Johnny's Italian Steakhouse - Middleton

It was not busy, and we sat in a comfortable booth. Our server was polite and attentive. Everything was delicious

Johnny's Italian Steakhouse is a celebration favorite. Very predictably great.
I really like the food and service. I appreciate that we can have a conversation without shouting over music or other noises.

Had a wonderful dinner with our granddaughter and her boyfriend. Service and food were very good as usual. Our server seemed to disappear at times but we weren’t in a hurry so ok. She needs som training.

A Classy treat for us! The music and atmosphere is our favorite. We went for brunch this time. The warm cinnamon rolls, prime rib, eggs benedict, sausages, were my favorite, but I loved the nice selection and variety of the food - everything one would expect from Johnny's.

Went to Johnnys for our anniversary dinner. Have been before and it’s always great! This time my steak came out too rare and I had to ask for it to be cooked a little more, but it was perfect after that. My boyfriend’s steak was perfectly cooked. The Parmesan crust on the filet was outstanding. Great ambience, private booth so we could talk, and good service. We’ll be back!

The food was excellent after fixing my order.
We did state it was for our anniversary when we reserved, and nothing special was done for it.
Most restaurants would either decorate the table or offer a dessert on the house. So needless to say were disappointed by this.

Love this place. Awesome food, good service and Frank Sinatra Music. Dinner with friends didn’t disappoint. We started with two orders of crab cakes (1 cake per order). The cakes are large enough to share and very good. The men had lobster bisque and I’m told it’s the best in Madison. The ladies ordered Caesar salad. Also very good. We all ordered steaks which come with a choice of, potatoes, veggies or pasta Marinara. The filet Oscar comes with asparagus also. I ordered the steak Deburgo. Two small tenderloin medallions perfectly rare as ordered in a herb cream sauce with a side of garlic mashed potatoes. Excellent! Unfortunately we didn’t save room for dessert. Maybe next time.

Excellent food and service!!! We enjoyed sitting outside and had excellent service by Mitchell.

Had to get our own drinks Bartender on duty did not come from behind the bar to take our order - twice, I wasn't sure if I should have even left her a tip. Other than that Excellent dining room service and food.

Excellent lunch specials! Attentive waiter.

Outstangkng. Maybe the best dinnung experience I've ever had.

Had a first date there, the staff was amazing! They came over and were friendly and kind. Food was amazing and definitely am going back! Can’t say I got a second date but couldn’t ask for a better place!

We were treated like we were rock stars. Will always go back

Server was not friendly. I had food sensitivities and when requested if the chef could accommodate me she quoted me that the restaurant was franchised and can’t honor those requests. So, after my date received his food, she was kind enough to have brought me a plain side salad.

Everyone was very nice. There were 5 of us and the ladies all enjoyed our food very much however the 2 men both had your steak and stuffed shrimp dish and neither liked it. They thought the stuffing was pasty & weird and both said their steaks were tough and had an overkill of garlic. It was mentioned to staff and they offered dessert to compensate. Both men generally don't hesitate to express their opinions about anything but this time they didn't and they should have earlier in the meal and not at the end. My point is I just wanted you to know that at least this group didn't care for your steak & shrimp combo dinner.
Linda

Great food, waitress was awesome!

The food was very good but we were terribly rushed. It would have been much nicer if we had been given time to enjoy everything.

All of the food was good, but nothing blew me away. Had the Seafood Rockefeller. Restaurant was relatively quiet for a Saturday night. Really liked that they had a regular and a light portion for most of the appetizers.

Steaks were perfectly cooked to all parties preferences. Perfect timing on service. Food came out together and was hot. One of the last upscale diners in town. Will return.

Tried this steakhouse after reading the reviews. The stuffed mushrooms were to excellent, and the spinach salad with the warm bacon dressing was worth the up charge. steak made my day. Risotto along with the steak was worth enduring the cold weather to get together. Please understand I am from Fort Lauderdale, Florida.
Enjoyed my dinner so much that I have plans to return this week before I return to Florida. The service is terrific which made the experience so much more delightful.

This is a great deal. For $18 you get an amazing variety of food at the brunch, including some higher-end items like prime rib. I'd guess it's at least $40 worth, for less than half that price. And all of it is great-tasting. This is my 2nd time and I will definitely be back!

Our reservation was at 6:45, but we were seated as soon as we go there (which was a little early). The waitress was very nice and efficient. Our food came in a timely manner and it was very good! I would visit this restaurant again when I’m in the area.

Our 45th Wedding Anniversary. The menu is very complete and the meals that we had were extremely good. The Veal Sinatra with shrimp was hot and very tasty. The Crab Stuffed Shrimp was the same. We had plenty, so we had some left to enjoy the next day. Waitstaff was OK...not overbearing, but had their hands full with customers so not as attentive as I had hoped. We had the only table that the lighting was overly lit-the others had lower watt bulbs that added to the ambiance. Other than that, it was an enjoyable experience.

Daughters college graduation

Food was amazing! It came highly recommended, so I took a couple of friends who were all in town and we were made to feel like we were an inconvenience to our server. We had reservations in case it was busy, he took our order and he didn't come back until we paid for our bill (which he didn't even give us, a gal did since she saw us waiting. ) We even had to get up to grab a pitcher of water that was sitting on the bar to fill our glasses. Will not likely return because service is a bigger deal to me than the food. We had high hopes since our many friends suggested we eat there while in town.

A booth in the bar, dinner with friends on a slow Friday night. Dinner was very good. Tenderloin, nicely charred and fork tender. Main course — prime rib, (rare as ordered), unexpectedly served without au jus and overly salted, as were the garlic mashed potatoes. Appetizer — Crab cake (pricey at $13.00 for one medium sized cake). Dessert — excellent cheesecake and creme brûlée.

We are regulars and used to excellent attentive service. It was off tonight. We all commented on it. Maybe it was the little details that matter most. We had to ask for water, soup spoons, bread, and make our own dipping oil. Maybe it was because, instead of our waitress, it was the bussers and other wait-staff that passed by who attended to us. I cannot put a finger on it, but we all agreed we’ve had better service at less expensive restaurants.

Normally my favorite place, but for mother’s day you pay twice as much for the same buffet except they added shrimp and they take away bottomless mimosas for moms very disappointing

I came here with my parents and boyfriend after graduation and it was a great place to eat! Both my mom and I are gluten and dairy free and they were very accommodating when we asked. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for a nice meal.

Tasty food, server was attentive.....but it took a long time for food to arrive. Plan on being away from the office for two hours, and don't arrive too hungry!

Food was decent, service was terrible. Too many other excellent choices in the area to ruin a night here.

Our group appreciated the food, service and atmosphere at Johnny's Italian Steakhouse. The noise level was quiet to moderate so it allowed for good conversation. Thank you!

Food was just okay and our waiter seemed disinterested in helping us.

Easter Brunch, very busy, but delicious food!! Bit pricey for a brunch, but again, very high quality dishes.

We enjoyed our dinner. Our steaks were cooked just the way we ordered them

Unbelievable food and service!!! Can't wait to go back!!

Good was ok. Service has horrible. No water for the table. Had to ask him for refill on ice tea. Had to ask him for sugar. Never asked if we wanted anything just brought us our check.

The food is always top notch and the service is great!

Damon our waiter was amazing - very helpful and informative in our choices as well as when meal would be ready. Respectful and professional! All food choices were perfect- delicious! Will certainly return!

Our server was not very interested in our table. We waited a long time to order and receive drinks. Two people at our table commented that their food was served cold. Not the usual quality of service and no checkin by a manager. Would have rated this lower but we have eaten there before and it has been much better. Guess we write this off as one bad dinner but will not return if it happens again.

Great service and food, a remarkable experience will be back!