28 Restaurants Near Charlotte Amalie Historic District

28 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Caribbean Fish Market restaurant

1. Caribbean Fish Market

4.6

Exceptional(1285)

$$$$

• Seafood • St Thomas

Booked 22 times today

Food was delicious. The sea bass was great and I was surprised by how good the polenta was as I am not usually a fan. The pear and Brie pizza was tasty. We tried the stuffed Caribbean lobster which was good but there were no claws. Great view and the staff was attentive.

2. Sunset Grille

4.6

Exceptional(831)

$$$$

• Steakhouse • St Thomas

The food and ambiance was amazing. The service was ver slow and the server never came to check if we needed anything

3. Pesce Italian

4.7

Exceptional(818)

$$$$

• Italian • St Thomas

25th anniversary dinner last night.From the your first step in the door you won’t be disappointed.Great service and food was outstanding to say the least.Thanks again for making our night special

4. Ocean 362

4.5

Awesome(225)

$$$$

• Contemporary American • St. John

Booked 13 times today

Great location, food and atmosphere! I’ve never had a bad experience here. Thank you!

A photo of Mirador by Chef Benny restaurant

5. Mirador by Chef Benny

4.4

Awesome(386)

$$$$

• American • St Thomas

Booked 6 times today

Both servers were super helpful and friendly. We had both dinner and Brunch there and it was really good. I had the glazed salmon and it was very deicious. I also had the veggie omelet at Brunch and it was really good.

6. Agave

4.6

Exceptional(312)

$$$$

• Contemporary Mexican • St Thomas

The food was outstanding, the servers were friendly and the ambiance was fun! Great little gem!

A photo of Hook Line & Sinker restaurant

7. Hook Line & Sinker

3.7

Very Good(133)

$$$$

• Seafood • St Thomas

Booked 3 times today

We initially were the only ones there and that set off alarms. However the food we ordered was good. My son got the shrimp scampi, I had the mussels, and my mom got the ribs. All was tasty. The interior was nicely styled, but nothing special. Our server was attentive. You really couldn’t see the small marina that it was dark. The print place could probably take better advantage of its location. Plus we had workers drilling on the awnings while we were there.

8. Blue 11

4.8

Exceptional(193)

$$$$

• Caribbean • St Thomas

Booked 7 times today

Amazing experience! The food was impeccable. The service was above and beyond. Loved our time there and would highly recommend!

9. 3 Palms

4.6

Exceptional(404)

$$$$

• Contemporary French / American • St Thomas

Booked 27 times today

First I should mention that Scott, our waiter was great, very accommodatingand funny. Lobster dumplings were very delightful, we liked the octopus and mussels too. The Cod main course was delicious!! Would recommend.