, but still make the trip whenever we can.

Boring night. Rushed and food was nothing special. Many places in the area that have better food more atmosphere!

Our food was great. Lobster tails were a real winner and the Caesar salads were chilled and attractively presented. Our server Tanya was lovely and excellent.
We look forward to returning!

This is possibly the most consistent restaurant in terms of quality service and environment in Palm Harbor Florida over the past 18 years. Although located in a plaza, once through the door the ambience is most pleasant. Food is of superior quality. Waitstaff well trained attentive and helpful. The menu has remained up to date and in fact innovative over these many years. This is our consistent go to restaurant for wonderful dining. Incidentally, the prices are more than fair.

Always Great

Great grouper and lobster tail dinners!

All was great

Food was great, we were 5 people and everyone had different dishes. Everybody was happy with their food. Highly recommend this restaurant.

As usual the experience was wonderful. Cocktails were just perfect. Oyster appetizers delighted us. Try the hogfish crusted in pablo, delicious. Our favorite.

Incredible food and service!

Wonderful food, service, and atmosphere. A perfect place to celebrate a special occasion or just to celebrate the day. Always great.

It was Fantastic. The service and the Food both outstanding. It was our first time there, we went for my Birthday. Cant wait to go again.

Dinner was terrific, service is always great. It was too cool in the dining room.

Always bring our out of town friends and relatives for excellent food and service.

Never disappointed

Always great service and great food. Always a favorite stop when i am in the Palm Harbor area.

Excellent, as always! Sometimes we forget how great this neighborhood classic is - then we are enchanted when we try it again. Wonderful seafood at moderate prices.

We went to Mystic Fish to celebrate my wife's birthday. We have been several times before and as always, we were treated to extraordinary food, atmosphere and service. My wife had the Kona seared scallops and I had the panko breaded hogfish and both were outstanding!

My FAVORITE RESTAURANT. I order the Hog Fish every time. Excellent.

Happy Hour wine good and nicely priced. Food very good, great variety, and moderately priced. Escargot and Paella both excellent.

Our visit to Mystic Fish was an experience that totally exceeded our expectations. We will be back!

Our waitress was very cordial and had a profound knowledge of the menu. She was very attentive and she had a constant killer smile.

I had an amazing dinner with my wife. From the moment we walked in to the moment we left everything was perfect. The food is delicious and that crab martini is the highlight of the meal. The drinks we ordered were perfectly made and the service is amazing. Can’t wait til I get a chance to come back.

Great food and great service. Would definitely go back again.

Always consistent, love the place

Always good

it is, and will always be my go to place in Palm Harbor.

Son was in town visiting and wanted something special

This is my favorite restaurant. The food is always superb, and beautifully displayed. Decor is pleasing to the eye. Early Dining is a very good value.

Since it is supposed to be a seafood focused restaurant one would hope they know he to prepare fish
I was wrong. Over cooked and not edible
Manager responded that’s too bad
I’ll not return

Always consistent food and service

Food was awesome, I would repeat my meal again.

Another great meal at Mystic Fish. One of our favorite restaurants.

We’ve been going here for well over 10 years. Food is always exceptional. Hands-down best restaurant in the Tampa Bay area.

A lovely atmosphere with delicious food. The service is always good. One of our favourite places to dine.

This has been one of my favorite restaurants since it first opened. Delicious food, great service, wonderful ambiance and very fairly priced. Who could ask for anything more?

Dining here is always a pleasure. Our server was extremely engaging and professional. The oysters were perfect and the hogfish snapper was excellent as usual. I had a terrific verbena whiskey sour. This is by far our favorite restaurant in the area.

Service is excellent, food is fabulous! Always consistent. Great restaurant!

Wonder experience. Food is great and the service was super. The early bird menu is awesome. The regular menu is awesome. Excellent.

Mystic Fish has been one of our absolute favorites for years. Never disappoints. We always take our out of town guests there.