The Diner Reviews are in: 100 Most Romantic Restaurants in America for 2023

Food is its own love language, but when it’s served in a cozy room or a candlelit booth? Guaranteed fireworks. For those looking for a quintessential Valentine’s Day dining experience, start with the most romantic restaurants across the US, created by analyzing over 13 million reviews.

OpenTable team

Select location:

Updated January 30, 2023

St. Elmo Steak House

Price: Expensive

Steak

Downtown Indy

4.8

19423 reviews

A classic old time steak house where the steak you eat is completely unreal! I had the ribeye which exquisite marbling made it melt in my mouth. Perfectly cooked and truly a culinary experience. Don't miss this vintage steakhouse on your next visit to downtown Indianapolis. Will definitely be back. :)

View Availability

The Cake Bake Shop - Carmel City Center

Price: Expensive

American

Carmel / Westfield

4.8

4451 reviews

We expected the desserts to be delicious but we’re delighted that all the food was excellent. The decorations for the holidays were exquisite.

View Availability