Restaurants near Port Jefferson Railroad Station

Outstanding dinner and exceptional if you require a gluten free menu

The food was delicious, the service was great and the value was good. My only problem was the slowing a dog to sit at the bar. I get that people are allowed service dogs, but this dog did not act like one. It was making noises and I chose to take the rest of meal home to eat in peace. This is not the restaurant’s fault it’s people taking advantage of rules meant to help the disabled.

this was our third time there for dinner over the past 2 weeks each time was excellent. Food did not disappoint and our server Lauren was stellar. Lauren was our server last week and she remembered us and details as to what we preferred. Castaway has become our new local go to place!

For over 25 years, this restaurant has been our go-to spot, and it never disappoints. Last night was extra special, as we celebrated our 25th wedding anniversary at the same place where we shared our first dinner as a couple. The food, service, and atmosphere remain just as perfect as they were all those years ago. It's more than a restaurant to us – it's a place filled with memories, and they continue to create new ones every time we visit. Here's to many more years of wonderful meals and cherished moments!

Very good food…great views of the water….service was very good…we really enjoyed it…was like a mini vacation