Great food and service
I did not like this restaurant. The food used to be better. Salad was underdressed and we asked for anchovies that never came. The pasta dish was not flavorful. The service was inattentive. I will not eat here again.
Excellent food, service!
I love Matteo’s. The food quality, service and ambience was outstanding. I would highly recommend this restaurant
Food was great . The waiter Gustavo was superb!!
Didn’t want to go home!!
Micheal is a great waiter. Food very good.
I had been looking forward to going to Matteo's because we enjoy their Long Island restaurant however I was disappointed. We arrived at 6 pm on Saturday for our reservation eating earlier than we normally do because that was the only time remaining on Open Table. We were seated immediately, delivered menus and received a visit from our waiter asking if we wanted to order drinks and dinner. We ordered drinks and before we received them we were asked again if we knew what we wanted to order. Drinks arrived and before we could even sip- we were asked again what we wanted to order. After the 4th time we were asked we took the hint and ordered.
We got our salad and dinners within 15 minutes and we were out of there in 45 minutes. The entrees were good but the chopped salad had no taste and the wines were mediocre.
This restaurant is always busy and I'm sure no one will even notice our review- but it was such a disappointing night that it was important for me to share.
We love the food & service at Matteo's. If you are looking for the BEST server, request Ricky. He will always guide you with what to order and is so attentive!
Excellent service food and atmosphere
Very good restaurant nice place on patio nice place near home with friends
We have never been disappointed here. The service and the food excellent . Keep up the quality and you will always be our Italian dining experience of choice.
Service outstanding and best Italian restaurant experience in a very long time. Pasta cooked perfectly. Salad and bread was very good too!
italian prepared in the new york style. very authentic. alway enjoy.
I’m in Florida for 2 nights each month and visit Matteo’s once a trip.
Always worth it.
great food love this restaurant on Long Island too
It’s a great neighborhood Italian restaurant always consistently good
Wonderful as usual .Zack was out waiter and he treated us royally. Excellent food and The napoleon for dessert is a nyst
Excellent neighborhood restaurant. Authentic italian in every way. Willing to make specialties without confrontation. Service great. Food absolutely delicious. Will be frequenting this restaurant!
Last time I was there, I had the ravioli entree. This time it was tough and thick.
Other dishes ordered by my friends were good.
Waiter was preoccupied and not good. Service has been inconsistent. Some
waiters are much better than others.
It felt air conditioned, when it was quite cold outside.
Not an overall great experience this time, versus my last visit just a short week ago.
Inconsistent is the operative word.