Restaurants near Anastasia Island Cottage by Vacation Rental Pros

Love the place and we go there every time we come to St Augustine. It has the feeling of a “locals hangout”, with a really great vibe and high end atmosphere, without breaking the bank. Service is always great and the cocktails are top!

The Columbia Restaurant is just delicious! You have to order a pitcher of table-made mojitos or sangria! An absolute must!! The Cuban bread has just the right crunch and is delicious. The 1905 salad is so flavorful and they make it right at your table. You can order it as a side salad or as your entree with turkey or shrimp. The chicken dishes and steak dishes are absolutely wonderful. Palomilla is a Cuban steak dish with the best flavor ever! If you don’t eat onion, then maybe pass on it though! Pollo Manchego is chicken breast coated with Cuban bread crumbs and manchego cheese as well as a citrusy sauce, sun dried tomatoes and fresh basil. For Tapas, the Stuffed Piquillo Peppers and the Empanadas are my favorites. The Cuban sandwich is also very good! The service is always attentive and the restaurant is just beautiful!

Very good service and food. Good family place for kids too.

ALL GOOD, not crowed and quick service, food specials offered and we accepted the beef short ribs and the pork chop Melanese and the special salad of melon prosciutto which was really good. The servings were generous and we each had a take home box to enjoy again! We will be back again no doubt, keep up the good work! Marie was our server and she was special, thanks again!

We began our Thanksgiving dinner with the crab cakes, which arrived hot and contained plenty of crab meat; I'll definitely order them again. For dinner, my husband had the turkey dinner platter with all the fixings, while I ordered the filet mignon with fingerling potatoes, which was delicious! Highly recommend this restaurant.